Prediction performance after learning in Gaussian process regression

Johan Wågberg, Dave Zachariah, Thomas B. Schön, Petre Stoica

Abstract

This paper considers the quantification of the prediction performance in Gaussian process regression. The standard approach is to base the prediction error bars on the theoretical predictive variance, which is a lower bound on the mean square-error (MSE). This approach, however, does not take into account that the statistical model is learned from the data. We show that this omission leads to a systematic underestimation of the prediction errors. Starting from a generalization of the Cramér-Rao bound, we derive a more accurate MSE bound which provides a measure of uncertainty for prediction of Gaussian processes. The improved bound is easily computed and we illustrate it using synthetic and real data examples.

Introduction

Gaussian Process (GP) regression is a cornerstone of modern machine learning, prized for its ability to provide not just point predictions but also a measure of uncertainty. These "error bars," or predictive variances, are essential for decision-making in fields ranging from robotics to Bayesian optimization. However, a critical flaw exists in the standard implementation: it assumes that model hyperparameters—such as length-scales and noise levels—are known exactly. In practice, these parameters are estimated from finite data, a process that introduces its own uncertainty.

The Problem: Overconfident Error Bars

When we learn a model from data, the resulting predictions are sensitive to the specific values of the estimated hyperparameters. Standard GP theory ignores this sensitivity, treating the learned parameters as ground truth. This leads to a systematic underestimation of the true Mean Square Error (MSE), resulting in overconfident predictions, particularly when data is sparse or when extrapolating far from training points.

Comparison of the standard prediction region versus the HCRB region. Note how the HCRB region expands significantly more during extrapolation, reflecting the true uncertainty of the learned model.

As shown in the figure above, the "Standard region" (light grey) remains relatively narrow even as we move away from the data points ($x > 1$). In contrast, the "HCRB region" (dark grey) grows much faster, providing a more realistic assessment of the risk involved in extrapolation.

The Solution: Hybrid Cramér-Rao Bound (HCRB)

To address this, the authors derive a new lower bound on the MSE by applying the Hybrid Cramér-Rao Bound. Unlike the standard Cramér-Rao bound, the HCRB can handle a mix of random variables (the latent function $f$) and deterministic parameters (the hyperparameters $\theta$).

The derived bound takes the form: $$MSE(\hat{f}_*) \ge \sigma^2_{*|y} + \mathbf{g}^T \mathbf{M}^{-1} \mathbf{g}$$

Here, $\sigma^2_{*|y}$ is the standard predictive variance. The second term, $\mathbf{g}^T \mathbf{M}^{-1} \mathbf{g}$, acts as a correction factor. It depends on the sensitivity of the prediction to the hyperparameters ($\mathbf{g}$) and the information available about those parameters ($\mathbf{M}$). This formulation is computationally efficient, requiring only gradients of the mean function rather than expensive sampling methods like MCMC.

Quantitative comparison of various MSE bounds. The HCRB (red) provides a much tighter lower bound to the true error than the standard predictive variance (blue).

Results and Validation

The authors validated the HCRB using both synthetic simulations and real-world atmospheric $CO_2$ data from Mauna Loa.

  1. Synthetic Experiments: Across various mean functions (constant, linear, sinusoidal), the HCRB consistently provided a tighter bound on the empirical MSE compared to the standard variance.
  2. Real-World Extrapolation: In the Mauna Loa dataset, the standard GP error bars failed to contain several future observations at a 99.7% confidence level. The HCRB-adjusted error bars, however, successfully covered these points, demonstrating its practical utility for long-term forecasting.

Conclusion

Accounting for the uncertainty introduced during the learning phase is vital for reliable GP regression. The HCRB provides a mathematically rigorous yet computationally efficient way to correct the overconfidence of standard error bars. By providing more realistic uncertainty estimates, this method enhances the safety and reliability of GPs in critical applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper considers the quantification of the prediction performance in Gaussian process regression. The standard approach is to base the prediction error bars on the theoretical predictive variance, which is a lower bound on the mean square-error (MSE). This approach, however, does not take into account that the statistical model is learned from the data. We show that this omission leads to a systematic underestimation of the prediction errors. Starting from a generalization of the Cramér-Rao bound, we derive a more accurate MSE bound which provides a measure of uncertainty for prediction of Gaussian processes. The improved bound is easily computed and we illustrate it using synthetic and real data examples. of uncertainty for prediction of Gaussian processes and illustrate it using synthetic and real data examples.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wagberg2017prediction,
  author = {Johan Wågberg and Dave Zachariah and Thomas B. Schön and Petre Stoica},
  title = {{Prediction performance after learning in Gaussian process regression}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=TknQ6Mok-0},
}
Figure