Predicting the Curie temperature in substitutionally disordered alloys using a first-principles based model

Marian Arale Brännvall, Rickard Armiento, Björn Alling

Abstract

When exploring new magnetic materials, the effect of alloying plays a crucial role for numerous properties. By altering the alloy composition, it is possible to tailor, e.g., the Curie temperature ($T_\text{C}$). In this work, $T_\text{C}$ of various alloys is investigated using a previously developed technique [Brännvall et al. Phys. Rev. Mat. (2024)] designed for robust predictions of $T_\text{C}$ across diverse chemistries and structures. The technique is based on density functional theory calculations and utilizes the energy difference between the magnetic ground state and the magnetically disordered paramagnetic state. It also accounts for the magnetic entropy in the paramagnetic state and the number of nearest magnetic neighbors. The experimentally known systems, Fe$_{1-x}$Co$_x$, Fe$_{1-x}$Cr$_x$, Fe$_{1-x}$V$_x$, NiMnSb-based Heusler alloys, Ti$_{1-x}$Cr$_x$N, and Co$_{1-x}$Al$_x$ are investigated. The experimentally unexplored system Fe$_{1-x}$Tc$_x$ is also tested to demonstrate the usefulness of the developed method in guiding future experimental efforts. This work demonstrates the broad applicability of the developed method across various systems, requiring less hands-on adjustments compared to other theoretical approaches.

Introduction

The Curie temperature ($T_C$)— the threshold at which a material transitions from a permanent magnet to a paramagnetic state—is a critical parameter for magnetic applications ranging from data storage to energy conversion. In modern materials science, the design of high-performance magnets often involves complex alloying, where multiple elements are substituted to fine-tune properties. However, predicting how these compositional changes affect $T_C$ remains a significant challenge.

Experimental discovery is inherently slow and resource-intensive. On the theoretical side, researchers typically face a trade-off between high-fidelity Heisenberg models, which require intensive manual effort to map exchange interactions, and "black-box" machine learning (ML) models. While fast, ML often struggles to capture the continuous physical variations and sharp "kinks" in $T_C$ curves caused by structural phase transitions. This paper presents a robust, physics-based approach that bridges this gap, offering a scalable yet fundamentally grounded method for high-throughput screening.

Methodology: Bridging DFT and Statistical Mechanics

The authors utilize a model that defines $T_C$ using three primary physical quantities derived from Density Functional Theory (DFT):

  • $\Delta E$ (Energy Difference): The energy gap between the magnetic ground state (ordered) and the paramagnetic state (disordered).
  • $S^{mag}$ (Magnetic Entropy): A measure of the disorder in the paramagnetic state.
  • $NN$ (Nearest Neighbors): The number of nearest magnetic neighbors.

To simulate disordered alloys, the researchers employed Special Quasirandom Structures (SQS) to represent random atomic distributions within periodic cells. The paramagnetic state was modeled using Disordered Local Moments (DLM), which constrains magnetic moments in random directions. A key innovation in this model is the inclusion of a correction factor $(1 - B/NN^C)$ to account for Short-Range Order (SRO). This is vital because as a magnet is diluted with non-magnetic atoms, the local environment changes in ways that simple mean-field theories often overlook.

Validation Across Diverse Systems

The model was rigorously benchmarked against several experimentally known substitutional random alloy systems, including iron-based binaries, Heusler alloys, and nitrides.

Curie temperature predictions for various alloy systems compared to experimental data.

As shown in Figure 1, the model successfully captures complex trends across different material classes. In the Fe-Co system, it accurately tracks the $T_C$ peak in the bcc region and shows excellent agreement in the cobalt-rich fcc region (with errors less than 60 K). For Heusler alloys like $Ni_xMnSb$, the predictions closely follow experimental values, only deviating at high nickel concentrations where structural disorder becomes more pronounced. The model also correctly predicts the "dilution effect," where adding non-magnetic elements like Aluminum or Copper lowers $T_C$ by reducing the number of magnetic neighbors, effectively weakening the "magnetic glue" holding the spins in alignment.

Guiding Experimental Efforts: The Fe-Tc Case Study

To demonstrate the model's utility in guiding future experimental work, the authors performed a "blind" prediction for the $Fe_{1-x}Tc_x$ system. Technetium is radioactive, making it difficult to characterize in a laboratory setting.

Predicted Curie temperature for the experimentally unexplored Fe-Tc system.

As illustrated in Figure 4, the model predicts that adding Technetium to Iron will steadily decrease $T_C$, behaving similarly to other transition metals like Molybdenum or Ruthenium. This provides a valuable theoretical baseline for researchers interested in the magnetic properties of rare or hazardous alloy systems.

Limitations and Future Directions

While broadly applicable, the model has specific limitations. It performs best on "local" magnets where spins are tied to specific atoms. It struggles with highly "itinerant" magnets, such as the $Co-Al$ system, where the magnitude of the magnetic moments changes significantly between ordered and disordered states.

Furthermore, the model has a mathematical lower limit of 124 K, which prevents its use for cryogenic magnetic materials. This floor led to an overestimation of $T_C$ for the $Ti_{1-x}Cr_xN$ system. Future work will focus on refining the model to account for variations in magnetic moment magnitude and developing correction terms to better handle the low-$T_C$ regime.

Summary updated

Abstract

When exploring new magnetic materials, the effect of alloying plays a crucial role for numerous properties. By altering the alloy composition, it is possible to tailor, e.g., the Curie temperature ($T_\text{C}$). In this work, $T_\text{C}$ of various alloys is investigated using a previously developed technique [Brännvall et al. Phys. Rev. Mat. (2024)] designed for robust predictions of $T_\text{C}$ across diverse chemistries and structures. The technique is based on density functional theory calculations and utilizes the energy difference between the magnetic ground state and the magnetically disordered paramagnetic state. It also accounts for the magnetic entropy in the paramagnetic state and the number of nearest magnetic neighbors. The experimentally known systems, Fe$_{1-x}$Co$_x$, Fe$_{1-x}$Cr$_x$, Fe$_{1-x}$V$_x$, NiMnSb-based Heusler alloys, Ti$_{1-x}$Cr$_x$N, and Co$_{1-x}$Al$_x$ are investigated. The experimentally unexplored system Fe$_{1-x}$Tc$_x$ is also tested to demonstrate the usefulness of the developed method in guiding future experimental efforts. This work demonstrates the broad applicability of the developed method across various systems, requiring less hands-on adjustments compared to other theoretical approaches.
BibTeX
@article{brannvall2025predicting,
  author = {Marian Arale Brännvall and Rickard Armiento and Björn Alling},
  title = {{Predicting the Curie temperature in substitutionally disordered alloys using a first-principles based model}},
  journal = {Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jmmm.2025.173361},
}
Figure