Precision Inclusive Higgs Physics at $e^+e^-$ Colliders With Tracking\n Detectors and Without Calorimetry

Patrick Draper, Jonathan Kozaczuk, Scott Thomas

Abstract

A primary goal of a future $e^+e^-$ collider program will be the precision measurement of Higgs boson properties. For practical reasons, it is of interest to determine the minimal set of detector specifications required to reach this and other scientific goals. We investigate the precision obtainable for the $e^+ e^- \rightarrow Z h \rightarrow \mu^+ \mu^- X$ inclusive cross section and the Higgs boson mass using the di-muon recoil method, considering a detector that has only an inner tracking system within a solenoidal magnetic field, surrounded by shielding and an outer muon identification system. We find that the sensitivity achievable with such a tracking detector is only marginally reduced compared to that expected for a general-purpose detector with additional electromagnetic and hadronic calorimeter systems.

Introduction

Future $e^+e^-$ colliders, such as the ILC, CEPC, or FCC-ee, are envisioned as "Higgs Factories" designed to probe the Higgs sector with unprecedented precision. However, the immense cost and complexity of full-scale detectors pose significant challenges. This research explores whether a simplified, lower-cost detector configuration—omitting expensive calorimetry—could still fulfill the primary scientific objectives of a Higgs factory.

Rethinking Detector Design

Standard particle detectors are composed of multiple layers, including electromagnetic (ECAL) and hadronic (HCAL) calorimeters designed to measure particle energy by stopping them. This study proposes a "tracker-only" approach, where the calorimeters are replaced by inert shielding material.

Schematic comparison of a general-purpose detector (left) and the proposed tracker-only detector (right).

As shown in Figure 1, the minimalist design retains the inner tracker and the outer muon system but removes the bulky calorimetry layers. The central question is whether the loss of energy information from the calorimeters significantly degrades the precision of Higgs measurements.

The Di-Muon Recoil Method

The study focuses on the $e^+e^- \to Zh$ production process, specifically where the $Z$ boson decays into two muons ($\mu^+\mu^-$). Because the initial state of the $e^+e^-$ collision is well-defined, measuring the momenta of the two muons with high precision allows for the calculation of the "recoil mass" ($m_{\text{reco}}$). This value corresponds to the mass of the Higgs boson, regardless of how the Higgs itself decays. Since trackers are exceptionally good at measuring muon momenta, the recoil method is naturally suited for a tracker-based system.

Comparative Performance and Results

Using simulated datasets generated with Whizard 2 and Pythia 6, the researchers compared the performance of the tracker-only setup against a full "Tracker + ECAL" configuration. The results demonstrate that the recoil mass peak remains remarkably clear even without calorimetry.

Comparison of the reconstructed recoil mass ($m_{\text{reco}}$) for the tracker-only setup (left) and the tracker + ECAL setup (right).

As illustrated in Figure 6, the signal peak (teal) for $Zh$ production is clearly visible above the background in both scenarios. The primary difference lies in the background rejection; without an ECAL, it is harder to veto events involving Initial State Radiation (ISR) photons. Quantitatively, the precision loss is minimal:

  • Cross-section ($\sigma_{Zh}$) Precision: 5.9% for tracker-only vs. 4.9% for full calorimetry (at $200\text{ fb}^{-1}$).
  • Higgs Mass ($m_h$) Precision: 56 MeV for tracker-only vs. 47 MeV for full calorimetry.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The study concludes that a tracker-only detector is a viable candidate for a staged or lower-cost approach to a future $e^+e^-$ collider. While calorimetry remains essential for studying specific "exclusive" Higgs decays (like $H \to \gamma\gamma$), the core inclusive measurements of mass and cross-section are surprisingly robust. Future work may explore adding a thin photon veto layer to mitigate the ISR background at a fraction of the cost of a full calorimeter system.

Summary updated

Abstract

A primary goal of a future $e^+e^-$ collider program will be the precision\nmeasurement of Higgs boson properties. For practical reasons it is of interest\nto determine the minimal set of detector specifications required to reach this\nand other scientific goals. Such information could be useful in developing a\nstaged approach to the full collider project with an initial lower-cost version\nfocused on achieving some of the primary scientific objectives. Here we\ninvestigate the precision obtainable for the $e^+ e^- \\rightarrow Z h\n\\rightarrow \\mu^+ \\mu^- X$ inclusive cross section and the Higgs boson mass\nusing the di-muon recoil method, considering a detector that has only an inner\ntracking system within a solenoidal magnetic field, surrounded by many nuclear\ninteraction lengths of absorbing material, and an outer muon identification\nsystem. We find that the sensitivity achievable in these measurements with such\na tracking detector is only marginally reduced compared to that expected for a\ngeneral purpose detector with additional electromagnetic and hadronic\ncalorimeter systems. The difference results mainly from multi-photon\nbackgrounds that are not as easily rejected with tracking detectors. We also\ncomment on the prospects for an analogous measurement of the inclusive cross\nsection $\\sigma( e^+ e^- \\to Z h \\to e^+ e^- X)$. Finally, we study searches\nfor light scalars utilizing the di-muon recoil method, estimating the projected\nreach with a tracking and general purpose detector.\n
BibTeX
@article{draper2020precision,
  author = {Patrick Draper and Jonathan Kozaczuk and Scott Thomas},
  title = {{Precision Inclusive Higgs Physics at $e^+e^-$ Colliders With Tracking\textbackslash\{\}n Detectors and Without Calorimetry}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep09(2020)174},
}

Loading related content...

Figure