Precise structure and polarization determination of Hf0.5Zr0.5O2 with electron ptychography

Xiaoyue Gao, Zhuohui Liu, Bo Han, Xiaowen Zhang, R. Le Van Mao, Ruochen Shi, Ruixue Zhu, Jiangbo Lu, Tao Wang, Ge Chen, Peng Gao

Abstract

Hafnium Zirconium Oxide ($Hf_{0.5}Zr_{0.5}O_2$, or HZO) is a leading candidate for next-generation ferroelectric memories and transistors due to its scalability and CMOS compatibility. However, the physical origin of its ferroelectricity has remained a subject of debate because of the material's complex phase transitions and nanoscopic microstructure. This study utilizes multislice electron ptychography to investigate the atomic structure of substrate-free HZO freestanding films. With an ultra-high spatial resolution of approximately 25 pm, we simultaneously image cations and oxygen atoms, allowing for the precise determination of intrinsic atomic structures across different phases. Our findings confirm that the orthorhombic phase is the source of ferroelectricity, with a measured spontaneous polarization of $34 \pm 4$ µC/cm². Furthermore, we identify significant polarization suppression at grain boundaries and reveal the preferential distribution of oxygen vacancies, providing a fundamental framework for the design of high-performance ferroelectric devices.

Introduction

Hafnium-based ferroelectrics have revolutionized the field of non-volatile memory because they maintain ferroelectric properties at thicknesses below 10 nm and integrate seamlessly with standard silicon manufacturing. Despite this potential, HZO is a "shapeshifter," often existing as a mixture of orthorhombic, monoclinic, and tetragonal phases within tiny grains.

Traditional Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM) faces two primary hurdles in resolving HZO's secrets: it lacks the sensitivity to clearly image light oxygen atoms—which are critical to polarization—and the presence of a substrate often introduces "clamping" effects that distort the material's intrinsic properties. This research overcomes these barriers by combining freestanding film synthesis with cutting-edge electron ptychography.

Methodology

To isolate the intrinsic properties of HZO, the researchers synthesized 5-nm-thick films and subsequently released them from their growth substrates. These freestanding films were then analyzed using Multislice Electron Ptychography (MEP).

MEP is a computational imaging technique that processes 4D-STEM data (a full diffraction pattern captured at every scan position). While standard STEM resolution typically bottoms out around 60 picometers (pm), MEP pushed the resolution limit to a staggering ~25 pm. This sensitivity allowed the team to map the positions of both heavy metal cations (Hf/Zr) and light oxygen atoms simultaneously. To ensure statistical rigor, the team employed deep learning tools (AtomAI) and Atomap to analyze thousands of atomic positions and displacements.

Key Insights and Results

Confirmation of the Ferroelectric Phase

The study provides a "smoking gun" for HZO's ferroelectricity by confirming the dominance of the orthorhombic phase ($Pca2_1$). By measuring the precise displacement of atoms, the team calculated an average atomic displacement of $56 \pm 6$ pm. This corresponds to an intrinsic spontaneous polarization of $34 \pm 4$ µC/cm², a value that aligns with theoretical predictions but is often obscured in bulk or clamped samples.

The Role of Oxygen Vacancies

For the first time, oxygen vacancies ($V_O$) were directly imaged along the [111] zone axis. The data revealed that these vacancies are not distributed randomly; instead, they exhibit a preferential distribution. This non-random arrangement likely plays a critical role in stabilizing the ferroelectric orthorhombic phase and may even enhance the material's polarization strength.

Boundary and Interface Effects

The research highlights a stark difference between internal domain walls and grain boundaries:

  • 180° Ferroelectric Domain Walls: These boundaries showed no distinguishable structural changes or distortions, suggesting they do not inherently degrade polarization.
  • Grain Boundaries: In contrast, grain boundaries acted as "dead zones," where polarization was suppressed by approximately 23% across the first 3 to 4 atomic layers. This finding explains why polycrystalline HZO films often exhibit lower performance than their single-crystal counterparts.

Conclusion

By achieving sub-angstrom resolution through electron ptychography, this study clarifies the structural origins of ferroelectricity in HZO. The direct observation of oxygen vacancy ordering and the quantification of grain boundary degradation provide a roadmap for "defect engineering." Future development of HZO-based devices will likely focus on controlling these oxygen vacancy distributions and minimizing grain boundary interference to maximize the efficiency and speed of next-generation ferroelectric memories.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hf0.5Zr0.5O2 (HZO) is a promising candidate for next generation ferroelectric memories and transistors. However, its ferroelectricity origin is still under debate due to the complex of its phase and microstructure in practical samples. In this study, we investigate the atomic structure of substrate-free HZO freestanding film with multislice electron ptychography, for which the ultra-high space resolution (up to ~25 pm) and capability to simultaneously image the cation and oxygen allow us to precisely determine the intrinsic atomic structures of different phases and reveal subtle changes among them. We clarify that the orthorhombic phase is ferroelectric with spontaneous polarization ~34{\pm}4 μC/cm2 (corresponding to 56{\pm}6 pm in displacement) that is accurately measured through statistical analysis. Significant polarization suppression is observed near the grain boundary, while no distinguishable structural changes are detected near the 180° ferroelectric domain walls. Through the direct oxygen imaging of orthorhombic phase from the [111] zone axis, we quantify a substantial number of oxygen vacancies with a preferential distribution, which influences the polarization direction and strength. These findings provide fundamentals for HZO research, and thus lay a foundation for the design of high-performance ferroelectric devices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2026precise,
  author = {Xiaoyue Gao and Zhuohui Liu and Bo Han and Xiaowen Zhang and R. Le Van Mao and Ruochen Shi and Ruixue Zhu and Jiangbo Lu and Tao Wang and Ge Chen and Peng Gao},
  title = {{Precise structure and polarization determination of Hf0.5Zr0.5O2 with electron ptychography}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-026-69514-w},
}
Figure