Power allocation and cooperative diversity in two-way non-regenerative cognitive radio networks

Saeed Vahidian, Maryam Najafi, Marzieh Najafi, Fawaz S. Al-Qahtani

This paper, titled "Power Allocation and Cooperative Diversity in Two-Way Non-Regenerative Cognitive Radio Networks," explores how to squeeze more efficiency out of wireless spectrum by allowing secondary users to "borrow" frequencies from primary users while using smart relaying techniques to maintain signal quality.

TL;DR

The authors derive new, precise mathematical formulas to predict the performance of two-way cognitive radio networks operating over complex fading environments (Nakagami-$m$). By modeling how secondary users can cooperate via relays without disrupting the primary network, they provide a framework for optimizing power allocation and minimizing signal errors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless spectrum is a finite and crowded resource. Cognitive Radio (CR) is a solution where "Secondary Users" (SUs) utilize the frequency bands of "Primary Users" (PUs) as long as they don't cause too much interference.

Most existing research on this topic assumes simple "Rayleigh fading" (a basic model for signal bouncing) or one-way communication. However, real-world signals often face more complex fading, and two-way communication (where two nodes exchange data simultaneously via a relay) is much more spectrally efficient.

The challenge lies in the math: when you combine two-way relaying, interference from the primary network, and the requirement to protect the primary user's signal, calculating the Outage Capacity (OC) and Average Symbol Error Probability (ASEP) becomes incredibly difficult. This paper aims to provide those missing analytical tools.

Methods

The researchers analyzed a dual-hop, block-fading network using Non-Regenerative (Amplify-and-Forward) relays. Unlike "regenerative" relays that decode and re-encode a signal, these simply amplify what they receive, which is faster and requires less processing power.

Key methodological highlights include:

  • Nakagami-$m$ Fading Model: They used this versatile model because it can represent various fading conditions (including Rayleigh, Hoyt, and Rician) by adjusting the $m$ parameter.
  • Two Scenarios:
    • Scenario (a): A single relay where both the source nodes and the relay are hit by interference from the Primary User.
  • Scenario (b): Multiple relays where "Best-Relay Selection" is used. Here, the primary transmitter is assumed to be far from the sources but still interferes with the relays.
  • Power Constraint Strategy: Instead of a fixed power limit, the SUs' transmit power is dynamically adjusted based on the Primary User's outage probability.
  • Mathematical Derivations: The authors derived closed-form expressions for the Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) of the Signal-to-Interference-plus-Noise Ratio (SINR), utilizing complex functions like the Tricomi confluent hypergeometric function.

Datasets

This is a theoretical and analytical paper, so it does not use real-world datasets. Instead, the authors used Monte Carlo simulations (averaging over $10^5$ independent iterations) to generate synthetic data. This data was used to validate that their derived mathematical formulas accurately predict network behavior.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Interference Floor": If the primary transmitter's power increases beyond a certain point, the secondary network hits an "error floor." No matter how much you try to optimize, the secondary performance stops improving because the SUs must cap their power to avoid harming the primary network.
  • Fading Severity Matters: The performance of the secondary network improves significantly as the Nakagami $m$ parameter increases. This confirms that the "severity" of the environment is a dominant factor in cognitive radio success.
  • Diversity Gain: In Scenario (b), the "Best-Relay Selection" strategy provides a massive boost in performance (diversity gain), especially in the mid-to-high SNR (Signal-to-Noise Ratio) regions.
  • PU Protection vs. SU Performance: There is a direct trade-off. If the Primary User requires a very strict (low) outage threshold, the Secondary User's performance plummets because they are forced to transmit at very low power.

Key Results

  • Analytical Accuracy: The derived closed-form expressions for Outage Capacity and ASEP were shown to be "tight lower bounds," meaning they are very close to the actual simulated performance.
  • Impact of Relay Count: In Scenario (b), increasing the number of available relays ($K$) significantly lowers the outage probability, demonstrating the value of cooperative diversity.
  • Validation: The simulation results (dots on the graphs) perfectly matched the analytical results (lines), proving the mathematical models are reliable for system design.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Integer Constraints: Some of the derivations assume the Nakagami parameter $m$ is an integer, which may not cover every niche fading scenario.
  • Relay Type: The study is limited to non-regenerative (AF) relays. Future work could compare these results against Decode-and-Forward (DF) relays in the same cognitive setup.
  • Channel State Information (CSI): The model assumes certain levels of knowledge about the channel. Investigating performance with "imperfect" or delayed CSI would be a logical next step for more realistic deployments.
  • Network Scale: The paper focuses on a relatively small setup (two sources, one or a few relays). Scaling this analysis to a dense "Internet of Things" (IoT) environment with many cognitive users remains a challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate the performance of a dual-hop block fading cognitive radio network with underlay spectrum sharing over independent but not necessarily identically distributed (i.n.i.d.) Nakagami-m fading channels. The primary network consists of a source and a destination. Depending on whether the secondary network which consists of two source nodes have a single relay for cooperation or multiple relays thereby employs opportunistic relay selection for cooperation and whether the two source nodes suffer from the primary users' (PU) interference, two cases are considered in this paper, which are referred to as Scenario (a) and Scenario (b), respectively. For the considered underlay spectrum sharing, the transmit power constraint of the proposed system is adjusted by interference limit on the primary network and the interference imposed by primary user (PU). The developed new analysis obtains new analytical results for the outage capacity (OC) and average symbol error probability (ASEP). In particular, for Scenario (a), tight lower bounds on the OC and ASEP of the secondary network are derived in closed-form. In addition, a closed from expression for the end-to-end OC of Scenario (a) is achieved. With regards to Scenario (b), a tight lower bound on the OC of the secondary network is derived in closed-form. All analytical results are corroborated using Monte Carlo simulation method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vahidian2017power,
  author = {Saeed Vahidian and Maryam Najafi and Marzieh Najafi and Fawaz S. Al-Qahtani},
  title = {{Power allocation and cooperative diversity in two-way non-regenerative cognitive radio networks}},
  booktitle = {ICC},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=SOZYDTX0Cw},
}

Loading related content...

Figure