PoseFix: Model-agnostic General Human Pose Refinement Network

Gyeongsik Moon, Ju Yong Chang, Kyoung Mu Lee

TL;DR

This paper introduces PoseFix, a novel "model-agnostic" network that refines human pose estimations from any existing method. By training on synthetically generated pose errors based on real-world error distributions, PoseFix can be applied as a post-processing step to significantly improve the accuracy of various state-of-the-art pose estimators without needing their internal code.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately localizing human body keypoints in 2D images (human pose estimation) is crucial for understanding human behavior and interactions. While deep learning has led to impressive advancements, existing pose estimation methods still make errors. Many refinement techniques are tightly coupled with the specific pose estimation model they are designed for, making them difficult to adapt or use with other methods. This creates a need for a general-purpose refinement tool that can boost the performance of any pose estimator without requiring deep integration or knowledge of its internals.

Methods

The core innovation of PoseFix is its "model-agnostic" approach. Instead of being trained end-to-end with a specific pose estimator, PoseFix is trained offline using a clever data synthesis strategy. The authors observed that different state-of-the-art pose estimators tend to make similar types of errors (e.g., jitter, inversion, swap, miss). They leverage this insight by:

  1. Synthesizing Pose Errors: They generate synthetic incorrect poses by adding these common error types to ground-truth poses, guided by empirical error distributions from prior research. This creates a diverse and realistic training dataset that mimics real-world failure cases.
  2. Coarse-to-Fine Architecture: PoseFix uses a two-stage approach. It first takes a coarse input pose (represented as Gaussian heatmaps) and the input image to generate a finer pose representation (as one-hot encoded heatmaps). Finally, it outputs the refined keypoint coordinates. This coarse-to-fine strategy helps the network focus on both the general area and the precise location of keypoints.
  3. Model-Agnostic Application: During testing, PoseFix takes the output pose from any pose estimation method and the input image to produce a refined pose. It doesn't need access to the original model's code or internal workings, making it a flexible post-processing tool.

Datasets

  • MS COCO 2017 Keypoint Detection Dataset: Used for training and evaluation. This is a standard benchmark for human pose estimation.
  • PoseTrack 2018 Dataset: Used to demonstrate the generalizability of PoseFix on a different dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Error Distribution is Key: The surprising insight is that the types of errors made by different pose estimators are quite similar, even if their overall performance varies. This commonality allows for a generalizable refinement strategy.
  • Synthetic Data for Robustness: Training on synthetically generated errors, rather than just ground truth, makes the model robust to the specific failure modes of various pose estimators.
  • Post-Processing Power: The model-agnostic nature is a significant advantage. It means PoseFix can be easily "plugged in" to existing pipelines, offering immediate performance boosts without complex integration.
  • Coarse-to-Fine is Crucial: The paper emphasizes that the coarse-to-fine estimation pipeline is essential for successful refinement, allowing the model to leverage initial rough pose information effectively.

Key Results

PoseFix consistently improves the performance of various state-of-the-art pose estimation methods.

  • Accuracy Gains: On the MS COCO test-dev set, PoseFix improved the Average Precision (AP) of methods like AE, Mask R-CNN, CPN, and Simple by significant margins (e.g., +7.3 AP for AE, +4.3 AP for Mask R-CNN, +3.2 AP for CPN, +1.6 AP for Simple).
  • Error Correction: PoseFix effectively corrects not only small displacement errors (jitter) but also larger errors like inversion, miss, and swap.
  • Generalizability: The model demonstrated performance improvements on the PoseTrack 2018 dataset as well, indicating its broad applicability.
  • Competitive with Refinement Modules: PoseFix achieved better results than conventional end-to-end trainable multi-stage refinement models, even when those models had similar architectures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dependence on Input Pose Quality: While PoseFix improves accuracy, its performance is still influenced by the quality of the initial pose estimation. Extremely poor input poses might still lead to suboptimal results.
  • Computational Overhead: As a post-processing step, PoseFix adds computational cost to the overall pipeline, though the paper doesn't explicitly quantify this.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their model-agnostic approach can be easily adapted to other pose estimation tasks and could serve as a flexible add-on module for future pose estimation models. The success of the coarse-to-fine strategy and synthetic error generation points towards further exploration in these areas.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-person pose estimation from a 2D image is an essential technique for human behavior understanding. In this paper, we propose a human pose refinement network that estimates a refined pose from a tuple of an input image and input pose. The pose refinement was performed mainly through an end-to-end trainable multi-stage architecture in previous methods. However, they are highly dependent on pose estimation models and require careful model design. By contrast, we propose a model-agnostic pose refinement method. According to a recent study, state-of-the-art 2D human pose estimation methods have similar error distributions. We use this error statistics as prior information to generate synthetic poses and use the synthesized poses to train our model. In the testing stage, pose estimation results of any other methods can be input to the proposed method. Moreover, the proposed model does not require code or knowledge about other methods, which allows it to be easily used in the post-processing step. We show that the proposed approach achieves better performance than the conventional multi-stage refinement models and consistently improves the performance of various state-of-the-art pose estimation methods on the commonly used benchmark. The code is available in this https URL\footnote{\url{https://github.com/mks0601/PoseFix_RELEASE}}.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{moon2019posefix,
  author = {Gyeongsik Moon and Ju Yong Chang and Kyoung Mu Lee},
  title = {{PoseFix: Model-agnostic General Human Pose Refinement Network}},
  booktitle = {CVPR},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=rm-v0MxdTB},
}
Figure