Portable ultrasound devices for obstetric care in resource-constrained environments: mapping the landscape

Bryan J. Ranger, Elizabeth Bradburn, Qingchao Chen, Micah Kim, J. Alison Noble, Aris T. Papageorghiou

TL;DR

This paper maps the landscape of affordable, portable ultrasound devices for obstetric care in resource-limited settings. It provides a crucial resource for clinicians and researchers by detailing device capabilities, costs, and ideal technical features, aiming to improve maternal and perinatal health outcomes globally.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maternal and perinatal mortality rates remain alarmingly high in many underserved regions worldwide. The World Health Organization (WHO) emphasizes the critical role of antenatal ultrasound in improving pregnancy outcomes, but access to this technology is often limited in resource-constrained environments. While traditional ultrasound machines are expensive and complex, a new generation of portable, cost-effective ultrasound devices has emerged. However, a clear understanding of their capabilities, limitations, and suitability for these specific settings has been lacking, hindering informed decision-making for procurement and implementation. This paper aims to bridge that gap by providing a comprehensive overview and framework for evaluating these devices.

Methods

The authors conducted a desk review to map the landscape of portable ultrasound devices suitable for obstetric care in resource-constrained environments. Their methodology involved:

  • Defining Ideal Technical Features: They consulted with subject matter experts (SMEs), including clinicians and researchers from various global settings, to establish a list of essential technical features. These features were categorized into "minimum viable product" (baseline requirements) and "target state" (ideal attributes). Key features included image acquisition modes, cost, portability, power, compatibility (hardware and software), connectivity, data storage, data security, and regulatory certification.
  • Device Identification: They identified candidate devices through internet searches, company websites, and discussions with industry partners, focusing specifically on low-cost (under $10,000) portable, mobile, or tablet-based systems.
  • Data Collection and Verification: Information on the identified devices was gathered from publicly available sources, input from SMEs, and discussions with company representatives. The review was conducted and verified in March 2022.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a desk review of commercially available devices, not an empirical study with datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Minimum Viable" vs. "Target State" Framework: The clear distinction between essential baseline features and aspirational ideal features provides a practical and adaptable framework for evaluating devices, applicable beyond just obstetric ultrasound.
  • The Rise of AI and Connectivity: The paper highlights the increasing importance of features that support artificial intelligence (AI) integration and robust connectivity. This reflects a forward-thinking approach, recognizing that future advancements in ultrasound will likely leverage AI for image analysis and automated measurements, and that seamless data transfer is crucial for remote consultations and record-keeping.
  • Cost is a Major Driver, But Not the Only One: While cost-effectiveness is a primary advantage of these portable devices, the review emphasizes that other factors like usability, durability, and compatibility with existing infrastructure (e.g., mobile platforms, cloud storage) are equally critical for successful implementation in resource-limited settings.
  • SDK/API Availability is Key for Innovation: The lack of Software Development Kits (SDKs) or Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) for many devices is a significant barrier to developing custom applications, including AI-driven tools, which limits the potential for innovation and adaptation.

Key Results

The review identified 14 portable mobile-based ultrasound systems. Key findings include:

  • Probe Diversity: Ten devices offered convex probes, ideal for obstetrics, with some also providing linear or dual-probe options.
  • Feature Variations: While most devices offered B-mode and M-mode imaging, the availability of color Doppler and specific obstetric calculators (for gestational age, estimated fetal weight, etc.) varied significantly.
  • Cost Range: Device costs ranged from $700 to $10,000, with some available via subscription models.
  • Connectivity and Data Storage: A mix of USB and wireless connectivity was observed, with varying levels of cloud and smartphone-based storage options.
  • SDK/API Limitations: A notable finding was that eight of the devices lacked an SDK or API at the time of the review, hindering the development of new applications.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Temporally Finite Benefit: The rapidly evolving nature of portable ultrasound technology means any review is a snapshot in time.
  • Manufacturer-Based Data: Information was primarily gathered from publicly available sources and company representatives, which may not always reflect real-world performance. Field testing was deemed prohibitive due to the number of devices and rapid development.
  • Subjectivity of Imaging: Specific imaging characteristics were not evaluated due to their subjective nature.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Convening Focus Groups: Bringing together clinicians, AI researchers, and technologists to establish trials and gather targeted feedback on device selection.
  • Field Validation Studies: Conducting real-world evaluations of shortlisted devices.
  • Broader Applicability: Adapting the framework for evaluating portable ultrasound technology for other clinical applications (e.g., cardiac, lung, musculoskeletal).
  • Testing with Diverse Users: Evaluating devices with healthcare workers of varying skill levels and hand sizes to assess ergonomic performance.

Reviewers also highlighted areas for improvement, such as developing a standardized scoring framework for easier comparison, providing more detail on the SME consultation process, and including full source data for enhanced reproducibility.

Summary updated

Abstract

<ns3:p>Background The WHO’s recommendations on antenatal care underscore the need for ultrasound assessment during pregnancy. Given that maternal and perinatal mortality remains unacceptably high in underserved regions, these guidelines are imperative for achieving better outcomes. In recent years, portable ultrasound devices have become increasingly popular in resource-constrained environments due to their cost-effectiveness, useability, and adoptability in resource-constrained settings. This desk review presents the capabilities and costs of currently available portable ultrasound devices, and is meant to serve as a resource for clinicians and researchers in the imaging community. Methods A list of ideal technical features for portable ultrasound devices was developed in consultation with subject matter experts (SMEs). Features included image acquisition modes, cost, portability, compatibility, connectivity, data storage and security, and regulatory certification status. Information on each of the devices was collected from publicly available information, input from SMEs and/or discussions with company representatives. Results 14 devices were identified and included in this review. The output is meant to provide objective information on ideal technical features for available ultrasound systems to researchers and clinicians working in obstetric ultrasound in low-resource settings. No product endorsements are provided. Conclusions This desk review provides an overview of the landscape of low-cost portable ultrasound probes for use in obstetrics in resource-constrained environments, and provides a description of key capabilities and costs for each. Methods could be applied to mapping the landscape of portable ultrasound devices for other clinical applications, or may be extended to reviewing other types of healthcare technologies. Further studies are recommended to evaluate portable ultrasound devices for usability and durability in global field settings.</ns3:p>
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ranger2024portable,
  author = {Bryan J. Ranger and Elizabeth Bradburn and Qingchao Chen and Micah Kim and J. Alison Noble and Aris T. Papageorghiou},
  title = {{Portable ultrasound devices for obstetric care in resource-constrained environments: mapping the landscape}},
  booktitle = {Gates},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.12688/gatesopenres.15088.2},
}

Loading related content...

Figure