Polynomial Treedepth Bounds in Linear Colorings

Jeremy Kun, Michael P. O'Brien, Marcin Pilipczuk, Blair D. Sullivan

Abstract

This paper investigates the relationship between $p$-linear colorings and $p$-centered colorings in the context of sparse graph algorithms. While $p$-centered colorings are a standard tool for decomposing graphs into subgraphs of bounded treedepth, they often require a large number of colors. We explore $p$-linear colorings as a more efficient alternative, requiring a unique color only on every path rather than every connected subgraph. We prove that $p$-linear colorings still provide a polynomial bound on treedepth across various graph classes, including general graphs, trees, and interval graphs, despite the increased computational complexity of verifying such colorings.

Introduction

The analysis of sparse graphs, particularly those belonging to classes of bounded expansion, often relies on a "divide and conquer" strategy. This pipeline involves coloring a graph such that small sets of colors induce subgraphs with low treedepth. Treedepth is a critical structural parameter that determines the efficiency of solving NP-hard problems on these subgraphs. The standard approach utilizes $p$-centered colorings, which ensure that every connected subgraph contains a vertex with a unique color. However, the number of colors required for $p$-centered colorings can be prohibitively high, leading to combinatorial explosions in algorithm runtime.

Problem Statement

The primary bottleneck in sparse graph algorithms is the number of colors ($k$) used in the initial decomposition. The authors of "Polynomial Treedepth Bounds in Linear Colorings" seek to relax the constraints of $p$-centered colorings to reduce $k$ while maintaining the structural guarantees necessary for efficient problem-solving. Specifically, they introduce $p$-linear colorings, which only require a unique color to appear on every path within the graph, rather than every connected subgraph. The central question is whether this relaxation preserves a manageable bound on the resulting treedepth.

Methods

The research employs several mathematical strategies to bridge the gap between linear colorings ($\chi_{lin}$) and centered colorings ($\chi_{cen}$):

  • Grid Minor Theory: For general graphs, the authors utilize graph minor theory to establish that a small linear coloring implies a polynomially bounded treedepth.
  • Potential Functions: For trees, a recursive potential function approach demonstrates that the gap between the two coloring types is logarithmic relative to the tree's maximum degree.
  • Prevailing Paths: In the case of interval graphs, the authors developed an algorithm to span maximal cliques, proving a quadratic relationship between the coloring types.
  • Complexity Analysis: The study uses reductions from CNF-SAT to evaluate the difficulty of recognizing $p$-linear colorings.

Key Results

The paper establishes several significant bounds and complexity results:

  • General Graphs: A polynomial upper bound exists. While the initial proof suggested a high exponent (190), subsequent refinements in the field have reduced this to 19.
  • Interval Graphs: A tight quadratic bound was proven: $\chi_{cen}(G) \leq (\chi_{lin}(G))^2$.
  • Trees: For a tree $T$ with maximum degree $\Delta$, $\chi_{cen}(T) \leq (\log_2 \Delta) \cdot \chi_{lin}(T)$.
  • Hardness: The authors proved that recognizing $p$-linear colorings is co-NP-complete, as finding a path without a unique color (the "Non-centered Path" problem) is NP-complete.

Discussion and Future Work

A major insight of this work is that ensuring unique colors on paths is sufficient to prevent treedepth from becoming unmanageable. However, a significant gap remains between the proven polynomial upper bounds and the observed lower bounds (a ratio of approximately 2). The authors propose Conjecture 1: $\chi_{cen}(G) \leq 2\chi_{lin}(G)$ for any graph $G$.

Furthermore, the co-NP-completeness of verifying linear colorings presents a practical challenge. Future research should focus on developing heuristics or approximation algorithms to find these colorings efficiently, as well as replacing the "heavy machinery" of graph minor theory with more specialized algorithms suitable for large-scale network applications. This work paves the way for more efficient graph decomposition techniques in algorithmic graph theory.

Summary updated

Abstract

Low-treedepth colorings are an important tool for algorithms that exploit structure in classes of bounded expansion; they guarantee subgraphs that use few colors have bounded treedepth. These colorings have an implicit tradeoff between the total number of colors used and the treedepth bound, and prior empirical work suggests that the former dominates the run time of existing algorithms in practice. We introduce p-linear colorings as an alternative to the commonly used p-centered colorings. They can be efficiently computed in bounded expansion classes and use at most as many colors as p-centered colorings. Although a set of \(k<p\) colors from a p-centered coloring induces a subgraph of treedepth at most k, the same number of colors from a p-linear coloring may induce subgraphs of larger treedepth. We establish a polynomial upper bound on the treedepth in general graphs, and give tighter bounds in trees and interval graphs via constructive coloring algorithms. We also give a co-NP-completeness reduction for recognizing p-linear colorings and discuss ways to overcome this limitation in practice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kun2018polynomial,
  author = {Jeremy Kun and Michael P. O'Brien and Marcin Pilipczuk and Blair D. Sullivan},
  title = {{Polynomial Treedepth Bounds in Linear Colorings}},
  booktitle = {WG},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-030-00256-5\_27},
}
Figure