Political Hierarchy of Opening-Up Policy and China’s Carbon Reduction: Empirical Research Based on Spatial Regression Discontinuity

Nan Zhang, Yan ZhuangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

China's "opening-up" policies, intended to boost economic growth, have paradoxically led to increased carbon emissions in its eastern coastal regions, particularly near policy boundaries. This study reveals that while these policies might eventually lead to carbon reduction through mechanisms like fiscal subsidies, their immediate effect is a "pollution paradise" scenario, especially in areas with less stringent environmental regulations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles a critical question at the intersection of economic policy and environmental sustainability: how does China's "opening-up" policy, a cornerstone of its economic development strategy, influence its carbon emissions? While the "pollution paradise" theory suggests that increased trade openness can lead to developing countries becoming dumping grounds for polluting industries, there's ongoing debate and limited empirical evidence, especially concerning the nuanced impact of policy hierarchy and spatial distribution. The authors aim to fill this gap by investigating how the political hierarchy of opening-up policies, specifically the upgrade of pilot regions, affects carbon reduction at a granular county level in China's economically vital eastern coastal region. They also explore the spatial dimensions of this impact, considering boundary effects and regional heterogeneity.

Methods

The core methodological contribution of this paper is the application of Spatial Regression Discontinuity (Spatial RD). This approach is particularly well-suited for evaluating the impact of policies that are implemented based on a specific geographic threshold or boundary.

Here's a breakdown of the key techniques:

  • Counterfactual Framework: The study constructs a counterfactual by comparing counties designated as "pilot zones" (treatment group) with adjacent "non-pilot zones" (control group) that share similar characteristics but were not subject to the same policy upgrade.
  • Spatial Regression Discontinuity (Spatial RD): This method leverages the geographic boundary between pilot and non-pilot zones as a natural experiment. By analyzing data points very close to this boundary, the researchers can isolate the causal effect of the policy upgrade, assuming that units just on either side of the boundary are otherwise similar.
  • Local Linear and Quadratic Polynomial Estimations: To account for potential non-linear relationships between distance to the boundary and carbon emissions, the authors employ both local linear and quadratic polynomial regression techniques.
  • Robustness Checks: Various methods are used to ensure the reliability of the findings, including:
  • Varying bandwidths (distances around the boundary) for analysis.
  • Adjusting the definition of the boundary (e.g., creating a "boundary surface").
  • Testing with net carbon emissions instead of total carbon emissions.
  • Conducting a placebo test by artificially shifting the boundary to see if the policy effect disappears.
  • Heterogeneity Tests: The analysis is further broken down by province to understand how the policy's impact varies across different regions.

Datasets

The study utilizes county-level data for China's 9 eastern coastal provinces (cities) from 1997 to 2017. Key datasets include:

  • Carbon Emissions Data: County-level carbon emissions data (total and net) from 1997-2017.
  • Policy Data: Information on the designation of "pilot zones" for opening-up policies.
  • Geographic Data: County coordinates, altitude, and distance to coastlines.
  • Economic Data: GDP, population.
  • Financial Subsidy Data: Central government financial subsidies to local pilot zones (1997-2017), sourced from the "China Statistical Yearbook."

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Opening-Up" Paradox: The most striking finding is that the improvement in the political hierarchy of opening-up policies (e.g., upgrading to national-level pilot zones) is negatively related to carbon reduction, meaning it boosts carbon emissions. This directly supports the "pollution paradise" hypothesis in this context.
  • Boundary Matters: The impact of the opening-up policy is not uniform. There's a significant "boundary effect," where the policy's influence is more pronounced in counties immediately adjacent to the policy's designated areas. This suggests that the spatial discontinuity of policy implementation is crucial.
  • Provincial Heterogeneity: The impact varies significantly across provinces. Some provinces (Hebei, Zhejiang, Guangdong) show a positive effect on carbon emissions, while others (Liaoning, Fujian, Shandong, Jiangsu) demonstrate a negative effect (i.e., carbon reduction). This highlights the complex interplay of regional factors.
  • Location, Location, Location: Both man-made factors (like the presence of ports) and natural factors (like altitude) play a role in how opening-up policies affect carbon emissions. Man-made factors, particularly those related to coastal advantages and industrial agglomeration, appear to be stronger drivers of increased emissions.
  • Policy Intensity as a Mediator: The study suggests that policy intensity, often reflected in financial subsidies, is a key mechanism through which the political hierarchy of opening-up policies influences carbon reduction.

Key Results

  • Positive Impact on Carbon Emissions: The improvement of the political hierarchy of the opening-up policy significantly increases total regional carbon emissions in the eastern coastal areas.
  • Boundary Jump and Depression Effects: Provinces exhibit distinct patterns:
  • Boundary Jump: Some provinces show a significant increase in emissions across the policy boundary.
  • Boundary Depression: Other provinces show a decrease in emissions closer to the coastline, suggesting a concentration of policy benefits and potentially higher emissions further inland.
  • Net Carbon Emissions: The impact on net carbon emissions is significant only in areas immediately adjacent to the border.
  • Heterogeneous Effects:
    • Positive Impact Provinces: Hebei, Zhejiang, and Guangdong showed significant positive effects on carbon emissions.
  • Negative Impact Provinces: Liaoning, Fujian, Shandong, and Jiangsu showed significant negative effects (carbon reduction).
  • Man-made vs. Natural Factors: Coastal counties experienced a significant promotion of carbon emissions, while border counties showed no significant impact. Altitude, a natural factor, was found to have a significant carbon-reduction effect.
  • Fiscal Subsidies: A positive correlation was found between policy intensity (financial subsidies) and carbon reduction, particularly in areas further from the border.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Period: The study covers data from 1997-2017. The authors note that China's opening-up policy evolved from market-oriented to institutional-oriented after 2008, and future research could explore the impact of this shift.
  • Action Mechanism Clarity: While the study identifies policy intensity and location selection as key mechanisms, the exact direction of their influence on carbon emissions remains somewhat unclear and warrants further investigation.
  • Net Carbon Emissions Calculation: The calculation of net carbon emissions considered only CCS capacity of mountains and vegetation, potentially overlooking marine CCS capacity in coastal areas.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest exploring the impact of the institutional-oriented opening-up policy and further investigating the precise action direction of policy intensity and location selection. They also propose examining the impact of administrative border barriers and promoting regional economic integration for carbon reduction.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper constructs a counterfactual framework based on the opening-up policies of provinces in the eastern coastal region. It analyzes the role of the political hierarchy of the opening-up policy in China’s carbon reduction at the county level by using Spatial Regression Discontinuity, and the data used are from 1997 to 2017. The study found the following: (1) The improvement of the political hierarchy of the opening-up policy is negatively related to the carbon reduction, which has significantly boosted the carbon emission of counties in the eastern coastal areas of China. (2) The impact on border counties is more significant, and there is an obvious boundary effect. In terms of net carbon emissions, the political-hierarchy difference has a significant impact only in the area adjacent to the border. (3) There is strong heterogeneity among provinces, showing the boundary jump effect and boundary depression effect. (4) The political-hierarchy differences are significantly related to the regional carbon reduction by changing policy intensity, resulting in fiscal subsidies effects and gradient transfer effects. The location selection for the implementation of the opening-up policy significantly impacted the carbon reductions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023political,
  author = {Nan Zhang and Yan Zhuang},
  title = {{Political Hierarchy of Opening-Up Policy and China’s Carbon Reduction: Empirical Research Based on Spatial Regression Discontinuity}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15075995},
}
Figure