Poisson Ordinal Network for Gleason Group Estimation Using Bi-Parametric MRI

Yinsong Xu, Yipei Wang, Ziyi Shen, Iani J. M. B. Gayo, Natasha Thorley, Shonit Punwani, Aidong Men, Dean C. Barratt, Qingchao Chen, Yipeng Hu

Introduction

Prostate cancer grading is a critical step in determining patient treatment. Currently, the gold standard is the Gleason system, which categorizes tissue into groups based on cellular aggressiveness. However, this requires invasive biopsies. While bi-parametric MRI (bpMRI) is used for initial screening, its use for definitive grading remains limited by the subjective nature of interpretation and the technical difficulty of modeling ordinal medical data. Researchers have introduced the Poisson Ordinal Network (PON) to bridge this gap, offering a deep learning architecture that respects the natural progression of cancer grades.

The Challenge of Ordinality

Standard classification models treat categories like "Gleason Grade 1" and "Gleason Grade 5" as independent labels, similar to distinguishing between a "dog" and a "cat." In reality, Gleason groups are ordinal; a misclassification between adjacent grades (e.g., Grade 3 vs. Grade 4) is clinically less severe than a jump from Grade 1 to Grade 5.

Gleason grading process and the clinical intuition behind uni-modal prediction distributions.

Furthermore, MRI appearances of the same grade can vary significantly across patients. Traditional cross-entropy loss functions ignore this ordering, often leading to "non-intuitive" multi-modal predictions where a model might assign high probability to two very different grades simultaneously. The PON addresses this by forcing the model's output to be uni-modal, mirroring biological reality.

The Poisson Ordinal Network (PON)

To address these issues, the PON architecture incorporates the logic of medical grading directly into its design through three key components.

Overview of the PON architecture, featuring Poisson encoding and memory-bank-based contrastive learning.

Poisson-based Prediction and Encoding

Instead of a standard Softmax output, the PON predicts a single parameter, $\lambda$, which defines a Poisson distribution. This ensures the output is always uni-modal, reflecting the likelihood that a sample belongs to a specific point on a continuous spectrum of severity. The model is trained using Poisson encoding, where ground-truth labels are represented as distributions rather than "one-hot" vectors. This is paired with a Poisson Focal Loss to prioritize learning from ambiguous, "hard" cases in the middle of the scale.

Contrastive Learning with a Memory Bank

Handling high-resolution 3D MRI data often restricts batch sizes due to hardware limitations. To overcome this, the authors implemented a contrastive learning branch using a memory bank. This component stores feature representations from previous training steps, allowing the model to compare current images against a diverse set of "remembered" examples. This process pulls features of the same Gleason grade together in the latent space, improving the model's ability to generalize across different patients despite high variance in MRI appearances.

Experimental Results

The PON was evaluated using the PROMIS dataset, which includes bpMRI scans from 265 patients, with ground truth established via high-accuracy saturation biopsies.

  • Performance: The PON achieved an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 60.06%, significantly outperforming standard Cross-Entropy models (53.91%).
  • Clinical Utility: In identifying clinically significant cancer (Gleason $\ge$ 4+3), the model reached a sensitivity of 44.12% at 80% specificity.
  • Human-AI Synergy: The model correctly identified 30 out of 48 "false positives" originally flagged by expert radiologists, highlighting its potential as a diagnostic "second reader" to help doctors avoid unnecessary biopsies.

Conclusion

While predicting Gleason grades from MRI alone remains a formidable challenge, the Poisson Ordinal Network demonstrates that incorporating domain-specific constraints—like ordinality and uni-modality—can significantly improve AI performance. By reducing the rate of false positives, such models could eventually serve as a powerful co-pilot for radiologists, improving the standard of care for prostate cancer patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Gleason groups serve as the primary histological grading system for prostate cancer, providing crucial insights into the cancer's potential for growth and metastasis. In clinical practice, pathologists determine the Gleason groups based on specimens obtained from ultrasound-guided biopsies. In this study, we investigate the feasibility of directly estimating the Gleason groups from MRI scans to reduce otherwise required biopsies. We identify two characteristics of this task, ordinality and the resulting dependent yet unknown variances between Gleason groups. In addition to the inter- / intra- observer variability in a multi-step Gleason scoring process based on the interpretation of Gleason patterns, our MR-based prediction is also subject to specimen sampling variance and, to a lesser degree, varying MR imaging protocols. To address this challenge, we propose a novel Poisson ordinal network (PON). PONs model the prediction using a Poisson distribution and leverages Poisson encoding and Poisson focal loss to capture a learnable dependency between ordinal classes (here, Gleason groups), rather than relying solely on the numerical ground-truth (e.g. Gleason Groups 1-5 or Gleason Scores 6-10). To improve this modelling efficacy, PONs also employ contrastive learning with a memory bank to regularise intra-class variance, decoupling the memory requirement of contrast learning from the batch size. Experimental results based on the images labelled by saturation biopsies from 265 prior-biopsy-blind patients, across two tasks demonstrate the superiority and effectiveness of our proposed method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2024poisson,
  author = {Yinsong Xu and Yipei Wang and Ziyi Shen and Iani J. M. B. Gayo and Natasha Thorley and Shonit Punwani and Aidong Men and Dean C. Barratt and Qingchao Chen and Yipeng Hu},
  title = {{Poisson Ordinal Network for Gleason Group Estimation Using Bi-Parametric MRI}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Medical Image Computing and Computer-Assisted Intervention},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-031-72086-4\_53},
}
Figure