Plenary Impressions of the 5th Plenary Council of Australia

Angela McCarthyPastoral 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This report provides a first-hand ethnographic account of the 5th Plenary Council of Australia held in July 2022. It documents a pivotal moment of institutional disruption and reform within the Catholic Church, specifically focusing on the tensions between traditional hierarchy and modern synodal pressures regarding the role of women and lay leadership.

Introduction

The 5th Plenary Council of Australia represented a landmark event in the history of the local Church, aiming to address contemporary challenges through a "synodal" lens. This paper, based on the daily journals and observations of participant Angela McCarthy, offers an "under-the-hood" perspective on the week-long assembly. It captures the transition from a top-down governance model to a more collaborative, listening-based approach, highlighting the friction and eventual adaptation that occurred when traditional structures met the "sense of the faithful" (sensus fidelium).

The Challenge of Synodality

The central problem addressed during the Council was procedural and cultural: how to integrate collaborative governance into a historically hierarchical institution. This tension was most visible in discussions regarding the role of laypeople and the recognition of women's leadership. The assembly faced the difficult task of moving 250+ diverse members—including clergy, religious, and laypeople—from diametrically opposed views toward a consensus capable of being codified into ecclesiastical law.

Methodology: Ethnographic Discernment

The insights presented here are derived from a qualitative, auto-ethnographic approach. The author recorded daily observations to capture the evolving mood and actions of the event. Central to the Council’s process were several key "procedural technologies":

  • Spiritual Conversations: A structured method of discernment involving silent prayer and timed speaking intervals to ensure all voices were heard without immediate debate.
  • Bicameral Voting: A system where "consultative" votes by all members were followed by "deliberative" votes by bishops, requiring a two-thirds majority for passage.
  • Procedural Disruption: An unplanned but critical "method" where members refused to take their seats after a failed vote, forcing a shift toward a more flexible, collaborative writing process.
The assembly hall during the Council, illustrating the solemn and formal setting of the deliberations.

Key Insights and Results

The Council experienced a significant crisis on Wednesday when a section of the framework regarding the equal dignity of women and men failed to pass the bishops' deliberative vote. This failure, described by some as "manure," ultimately provided the "nutrients" for a more mature discernment.

Successful Reform of Part 4

Following the initial rejection and a subsequent protest, the section "Witnessing to the Equal Dignity of Women and Men" was completely rewritten. The new version passed with near-unanimous support, marking a significant victory for those advocating for gender equality within church structures.

Governance and Lay Participation

A major theological shift was observed in the recognition that governance within the Church stems from baptism rather than ordination. This opens the door for laypeople to occupy high-level leadership roles. However, limitations remain; while the Council accepted formal ministries for lay preaching in some contexts, it rejected a motion to allow laypeople to preach the homily during Mass.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The 5th Plenary Council demonstrated surprising institutional agility, adapting its processes mid-week to overcome deadlock. However, the journey is far from over. The decrees passed must now undergo the recognitio process—a review by the Holy See in Rome—before they can become law. Furthermore, a mandatory six-month waiting period precedes implementation, and the true measure of the Council's success will be how these high-level decrees are translated into practice at the local parish level.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{mccarthy2022plenary,
  author = {Angela McCarthy},
  title = {{Plenary Impressions of the 5th Plenary Council of Australia}},
  booktitle = {Pastoral},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.59405/2653-7834.1151},
}
Figure