Playback experience driven cross layer optimisation of APP, transport and MAC layer for video clients over long-term evolution system

Xinyu Huang, Lijun He

Abstract

In traditional communication systems, information from the Application (APP), transport, and Media Access Control (MAC) layers is often siloed, leading to inconsistencies between TCP congestion states, client requirements, and resource allocation. To solve this problem, we propose a joint optimization framework consisting of the APP, transport, and MAC layers to improve video playback experience and system throughput. First, a client requirement aware autonomous packet drop (APD) strategy, based on packet importance, channel condition, and playback status, is developed to decrease network load and rebuffering events. Further, TCP-state aware downlink and uplink resource allocation schemes are proposed to achieve smooth video transmission and steady ACK feedback. Simulation results show that our algorithm significantly improves system throughput and playback continuity with acceptable video quality.

Introduction

Mobile video streaming frequently encounters the "spinning wheel of death," a symptom of rebuffering that degrades user experience. This issue is largely due to the lack of interaction between network layers in traditional architectures. The Application layer understands buffer status, the Transport layer (TCP) manages congestion, and the MAC layer handles radio resource allocation. However, these layers are typically "blind" to one another.

TCP's reliability mechanisms often attempt to deliver every bit of data, even if it arrives too late for a video frame to be useful. Meanwhile, the MAC layer might allocate excessive downlink resources to a user whose uplink is congested, preventing the return of Acknowledgement (ACK) packets and causing the stream to stall. This research proposes a cross-layer framework to synchronize these processes.

Proposed Cross-Layer Optimization Framework

The proposed framework integrates the APP, transport, and MAC layers to optimize resource use and playback continuity.

System architecture of the proposed cross-layer optimization framework, showing the interaction between the HAS server, eNodeB, and client playback.

The framework consists of three core strategies:

Autonomous Packet Drop (APD) Strategy

Implemented at the APP layer, the APD strategy preemptively drops low-priority video packets based on motion vectors and coding modes when congestion is detected. This prevents the TCP congestion window from collapsing and helps maintain the playback buffer.

Detailed mechanism of the Autonomous Packet Drop (APD) strategy and its interaction with the TCP sending window.

The MAC layer calculates the actual transmission capacity required for each client based on their ACK feedback rate. This avoids wasting downlink resources on clients who cannot acknowledge data due to poor uplink conditions.

This algorithm prioritizes the uplink transmission of ACK packets that are close to their Retransmission Timeout (RTO). By ensuring timely ACK delivery, the downlink data flow remains steady.

Experimental Evaluation

The researchers evaluated the framework using the NS3 (Network Simulation 3) simulator, configured for a standard LTE macro-cell environment. Eight standard YUV video sequences (e.g., flower.cif, soccer.cif, foreman.cif) were used, pre-encoded using H.264/AVC into segments of 60 frames at 30 fps.

Results and Discussion

The proposed APD_TU_TD algorithm was compared against standard schedulers like Proportional Fair (PF) and Round-Robin (RR):

  • Throughput: Achieved a 13.9% improvement in system throughput compared to the MAXCI algorithm and over 50% improvement over standard PF/RR schedulers.
  • Rebuffering: Reduced average rebuffering time by 60.82% compared to the base optimization without the packet-drop strategy.
  • Video Quality: The decline in Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio (PSNR) was limited to approximately 1.5%, which is generally imperceptible to viewers.
  • Scalability: The system maintained stable performance even as the number of clients in the cell increased to 20.

The results highlight that "strategic imperfection"—dropping a small amount of data to avoid retransmission delays—is a powerful tool for improving Quality of Experience (QoE). Additionally, the study underscores the importance of the uplink-downlink feedback loop in streaming performance.

Conclusion

This cross-layer approach effectively mitigates rebuffering by aligning network resource allocation with application-level requirements and transport-layer states. Future work will focus on adapting the framework for newer codecs like HEVC and VVC, as well as testing in real-world 5G environments characterized by unpredictable interference and mobility.

Summary updated

Abstract

In traditional communication system, information of APP (Application) layer, transport layer and MAC (Media Access Control)layer has not been fully interacted,which inevitably leads to inconsistencies among TCP congestion state, clients'requirements and resource allocation. To solve the problem, we propose a joint optimization framework, which consists of APP layer, transport layer and MAC layer, to improve the video clients'playback experience and system throughput. First, a client requirement aware autonomous packet drop strategy, based on packet importance, channel condition and playback status, is developed to decrease the network load and the probability of rebuffering events. Further, TCP (Transmission Control Protocol) state aware downlink and uplink resource allocation schemes are proposed to achieve smooth video transmission and steady ACK (Acknowledgement) feedback respectively. For downlink scheme, maximum transmission capacity requirement for each client is calculated based on feedback ACK information from transport layer to avoid allocating excessive resource to the client, whose ACK feedback is blocked due to bad uplink channel condition. For uplink scheme, information of RTO (Retransmission Timeout) and TCP congestion window are utilized to indicate ACK scheduling priority. The simulation results show that our algorithm can signficantly improve the system throughput and the clients'playback continuity with acceptable video quality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2020playback,
  author = {Xinyu Huang and Lijun He},
  title = {{Playback experience driven cross layer optimisation of APP, transport and MAC layer for video clients over long-term evolution system}},
  booktitle = {IET Commun},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=OBIeXj6p37},
}
Figure