Plasticity facilitates rapid evolution

Mikhail Burtsev, K. V. Anokhin, Patrick BatesonbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a computational model demonstrating how developmental plasticity can dramatically accelerate the evolution of complex biological systems. By simulating organisms with "functional systems" that can be acquired through learning (plasticity) and later genetically assimilated, the authors show that plasticity acts as a powerful driver of evolutionary innovation, especially when facing complex environmental challenges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the long-standing question of how complex biological structures and behaviors evolve, particularly the rapid evolution observed in some lineages. Traditional evolutionary theory often relies on gradual, piecemeal genetic changes. However, this can be slow, especially when multiple genetic changes are required simultaneously for a new adaptation to be beneficial. The authors explore how developmental plasticity – an organism's ability to adjust its phenotype in response to environmental cues – can overcome this bottleneck and facilitate faster evolutionary rates, leading to increased biological complexity. They specifically investigate the "Baldwin effect," the idea that learned behaviors can pave the way for genetically assimilated traits.

Methods

The researchers developed a computational model simulating organisms composed of interconnected "functional systems." These systems are built from discrete "elements," and a system becomes functional only when all its required elements are present. The model incorporates two primary mechanisms for acquiring these functional systems:

  • Genomic Reorganization (Mutation): This represents traditional Darwinian evolution, where random mutations can introduce or modify elements.
  • Plasticity (Learning): This allows individuals to acquire missing elements for a functional system during their lifetime, effectively "learning" or adapting to the environment. This learned adaptation is not directly inherited but can be later "assimilated" through genomic changes.

The model simulates populations over many generations, tracking the accumulation of functional systems. They then compare the evolutionary trajectories of populations with and without plasticity under various conditions, including different mutation rates and system complexities.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a simulated model organism and population dynamics rather than real-world datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Plasticity as an Evolutionary Accelerator: The most striking finding is that plasticity significantly speeds up the acquisition of new functional systems compared to evolution relying solely on mutation. This suggests that plasticity doesn't just help organisms cope with immediate challenges but actively drives the evolutionary process.
  • Complexity Amplifies Plasticity's Effect: The benefit of plasticity becomes even more pronounced as the complexity of the required functional systems increases (i.e., more elements are needed). This implies that plasticity is particularly crucial for evolving intricate biological features.
  • "Assimilate-Stretch" Process: The model supports a mechanism where plasticity allows organisms to acquire adaptations, and then genomic changes gradually replace the plastic acquisition with a more cost-effective, inherited mechanism. This "assimilate-stretch" process allows for continuous adaptation and further complexity.
  • Functional Systems and Overlap are Key: The concept of partially overlapping functional systems is central. This overlap means that elements acquired for one system can be reused in others, creating efficiencies and allowing for more rapid building of complex networks of adaptations.
  • Learning Trials Matter: Even a small amount of learning (represented by a few "learning trials") can substantially accelerate evolution, highlighting the importance of even limited adaptive capacity.

Key Results

  • Three-fold Increase in Evolution Rate: In simulations with a low mutation rate and moderate system complexity (C=20), plastic populations acquired, on average, 45.1 functional systems over 25,000 generations, compared to 14.3 systems in non-plastic populations – a more than three-fold increase.
  • Forty-fold Acceleration for High Complexity: For the most complex tasks (C=40), plasticity accelerated the accumulation of adaptive systems by approximately 40-fold.
  • Faster Acquisition of Complexity: The time required for plastic populations to accumulate a given number of systems was more than ten times shorter than for non-plastic populations.
  • Learning's Impact: Even one learning trial significantly accelerated evolution, with 2-5 trials showing further improvements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The model uses simplified representations of genetic architecture, mutation, and learning. For instance, genomic reorganization is modeled as a single point mutation, and Lamarckian inheritance (direct inheritance of acquired traits) is explicitly excluded, though the "assimilation" process mimics its evolutionary outcome.
  • Focus on Functional Systems: The study focuses on the accumulation of functional systems. Future work could explore the interplay of plasticity with other evolutionary forces or different types of biological complexity.
  • Brain Size Correlation: The authors suggest that increased brain size, leading to greater learning capacity, should correlate with faster evolution. This is supported by existing research on taxonomic groups with larger brains. Future research could explore this link more directly within their model.
  • Environmental Dynamics: The current model primarily deals with static environmental challenges. Investigating how plasticity influences evolution in dynamic or fluctuating environments would be a valuable extension.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Developmental plasticity enables organisms to cope with new environmental challenges. If deploying such plasticity is costly in terms of time or energy, the same adaptive behavior could subsequently evolve through piecemeal genomic reorganisation that replaces the requirement to acquire that adaptation by individual plasticity. Here we report a new dimension to the way in which plasticity can drive evolutionary change leading to ever greater complexity in biological organization. Our model deploys the concept of partially overlapping functional systems. We found that plasticity accelerated dramatically the evolutionary accumulation of adaptive systems in model organisms with relatively low rates of mutation. The effect of plasticity on the evolutionary growth of complexity was even greater when the number of elements needed to construct a functional system was increased. These results suggest that as the difficulty of challenges from the environment become greater, so plasticity exerts an ever more powerful role in meeting those challenges and in opening up new avenues for the subsequent evolution of complex adaptations.
BibTeX
@misc{burtsev2022plasticity,
  author = {Mikhail Burtsev and K. V. Anokhin and Patrick Bateson},
  title = {{Plasticity facilitates rapid evolution}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.05.04.490584},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure