Plasticity and dynamical heterogeneity in driven glassy materials

Michel Tsamados

Introduction

Amorphous materials, ranging from metallic glasses to emulsions and foams, do not flow with the smooth uniformity of simple liquids. Instead, their deformation is characterized by "crackling" noise—a series of discrete, intermittent plastic events. Historically, research into these materials has been bifurcated. One school of thought focuses on the quasistatic limit, where deformation occurs so slowly that the system relaxes completely between events. The other focuses on finite shear rates, where these plastic events overlap and interact dynamically.

This paper bridges these two regimes, demonstrating how Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations at finite rates converge to the theoretical "frozen" limits of quasistatic models. Central to this work is the discovery of a diverging dynamical cooperativity length scale ($\xi$), which reveals that as the rate of deformation slows, the internal response of the glass becomes increasingly global.

Methodology

The study utilizes a 2D Lennard-Jones (LJ) amorphous solid, a standard model for investigating glassy dynamics. To explore the transition across shear rates, the author employed two primary computational strategies:

  1. Molecular Dynamics (MD): Used to simulate the system at finite shear rates ($\dot{\gamma}$) ranging from $10^{-2}$ down to $10^{-5}$ at low temperatures.
  2. Potential Energy Minimization: A protocol used to simulate the $\dot{\gamma} \to 0$ (quasistatic) limit by finding successive local energy minima.

To quantify the spatial coordination of particle motion, the author applied the four-point correlation function ($\chi_4$). This statistical tool, originally developed for supercooled liquids, allows for the measurement of the number of particles moving cooperatively over specific strain intervals. Simulations were performed on samples containing between 625 and 40,000 particles to account for finite-size effects and boundary conditions, comparing Rigid Wall (RWBCs) and Lees-Edwards (LEBCs) setups.

The Three Regimes of Flow

The analysis identifies three distinct rheological regimes based on the shear rate:

  • The Quasistatic Regime (Low Shear Rate): Here, the stress response is independent of the shear rate. The flow is highly intermittent, characterized by significant "stress drops" corresponding to system-wide avalanches. MD results at the lowest rates ($10^{-5}$) almost perfectly match the quasistatic energy minimization curves.
  • The Rate-Dependent Regime (Intermediate Shear Rate): The material follows a Herschel-Bulkley law ($\tau = \tau_Y + c_1\dot{\gamma}^\beta$), where the effective viscosity changes with the speed of deformation. The yield stress is found to be $\tau_Y \approx 0.36$ with an exponent $\beta \approx 0.4$.
  • The Homogeneous Regime (High Shear Rate): At high speeds, the discrete nature of plastic events is smoothed out, and the flow becomes spatially uniform.

Diverging Cooperativity and Scaling Laws

The most significant finding is the behavior of the dynamical cooperativity length scale, $\xi$. As the shear rate approaches zero, $\xi$ diverges, meaning that plastic events coordinate over increasingly large distances. In the quasistatic limit, these events often organize into "L-shaped" structures or shear bands that span the entire simulation box.

The author proposes a physical model based on the diffusive propagation of plastic events. If the influence of a local rearrangement spreads through the material like a diffusion process, the cooperativity length should scale with the shear rate. The MD results confirm this, showing a power-law relationship: $\xi \propto \dot{\gamma}^{-\nu}$. The measured exponent $\nu$ (between 0.2 and 0.3) aligns closely with the theoretical prediction of $1/4$.

Furthermore, the structural relaxation time ($t_{1/e}$) shows distinct scaling behaviors, transitioning from $\dot{\gamma}^{-0.63}$ in the high-rate regime to $\dot{\gamma}^{-1}$ in the low-rate limit.

Conclusion and Outlook

By demonstrating the convergence of finite-rate MD to quasistatic energy minimization, this research validates the use of simplified quasistatic models for understanding slow physical processes in glasses. The discovery of the diverging length scale provides a robust framework for understanding dynamical heterogeneity through the lens of diffusive propagation.

However, several questions remain. The current study is limited to 2D geometries; confirming these scaling laws in 3D is a necessary next step. Additionally, while the current work focuses on the $T \approx 0$ limit, preliminary data suggests that temperature introduces complex effects that warrant a more detailed mapping of the Temperature-Shear Rate phase diagram.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many amorphous glassy materials exhibit complex spatio-temporal mechanical response and rheology, characterized by an intermittent stress-strain response and a fluctuating velocity profile. Under quasistatic and athermal deformation protocols this heterogeneous plastic flow was shown to be composed of plastic events of various sizes. In this paper, through numerical study of a 2D LJ amorphous solid, we generalize the study of the heterogeneous dynamics of glassy materials to the finite shear-rate and temperature case. The global mechanical response obtained through the use of Molecular Dynamics is shown to converge to the quasistatic limit obtained with an energy minimization protocol. The detailed analysis of the plastic deformation at different shear rates shows that the glass follows different flow regimes. At sufficiently low shear rates the mechanical response reaches a shear-rate independent regime that exhibits all the characteristics of the quasistatic response (finite size effects, yield stress...). At intermediate shear rates the rheological properties are determined by the externally applied shear-rate. Finally at higher shear the system reaches a shear-rate independent homogeneous regime. The existence of these three regimes is also confirmed by the detailed analysis of the atomic motion. The computation of the four-point correlation function shows that the transition from the shear-rate dominated to the quasistatic regime is accompanied by the growth of a dynamical cooperativity length scale $ξ$ that is shown to diverge with shear rate. This divergence is compared with the prediction of a simple model that assumes the diffusive propagation of plastic events.
BibTeX
@article{tsamados2010plasticity,
  author = {Michel Tsamados},
  title = {{Plasticity and dynamical heterogeneity in driven glassy materials}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal E},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1140/epje/i2010-10609-0},
}
Figure