TL;DR
This study reveals that plasmids, often associated with antibiotic resistance, are surprisingly common in antibiotic-susceptible environmental bacteria. This challenges the assumption that plasmid prevalence is solely driven by antibiotic selection, suggesting that susceptible bacteria may act as crucial reservoirs for the future spread of antibiotic resistance.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The rise of antibiotic-resistant pathogens is a major global health threat. A primary mechanism for the spread of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) is through plasmids, which can be transferred between bacteria. While much research has focused on plasmids in antibiotic-resistant bacteria, the role of plasmids in antibiotic-susceptible bacteria has been largely overlooked. This is a critical knowledge gap because susceptible bacteria, despite not currently harboring ARGs, could acquire them and become resistant. Understanding the prevalence and characteristics of plasmids in these susceptible populations is crucial for predicting and mitigating the future spread of antibiotic resistance.
Methods
The researchers developed a novel bioinformatics tool called PlasmidCounts to identify and quantify large plasmids (over 1000 bp) from short-read whole-genome sequencing data. This tool was calibrated using a smaller dataset of long-read sequencing data to ensure accuracy. They then applied this tool to analyze the genomes of over 200 environmental Enterobacteriaceae isolates. To assess the functional implications of plasmid presence, they conducted conjugation experiments, measuring the efficiency with which recipient strains could acquire new plasmids.
Datasets
The study utilized a dataset of 205 environmental Enterobacteriaceae isolates collected from various sources in New York City and the US Midwest. Whole-genome sequencing data (both short-read and long-read) were generated for these isolates. Additionally, they used a dataset of publicly available completed E. coli genomes with associated plasmid information for validation purposes. The raw sequencing data is deposited on NCBI under BioProject Accession ID PRJNA1190092.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Plasmids are ubiquitous, even in the "unresisted": The most striking finding is that plasmids are just as common in antibiotic-susceptible bacteria as they are in resistant ones. This directly challenges the long-held assumption that antibiotic selection pressure is the primary driver of plasmid prevalence.
- Susceptible strains as potential ARG reservoirs: The high prevalence of plasmids in susceptible bacteria suggests these strains could serve as crucial reservoirs for ARGs. They can acquire ARGs through various mechanisms and then potentially spread them to other bacteria.
- Conjugation isn't hindered by existing plasmids: Contrary to intuition, the presence of existing plasmids did not significantly impede a strain's ability to acquire new plasmids. This implies that susceptible bacteria with plasmids are readily able to accept new genetic material, including ARGs.
- IncF plasmids are not solely linked to resistance: The IncF family of plasmids, known to be associated with ARGs, was found to be abundant in susceptible strains as well, further supporting the idea that plasmids have a broader ecological role beyond just carrying resistance genes.
Key Results
- Out of 205 Enterobacteriaceae isolates, 137 carried zero or one plasmid, while 68 carried two or three large plasmids.
- There was no statistical relationship between the number of plasmids a strain carried and its antibiotic susceptibility percentage.
- Conjugation efficiency experiments showed no association between the number of pre-existing plasmids and a strain's ability to acquire new plasmids.
- The IncF family of plasmids was the most abundant, present in isolates with a wide range of non-resistance (NR) percentages (28% to 100%).
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the accuracy of PlasmidCounts can vary depending on dataset-specific factors like sequencing method and coverage depth. While their calibration with long-read data achieved high accuracy, they suggest that broader parameter sampling might be needed for optimal performance on diverse datasets.
Future work could focus on understanding the specific functions of plasmids in susceptible bacteria and how they might contribute to the acquisition and dissemination of ARGs. Further investigation into the ecological role of these plasmid-carrying susceptible strains in complex microbial communities is also warranted. The study provides a valuable resource of sequenced and phenotyped drug-susceptible Enterobacteriaceae strains for future research into the evolution of antibiotic resistance.
Summary updated