Plant Phylogeny and Growth Form as Drivers of the Altitudinal Variation in Woody Leaf Vein Traits

Ruili Wang, Haoxuan Chen, Xinrui Liu, Zhibo Wang, Jingwen Wen, Shuoxin ZhangFrontiers in Plant Science 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that plant evolutionary history (phylogeny) is a stronger driver of leaf vein structure than climate along an altitudinal gradient. The findings highlight that while altitude affects trees and shrubs differently, the underlying genetic blueprint plays a crucial role in shaping these vital leaf traits, supporting a hypothesis of phylogenetic conservatism.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Leaf veins are critical for plant survival, transporting water and nutrients to support photosynthesis. While we know that leaf vein traits can adapt to environmental conditions, much of the research has focused on how these traits vary across horizontal distances. However, how leaf vein traits change along vertical gradients, like mountain altitudes, and what factors drive these changes, remains less understood. Specifically, the authors aim to disentangle the relative contributions of plant evolutionary history (phylogeny), growth form (tree vs. shrub), and climate (altitude and aridity) in shaping leaf vein traits across an elevational gradient. This is important because understanding these drivers can shed light on plant adaptation strategies and even inform paleoclimate reconstructions.

Methods

The researchers collected leaf samples from 93 woody species across an altitudinal gradient (1,374–3,375 m) in China's Taibai Mountain. They meticulously measured three key leaf vein traits: vein density (VD), vein thickness (VT), and vein volume per unit leaf area (VV). To analyze the drivers of variation, they employed several statistical approaches:

  • Standard and Phylogenetic ANOVA: To compare vein traits between different plant functional groups (trees, shrubs, leaf types) and assess the influence of phylogeny.
  • Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) and Phylogenetic Generalized Least Squares (PGLS) Regression: To examine the relationships between vein traits, particularly the trade-off between VT and VD, considering phylogenetic relationships.
  • Standardized Major Axis (SMA) Estimation: To compare the slopes and elevations of the VT-VD relationship between trees and shrubs.
  • Blomberg's K and Pagel's λ Tests: To quantify phylogenetic signal, indicating how strongly traits are conserved within lineages.
  • Phylogenetically Nested Random Model (using REML): To partition the total variance in vein traits into components attributable to taxonomy (clade, order, family), environmental factors (site, aridity), and residual variation.
  • Linear Mixed-Effects Models: To assess the effects of growth form, aridity index, and their interaction on altitudinal variation in vein traits.

Datasets

The study utilized leaf samples from 93 woody species collected from the Taibai Mountain Nature Reserve. Climatic data (mean annual temperature, mean annual precipitation, and aridity index) were obtained from the WorldClim global database and the Global Aridity Index and Potential Evapotranspiration Climate Database. Phylogenetic information was derived from the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group IV classification and a comprehensive species-level angiosperm phylogeny constructed using phylomatic.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phylogeny Reigns Supreme: The most striking finding is that plant evolutionary history (phylogeny) explains a significantly larger proportion of the variation in leaf vein traits (17.1–86.6%) compared to climate (<0.011–6.3%). This strongly supports the hypothesis that leaf vein networks are largely conserved within lineages.
  • Growth Form Matters, But Differently: Altitude-related trends in vein traits were not uniform. Trees from higher altitudes showed lower vein density but higher thickness and volume, while shrubs exhibited the opposite trend for vein density, with no significant changes in thickness or volume. This suggests distinct adaptive strategies between growth forms.
  • Trees vs. Shrubs: Different Evolutionary Constraints: The influence of phylogeny on vein traits differed between trees and shrubs. Tree vein traits appeared to be more phylogenetically conserved, implying less flexibility for adaptation to environmental changes compared to shrubs.
  • The VT-VD Trade-off is Phylogeny-Dependent: A well-established trade-off between vein thickness and density was observed. However, this relationship became insignificant for all species and trees when phylogenetic effects were accounted for, suggesting that the trade-off might be more a consequence of shared evolutionary history than a direct functional constraint across all lineages.

Key Results

  • Phylogenetic effects explained a substantial portion of the variation in VD (up to 86.6%), VT (up to 74.4%), and VV (up to 17.1%).
  • Climate (aridity index) had a weak influence, explaining less than 10% of the variation in vein traits.
  • Trees at higher altitudes had significantly lower VD (P < 0.01) but higher VT and VV (P < 0.05) compared to trees at lower altitudes.
  • Shrubs at the highest altitude (3,375 m) had significantly higher VD (P = 0.016) than those at lower altitudes.
  • Phylogenetic signals were significant for VD in all species, and for VT and VV in trees, but not in shrubs.
  • A negative correlation between VT and VD was observed, but this relationship was only significant in shrubs after accounting for phylogeny.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Sample Size for Early-Divergent Groups: The study acknowledges that the inclusion of a greater number of early-divergent groups, such as conifers and basal angiosperms, would enhance the understanding of leaf vein trait evolution.
  • Weak Climate Effect: The relatively weak influence of climate on trait variation, despite the significant altitudinal gradient, suggests that other factors, possibly within-site environmental variations or community-level adaptations, might be masking direct trait-climate relationships.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future research should focus on incorporating more early-divergent lineages to better understand evolutionary mechanisms. They also propose that community-aggregated values could be a promising strategy for identifying trait-environment relationships and for predicting them quantitatively, given the limited influence of environmental differences between sites on species-level trait variation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Variation in leaf veins along environmental gradients reflects an important adaptive strategy of plants to the external habitats, because of their crucial roles in maintaining leaf water status and photosynthetic capacity. However, most studies concentrate on a few species and their vein variation across horizontal spatial scale, we know little about how vein traits shift along the vertical scale, e.g., elevational gradient along a mountain, and how such patterns are shaped by plant types and environmental factors. Here, we aimed to investigate the variation in leaf vein traits (i.e., vein density, VD; vein thickness, VT; and vein volume per unit leaf area, VV) of 93 woody species distributed along an elevational gradient (1,374-3,375 m) in a temperate mountain in China. Our results showed that altitude-related trends differed between growth forms. Tree plants from higher altitudes had lower VD but higher VT and VV than those from lower altitude; however, the opposite tend was observed in VD of shrubs, and no significant altitudinal changes in their VT or VV. Plant phylogenetic information at the clade level rather than climate explained most of variation in three leaf vein traits (17.1-86.6% vs. <0.011-6.3% explained variance), supporting the phylogenetic conservatism hypothesis for leaf vein traits. Moreover, the phylogenetic effects on vein traits differed between trees and shrubs, with the vein traits of trees being relatively more conserved. Together, our study provides new picture of leaf vein variation along the altitude, and highlights the importance of taking plant phylogeny into consideration when discussing trait variation from an ecological to a biogeographic scale.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020plant,
  author = {Ruili Wang and Haoxuan Chen and Xinrui Liu and Zhibo Wang and Jingwen Wen and Shuoxin Zhang},
  title = {{Plant Phylogeny and Growth Form as Drivers of the Altitudinal Variation in Woody Leaf Vein Traits}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2019.01735},
}
Figure