Abstract
A ruled surface is a shape swept out by moving a line in 3D space. Due to their simple geometric forms, ruled surfaces have applications in various domains such as architecture and engineering. However, existing methods that use ruled surfaces to approximate a target shape mainly focus on surfaces of non-positive Gaussian curvature. In this paper, we propose a method to compute a piecewise ruled surface that approximates an arbitrary freeform surface. Given the input shape represented as a triangle mesh, we propose a group-sparsity formulation to optimize the mesh shape into an approximately piecewise ruled form, in conjugation with a tangent vector field that indicates the ruling directions. Afterward, we use the optimization result to extract the patch topology and construct the initial rulings. Finally, we further optimize the positions and orientations of the rulings to improve the alignment with the input target shape. We apply our method to a variety of freeform shapes with different topologies and complexity, demonstrating its effectiveness in approximating arbitrary shapes.
Introduction
Freeform surfaces are essential components of modern architectural and industrial design, yet their fabrication remains complex and costly. A common strategy to facilitate manufacturing is to approximate these surfaces using simpler geometric primitives. While much research has focused on developable surfaces—which can be flattened without stretching—these are mathematically restricted to regions with zero Gaussian curvature.
In contrast, ruled surfaces—created by sweeping a straight line through space—offer a broader representational capacity, including surfaces with non-positive Gaussian curvature. This paper addresses the challenge of approximating arbitrary freeform surfaces, including those with positive curvature, using a piecewise ruled representation.
Methodology
The proposed pipeline consists of three primary stages designed to transform a target triangle mesh into a clean, piecewise ruled approximation.
- Joint Optimization of Shape and Direction: The authors introduce a first-order approximation for the ruling direction field, allowing for local variations that piecewise-constant fields cannot capture. A group-sparsity formulation, utilizing the Welsch function, encourages the surface to become ruled while naturally identifying locations for patch seams.
- Topology Extraction: Candidate discontinuities from the optimization stage are refined using graph-cut techniques to establish continuous polyline seams, effectively partitioning the mesh into distinct ruled patches.
- Refinement: The final stage optimizes the positions and orientations of the ruling endpoints to minimize the distance between the approximation and the target mesh while ensuring geometric consistency across patches.
Evaluation and Results
The method was evaluated across a diverse dataset of 3D models, ranging from organic shapes like the Stanford Bunny to complex architectural structures.
Performance Analysis
- Geometric Accuracy: The proposed approach consistently outperformed state-of-the-art developable approximation methods. For example, on the "Kitten" model, the maximum approximation error was reduced by nearly 50% compared to previous benchmarks.
- Manufacturing Simplicity: The method tends to produce shorter total seam lengths, resulting in larger, more continuous patches that are easier to fabricate.
- Computational Efficiency: Despite the complexity of the joint optimization, the pipeline is significantly faster than existing techniques, often reducing processing time by half (e.g., 24.8 minutes for the Kitten model vs. 55.7 minutes for previous methods).
Discussion and Conclusion
By extending approximation techniques beyond developability to general ruled surfaces, this work enables the efficient representation of a wider class of freeform shapes. The use of sparsity-inducing norms provides an automated way to discover optimal patch layouts, reducing the need for manual design intervention.
Future work will focus on addressing current limitations, such as preventing self-intersections in the generated surfaces and incorporating physical constraints related to specific fabrication tools like 5-axis CNC machines. Additionally, exploring G1 (tangent) continuity across seams could further improve the visual quality of the approximations for aesthetic applications.
Summary updated