PID Control of a Superheated Steam Temperature System Based on Integral Gain Scheduling

Xiaobo Cui, Pan Xu, Guohui Song, Haiming Gu, Hui Gu, Liang Wang, Hongxia ZhuEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of maintaining stable superheated steam temperatures in power plants, which is crucial for safety and efficiency, especially under varying load conditions. They propose a novel PID control strategy that dynamically adjusts its integral gain based on operating conditions, demonstrating improved tracking and disturbance rejection performance compared to standard PID and ADRC methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Thermal power units are increasingly tasked with rapid load changes due to the integration of renewable energy sources. This variability significantly impacts the dynamic characteristics of various subsystems, including the superheated steam temperature (SST) system. The SST system is critical for unit safety and economy; fluctuations in its temperature can lead to reduced efficiency and operational risks. Traditional PID controllers, while widely used due to their simplicity, often struggle to maintain optimal performance across a wide range of operating loads, particularly at lower loads where system dynamics change considerably. This paper aims to improve the SST control performance under these challenging, variable load conditions by developing a more adaptive PID control strategy.

Methods

The core of this paper is the proposal of a Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) control strategy with integral gain scheduling. The authors leverage a cascade control structure, which is common in industrial SST systems. This structure involves an inner loop controller (typically proportional) for fast response and an outer loop controller (PID) for overall system regulation.

The key innovation lies in integral gain scheduling. Recognizing that the time constants of the SST system's inert segment change significantly with load, the authors identified the integral gain ($k_{i2}$) as the most impactful parameter to schedule. Instead of scheduling all PID parameters, which would increase complexity, they focused on this single parameter. The scheduling is based on the current operating load.

To ensure the stability and effectiveness of their proposed controller, the authors:

  • Analyzed the SST system's dynamics under different load conditions (100%, 75%, 50%), noting the significant changes in time constants and gains.
  • Derived the PID controller's stability region using the D-partition method to confirm that the scheduled parameters remain within stable operating bounds across the investigated loads.
  • Validated the proposed method through simulations, comparing its performance against a standard PID controller and an Active Disturbance Rejection Control (ADRC) strategy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a well-established mathematical model of a typical multi-load supercritical 600 MW thermal power unit, with transfer functions provided for different operating loads.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integral Gain is Key: The paper highlights that the integral gain of the outer loop PID controller is the most critical parameter to schedule for improving SST control performance across varying loads, due to its significant impact on the system's inert segment dynamics.
  • Simplicity with Effectiveness: By focusing on scheduling only the integral gain, the proposed method achieves improved performance without the complexity of scheduling all PID parameters, making it more practical for industrial implementation.
  • Robustness Across Loads: The integral gain scheduling strategy demonstrably maintains stability and good control performance across a wide range of operating loads (100%, 75%, 50%), addressing a key limitation of fixed-gain PID controllers.
  • Balancing Performance and Complexity: The authors explicitly state their aim to balance control performance with implementation difficulty, leading to the choice of integral gain scheduling as a practical solution.

Key Results

The proposed PID controller with integral gain scheduling demonstrated superior performance in simulations compared to standard PID and ADRC:

  • Tracking Performance: Achieved faster tracking with no overshoot and shorter adjustment times, particularly evident in sinusoidal set-point tracking tests. For example, at 100% load, the proposed PID had the lowest Integral Absolute Error (IAE) of 3.3028 × 10³, compared to PID (4.2103 × 10³) and ADRC (5.7468 × 10³).
  • Disturbance Rejection: Showed satisfactory disturbance rejection capabilities, recovering quickly from step disturbances.
  • Robustness: Monte Carlo simulations with ±10% parameter perturbations confirmed that the proposed method, along with PID and ADRC, exhibits strong robustness to system uncertainties. The proposed PID showed a good balance of performance and concentrated distribution in IAEsp and IAEid plots, indicating good uncertainty handling.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Dependency: While the paper uses a widely accepted model, the effectiveness of the controller is inherently tied to the accuracy of this model. The study acknowledges the difficulty in establishing an accurate mathematical model for SST systems due to simplifications.
  • Simulation-Based Validation: The results are primarily based on simulations. While robust, real-world implementation and validation are the next logical steps.
  • Future Work: The authors express a strong desire to apply the proposed design method to field applications to further verify its effectiveness and promote wider adoption. They also plan to explore further applications of their method.

Summary updated

Abstract

The high-quality operation of a superheated steam temperature (SST) system is a core fact of the safety, economy, and stability of thermal power units. How to improve the control performance of an SST system under large-varying operating conditions is becoming a research hotspot. To solve this challenge, this paper proposes a proportional integral derivative (PID) control strategy based on integral gain scheduling. Based on the introduction of the SST system and classical model under typical operating conditions, the control difficulties of the SST system are analyzed theoretically. Then, a PID control strategy, based on integral gain scheduling, is introduced for the cascade control structure, and the stability of the proposed control strategy is analyzed by calculating the PID stability region. Finally, the effectiveness of the proposed method is verified under nominal and uncertain conditions, where the proposed method could obtain satisfactory tracking and disturbance rejection control performance. Simulation results show the valuable application prospects of the proposed method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cui2022pid,
  author = {Xiaobo Cui and Pan Xu and Guohui Song and Haiming Gu and Hui Gu and Liang Wang and Hongxia Zhu},
  title = {{PID Control of a Superheated Steam Temperature System Based on Integral Gain Scheduling}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15238978},
}
Figure