PHYTOSOCIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF BROWSING VEGETATION IN ASSOCIATION WITH EDAPHIC FACTORS IN THE CHOLISTAN RANGELANDS OF PAKISTAN

Muhammad Abdullah, Muhammad Rafay, Fahad Rasheed, Munir Ahmad, Z. Kamran, Moussa Azhar, Muhammad Adnan Akram, M. Jamalul Ihsan, Liaqat Ali, Touqeer AhmadApplied Ecology and Environmental Research 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Rangelands are temporally and spatially unique socioecological systems supporting natural vegetation and livestock production. The browsing vegetation of Cholistan rangelands in Pakistan is degrading due to multiples stresses; therefore, a phytosociological survey was carried to determine the browse community structure and their association with edaphic features. In this study, a total of 25 browse species belonging to 12 families and 17 genera were identified, among which Chenopodiaceae, Mimosaceae, and Rhamnaceae were found to be the dominant families. According to vegetation analysis, twenty browse communities were documented based on the Importance Value Index (IVI) of each species. Multivariate analysis has delineated three vegetation associations inhabiting the sand-dune, interdune sandy, and clayey saline habitats. Detrended Correspondence Analysis (DCA) of sites has maintained the coherency with vegetation groups identified by cluster analysis (CA). In Canonical Correspondence Analysis (CCA), soil electrical conductivity, sodium, organic matter, phosphorus, and potassium were the most important variables influencing range site distribution. Soil physicochemical analysis revealed that the texture of the sand-dune habitat was sandy; inter-dune was sandy loam, while clayey saline was clayey. This study has revealed that browsing vegetation patterns were predominantly associated with soil attributes. Results showed that organic matter and soil nutrients were better at the inter-dune sandy habitat, whereas pH, electrical conductivity, sodium, and soil moisture were high at the clayey saline habitat. The outcome of this research suggested that browse cover of Cholistan rangelands was under stress and varied according to seasons. Consequently, plant species with low IVIs need priority measures for conservation and those with high IVIs need monitoring ultimately to make these rangeland resources sustainable.

Introduction

Rangelands serve as the backbone of livestock production in arid regions, yet the Cholistan desert in Pakistan is facing severe degradation due to overgrazing, drought, and climate change. While grasses are seasonal, "browse" vegetation (shrubs and trees) provides a critical year-round food source for livestock.

The primary challenge in managing these rangelands is the lack of a precise understanding of the edaphic factors—the specific soil properties—that allow these hardy plants to persist. Without knowing which species thrive in which soil types, conservationists cannot effectively rehabilitate these lands. This paper bridges that gap by linking plant sociology (how species group together) with detailed soil physicochemical analysis.

Methodology

Researchers conducted a two-year field study (2014–2015) across 20 representative sites in the Cholistan desert. The approach combined traditional ecological sampling with robust multivariate statistics:

  • Vegetation Sampling: A combination of Line Transects and Quadrats (1x1m plots) was used to measure plant frequency, density, and cover. These metrics were synthesized into an Importance Value Index (IVI) for each species.
  • Soil Analysis: Soil samples were collected at depths of 0–30 cm and tested for pH, electrical conductivity (EC), ionic content (Na, K, P), organic matter, and texture.
  • Statistical Modeling: Three key techniques were employed: Cluster Analysis (CA) to group sites with similar vegetation; Detrended Correspondence Analysis (DCA) to visualize group relationships along environmental gradients; and Canonical Correspondence Analysis (CCA) to directly correlate specific soil variables with plant distribution.
Map of the Cholistan Desert showing the distribution of the 20 major study sites across the region.

Results and Discussion

The "Three Neighborhoods" of Cholistan

The study revealed that the desert is not a monolith but is composed of three distinct ecological associations driven by soil characteristics:

  1. Sand-dune Association: Dominated by Calligonum polygonoides and Haloxylon salicornicum, these are the "pioneers" of unstable, nutrient-poor sands.
  2. Inter-dune Sandy Association: These represent the "fertile valleys" of the desert. These areas exhibited higher organic matter and nutrients, supporting the most diverse browse communities (13 species).
  3. Clayey Saline Association: These are the "extremophiles." Dominated by salt-tolerant species like Suaeda fruticosa, these areas are defined by high alkalinity and sodium levels.
Representative habitats in the Cholistan rangelands: (a) sand dunes, (b) interdune sandy areas, and (c) clayey saline flats.

Chemical Drivers and Community Stress

The CCA revealed that Electrical Conductivity (EC) and Sodium (Na) were the most influential variables in determining plant distribution. In this arid ecosystem, soil chemistry is destiny. For instance, organic matter was significantly higher in inter-dune areas (0.74%) compared to sand dunes (0.32%) or saline flats (0.20%).

Furthermore, the documentation of 20 distinct browse communities highlighted varying levels of dominance. The highest IVI was found in the clayey saline flats for Suaeda fruticosa (79.02), underscoring its specialized dominance in harsh conditions. However, many other species exhibited low IVIs, signaling that the ecosystem is under significant environmental and anthropogenic stress.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study proves that vegetation patterns in the Cholistan rangelands are predominantly dictated by soil attributes. While providing a vital baseline, the research highlights the need for further exploration into biotic factors, such as grazing patterns, and long-term temporal monitoring to account for multi-year drought cycles.

Future conservation efforts should prioritize species with low IVIs and focus on maintaining the soil health of the relatively nutrient-rich inter-dune habitats. Integrating remote sensing data with these ground-level findings will be essential for scaling rehabilitation efforts across the entire desert landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rangelands are temporally and spatially unique socioecological systems supporting natural vegetation and livestock production. The browsing vegetation of Cholistan rangelands in Pakistan is degrading due to multiples stresses therefore a phytosociological survey was carried to determine the browse community structure and their association with edaphic features. In this study a total of 25 browse species belonging to 12 families and 17 genera were identified among which Chenopodiaceae, Mimosaceae, and Rhamnaceae were found to be the dominant families. According to vegetation analysis, twenty browse communities were documented based on the Importance Value Index (IVI) of each species. Multivariate analysis has delineated three vegetation associations inhabiting the sand-dune, interdune sandy and clayey saline habitats. Detrended Correspondence Analysis (DCA) of sites has maintained the coherency with vegetation groups identified by cluster analysis (CA). In Canonical Correspondence Analysis (CCA) soil electrical conductivity, sodium, organic matter, phosphorus, potassium were most important variables influencing range site distribution. Soil physicochemical analysis revealed that texture of sand-dune habitat was sandy; inter-dune was sandy loam while clayey saline was clayey. This study has revealed that browsing vegetation pattern was predominantly associated to soil attributes. Results showed that organic matter, and soil nutrients were better at inter-dune sandy habitat whereas pH, electrical conductivity, sodium, and soil moisture were high at clayey saline habitat. The outcome of this research suggested that browse cover of Cholistan rangelands was under stress and varied according to seasons. Consequently, plant species with low IVIs need priority measures for conservation and those with high IVIs need monitoring ultimately to make these rangeland resources sustainable.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abdullah2020phytosociological,
  author = {Muhammad Abdullah and Muhammad Rafay and Fahad Rasheed and Munir Ahmad and Z. KAMRAN and Moussa Azhar and Muhammad Adnan Akram and M. Jamalul Ihsan and Liaqat Ali and Touqeer Ahmad},
  title = {{PHYTOSOCIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF BROWSING VEGETATION IN ASSOCIATION WITH EDAPHIC FACTORS IN THE CHOLISTAN RANGELANDS OF PAKISTAN}},
  booktitle = {Applied Ecology and Environmental Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.15666/aeer/1806\_78137827},
}
Figure