Traditional ecological forecasting relies heavily on the "climate envelope" — the idea that if we know the temperature and precipitation a species prefers, we can map its future home. However, as Jiang et al. (2016) and Ren et al. (2020) argue, these purely abiotic models often fail because they treat species as if they live in a vacuum. In reality, a species' survival is dictated not just by the weather, but by a complex web of biological relationships: competition for resources, the presence of predators, and the availability of pollinators.
The Gap Between Potential and Realized Niches
The core problem in modern species distribution modeling (SDM) is the distinction between the fundamental niche (where a species could live based on climate) and the realized niche (where it actually lives). Hou et al. (2025) point out that relying solely on bioclimatic variables leads to an overestimation of habitat suitability. For example, an area might be climatically perfect for a rare orchid, but if the soil pH is wrong or the land has been urbanized, the species cannot survive.
Dong (2024) highlights that many models assume a "static niche," ignoring how species communities restructure. If a species is forced to migrate due to warming but its primary food source or pollinator does not move at the same pace, the predicted "suitable" habitat becomes a biological desert.
Competition and Physical Displacement
One of the most significant biotic filters is interspecific competition. He et al. (2008) emphasize that modeling species in isolation overlooks how they physically displace one another while competing for light, space, and nutrients. When two species have high niche overlap, their competitive dynamics—rather than climate alone—often determine which one persists in a specific zone.
This is particularly evident in fragile ecosystems. Yan et al. (2015) found that while precipitation drives the biomass of annual plants in dry steppes, their long-term stability is governed by competition for light and nutrients. Similarly, Jinfeng et al. (2025) note that aquatic plant restoration often fails because models ignore competition with epiphytic algae or herbivory by local fauna.
Trophic Mismatches and Predator-Prey Dynamics
Biotic interactions also include the "vertical" relationships of the food web. Babkina et al. (2024) demonstrate that for solitary wasps, a bioclimatic envelope is only viable if it overlaps with the range of their prey. If climate change causes a synchronization break between predator and prey, the predator's range will contract even if the temperature remains ideal.
Xiao et al. (2025) extend this to agricultural pests, noting that the presence of natural predators and the shifting availability of host plants are just as critical as temperature in determining where a pest will spread. Without these factors, models risk doubling the predicted range of invasive species by ignoring the biological checks and balances that limit their expansion.
Toward Multi-Species and Community Modeling
To bridge this gap, researchers are moving toward models that account for the "who interacts with whom" alongside the "where." Zarnetske et al. (2017) argue for integrating dispersal limitations and trophic interactions into landscape ecology to better forecast biodiversity shifts.
New computational frameworks are making this possible. Chen et al. (2017) developed Deep Multi-Species Embedding (DMSE), which uses neural networks to model hundreds of species simultaneously. By creating high-dimensional embeddings that capture how species co-occur, these models can implicitly learn the "social context" of a habitat—capturing predation and competition that single-species models miss. Similarly, Kalmbach et al. (2017) show that by learning community co-occurrence patterns, we can even predict the presence of rare species that haven't been directly observed, provided we understand the abiotic and biotic context they inhabit.
Key Foundational Work
Exploring consensus in 21st century projections of climatically suitable areas for African vertebrates (2011) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.
Auto-multicategorical regression model for the distribution of vegetation (2008) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.