TL;DR
This paper presents a physical modeling study of tidal stream turbine wakes under yawed conditions. The research reveals how turbine yaw affects wake deflection and velocity recovery, crucial for optimizing tidal energy arrays. Key findings show that upstream non-yawed turbines can significantly limit downstream wake steering, while yawed downstream turbines can influence both upstream and downstream wakes.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Tidal stream energy is a promising renewable source, but its efficient extraction, especially in arrays, is challenged by the variability of ocean currents. These variations can cause turbines to operate at yaw angles (rotor plane not perpendicular to the flow). This yawing degrades turbine performance and deflects the wake, impacting downstream turbines. Understanding and predicting this "wake steering" is vital for designing efficient and cost-effective tidal energy farms, particularly in confined areas where turbines are often placed close together. While wake steering is well-studied in wind energy, its specific implications for tidal turbines, especially in array configurations, require further investigation. This paper aims to fill this gap by experimentally studying the wake structures of yawed tidal stream turbines, both individually and in a two-turbine array.
Methods
The researchers conducted experiments in a recirculating flow flume at Hohai University. They used two main scenarios:
- Single Turbine: A single 3-bladed tidal turbine model (0.3m diameter) was tested at various yaw angles (0° to 30°).
- Two-Turbine Array: Two identical turbines were placed in alignment with a 5D (five turbine diameters) streamwise separation. One turbine was kept non-yawed while the other was yawed, or vice-versa, to study inter-turbine wake interactions.
Key measurements included:
- Thrust Force: Measured using an ATI-gamma six-axis force-torque sensor to quantify the forces acting on the turbine.
- Wake Velocity: Measured using a downward-facing Nortek Vectrino Profiler to map the flow velocity distribution in the turbine's wake at various downstream locations.
Data analysis involved phase-averaging for velocity measurements and calculating parameters like normalized velocity deficit and turbulence intensity. The "Centre of Mass" method was employed to track the wake centerline.
Datasets
This study is based on experimental data collected in a controlled laboratory environment. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation. The generated data, comprising thrust force and wake velocity measurements under various yaw conditions, is presented in the paper and can be considered a new benchmark for validating numerical models of yawed tidal turbine wakes.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Yawing Reduces Streamwise Thrust: As expected, increasing the yaw angle of a tidal turbine leads to a decrease in its streamwise thrust force and an increase in the spanwise force. This is a fundamental consequence of the rotor plane's orientation relative to the flow.
- Wake Steering is Proportional to Yaw: For a single turbine, the wake deflection and the rate at which the velocity deficit recovers increase proportionally with the yaw angle. This means a larger yaw angle leads to a more pronounced and further-reaching wake steer.
- Upstream Turbine Dominance: In a two-turbine array, a non-yawed upstream turbine significantly limits the wake steering of a yawed downstream turbine. This suggests that the upstream turbine's wake has a substantial influence on the downstream flow field.
- Downstream Turbine Influence: Interestingly, a yawed downstream turbine can influence the steering of both the upstream and downstream wakes. This highlights the complex interactions within an array.
- Turbulence Intensity Asymmetry: Yawing creates asymmetric turbulence intensity distributions in the wake, with higher values often appearing on one side, correlating with the direction of wake steering.
Key Results
- Thrust Force Reduction: For a single turbine and the upstream turbine in a two-turbine setup, thrust force decreased by approximately 12% at a 30° yaw angle compared to the non-yawed case. The downstream yawed turbine experienced a significant reduction of up to 46% in streamwise force, likely due to being in the wake of the upstream turbine.
- Wake Deflection: The maximum spanwise shift of the wake centerline for a single yawed turbine increased from 0.11D at 10° yaw to 0.19D at 30° yaw.
- Velocity Recovery: In the far wake, velocity recovery rates were generally higher for yawed turbines compared to non-yawed ones, indicating that the yawed turbine extracts less energy, thus disturbing the wake less.
- Array Effects: In the two-turbine scenario, an upstream non-yawed turbine reduced the loads on a yawed downstream turbine by over 50%. The wake steering of a yawed turbine was limited by the presence of a non-yawed turbine, either upstream or downstream.
Limitations and Future Work
- Reynolds Number Scaling: The authors acknowledge that the experimental Reynolds number was significantly lower than that expected in realistic tidal conditions. This scaling effect might mean viscous forces had a disproportionately larger impact in the lab.
- Two-Dimensional Assumption: The study focused on the horizontal plane at hub height. Future work could explore three-dimensional wake structures.
- Numerical Model Validation: The authors plan to use these experimental results to validate a 2D depth-averaged numerical model (Thetis) and further investigate yaw control strategies for optimal turbine array layouts. They also aim to integrate these findings into optimization algorithms for array design.
Summary updated