Phylogenetic and functional adaption of the gastrointestinal microbiome of goats kept at high altitude (4800 m) under intensive or extensive rearing conditions

Ke Zhang, Chong He, Yangbin Xu, Chenguang Zhang, Chao Li, Jing Xu, Meili Wang, Yuxin Yang, Langda Suo, Peter Kalds, Jiuzhou Song, Xiaolong Wang, Daniel Brügger, Yujiang Wu, Yulin ChenResearch Square 2020 · DOI

Introduction

The Tibetan Plateau, often called the "Roof of the World," presents one of the most extreme environments for livestock, characterized by low oxygen and sparse vegetation. Ruminants like the Tibetan goat have evolved to thrive here by relying on their gastrointestinal microbiome to convert fibrous plants into energy. As livestock management shifts from traditional extensive grazing to intensive drylot feeding, understanding the systemic microbial response across the entire digestive tract—including the rumen and the hindgut—is essential for optimizing animal health and productivity.

Methods

This study evaluated 50 half-sibling female Tibetan goats reared at an altitude of approximately 4,800 meters. The animals were divided into two groups: an extensive grazing group (natural alpine pasture) and an intensive drylot group (high-energy concentrate). At one year of age, samples were collected from the rumen, cecum, and colon, targeting both luminal contents and mucosal layers. The researchers utilized 16S rRNA gene sequencing for taxonomic profiling and metagenomic shotgun sequencing for functional analysis, generating a comprehensive catalog of 3.78 million non-redundant genes.

Results and Discussion

Metabolic Shifts and Growth Performance

Intensive drylot feeding significantly enhanced growth, with goats achieving a 48.5% higher yearling weight compared to their grazing counterparts. However, this productivity came at a metabolic cost. Drylot goats exhibited a sharp decline in rumen pH to approximately 5.04, indicating subacute ruminal acidosis. This shift was accompanied by a narrower acetate-to-propionate ratio, reflecting the fermentation of high-starch concentrates.

The Rumen-Hindgut Dynamic

While the acidic environment of the drylot rumen led to decreased microbial diversity, a compensatory effect was observed in the hindgut. The cecum and colon of drylot goats showed increased microbial diversity and higher bacterial counts. This suggests that high-grain diets lead to an influx of undegraded complex polysaccharides and starches into the lower digestive tract, fueling a secondary microbial community that differs significantly from the rumen.

Adaptation to Scarcity: The Methane Paradox and Bacitracin

Interestingly, grazing goats—despite consuming a high-fiber diet typically associated with high methane production—showed lower counts of Methanobrevibacter and fewer genes related to hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis. This "methane paradox" likely stems from the extreme energy scarcity of alpine pastures, which limits the substrates available for methanogens.

Furthermore, the grazing microbiome was enriched with bacitracin biosynthesis genes. Bacitracin, a natural antibiotic produced by Bacillus species, may serve as a specialized adaptation to harsh environmental stressors, potentially aiding host survival in the absence of high-quality nutrition.

Environmental and Health Implications

A concerning finding was the significant increase in Antibiotic Resistance Genes (ARGs) within the digestive tracts of drylot animals, particularly resistance to tetracyclines and macrolides. This occurred despite no direct antibiotic treatment during the study, suggesting that intensive rearing environments themselves may act as reservoirs for resistance.

Conclusion

This research highlights the profound impact of management systems on the microbial landscape of high-altitude ruminants. While intensive feeding maximizes growth, it alters the delicate balance of the gut microbiome and increases the prevalence of ARGs. Conversely, the grazing microbiome reveals unique evolutionary strategies, such as reduced methanogenesis and natural antibiotic production, which are critical for survival in extreme environments. These insights provide a foundation for developing sustainable livestock practices that balance productivity with ecological and animal health.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background: </bold>The gut microbiota composition is influenced by the diet as well as the environment in both wild and domestic animals. Although the rumen microbiome in herbivorous ruminants has been studied intensively, there is a lack of data regarding the simultaneous adaption of the rumen and hindgut metagenome as affected by different feeding systems in extreme environments. Therefore, we studied the effects of two feeding systems, grazing and drylot, on the rumen and hindgut microbiome composition of semi-feral Tibetan goats kept at high altitude (~4800 m). 16S rRNA gene sequencing and metagenomic analysis were conducted on DNA extracts from the contents and mucosal layer of different sections of the gastrointestinal tract (rumen, cecum, and colon).<bold>Results:</bold> Intensive drylot feeding resulted in significantly higher zootechnical performance, narrower ruminal acetate: propionate ratios and a drop in the average rumen pH at slaughter to ~5.04. In response, the ruminal microbiome of drylot goats expressed a significantly lower diversity compared to the grazing animals. Otherwise, hindgut microbial adaption appeared to more diverse in the drylot group suggesting a higher influx of undegraded complex non-starch polysaccharides from the rumen. Despite their higher fiber levels in the diet, grazing goats exhibited lower counts of <italic>Methanobrevibacter</italic> and genes associated with the hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis pathway, presumably reflecting the scarce dietary conditions (low energy density) when rearing goats on pasture from extreme alpine environments. These conditions appeared to promote a relevant abundance of bacitracin genes, which potentially benefits the host's adaption to harsh environmental conditions. In parallel, we recognized a significant increase in the abundance of antibiotic resistance genes in the digestive tracts of drylot animals.<bold>Conclusion: </bold>In summary, this study provides a deeper insight in the phylogenetic and functional adaption of the gastrointestinal microbiome of goats subject to intensive drylot and extensive pasture rearing conditions at high altitude.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2020phylogenetic,
  author = {Ke Zhang and Chong He and Yangbin Xu and Chenguang Zhang and Chao Li and Jing Xu and Meili Wang and Yuxin Yang and Langda Suo and Peter Kalds and Jiuzhou Song and Xiaolong Wang and Daniel Brügger and Yujiang Wu and Yulin Chen},
  title = {{Phylogenetic and functional adaption of the gastrointestinal microbiome of goats kept at high altitude (4800 m) under intensive or extensive rearing conditions}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-61555/v1},
}
Figure