Phase Contrast Image-Based Rapid Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing of Bacteria in Liquid Culture Media

Xiaonan Zhang, Xuenian Wang, Yaqing Bao, Zhiyuan Shen, Yang Xu, Bei Wang, Haowei Zhang, Tian Guan, Yonghong He

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, rapid antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) method that uses phase contrast microscopy and an in-house centrifuge to determine the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of antibiotics against bacteria in liquid culture within 4 hours. This significantly reduces the time compared to traditional methods, offering a promising solution for faster clinical diagnostics and point-of-care applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The escalating global threat of antibiotic resistance necessitates rapid and accurate antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST). Traditional AST methods, such as disk diffusion and broth dilution, typically require 16-24 hours to yield results. This delay can lead to the inappropriate use of antibiotics, contributing to the further development of resistant strains and prolonging patient recovery. The need for faster AST methods is critical for timely and effective therapeutic interventions, especially in clinical settings and for point-of-care diagnostics. Existing rapid AST methods often involve complex microfluidic devices or solid media, which can be costly, difficult to fabricate, or less ideal for nutrient and antibiotic exchange compared to liquid media.

Methods

The core innovation of this study lies in a two-step process:

  1. Centrifugation for Bacterial Enrichment: An in-house built centrifuge is used to rapidly concentrate bacteria from a liquid culture onto the inner wall of the bottom surface of a counting plate. This effectively creates a two-dimensional bacterial distribution, ensuring that the bacteria are within the focal plane of the microscope, minimizing the impact of settling over time.
  2. Phase Contrast Microscopy and Image Analysis: A custom-built phase contrast microscope is employed to track bacterial growth in real-time under varying concentrations of antibiotics. Phase contrast microscopy is chosen for its ability to visualize unstained biological samples, reducing sample preparation and potential damage. The acquired images are then processed using adaptive thresholding, background subtraction, and Gaussian filtering to segment bacteria from the background. The normalized growth rate is calculated based on the change in bacterial area over time, allowing for the determination of the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC).

Datasets

The study utilized E. coli (ATCC 25922) as the model bacterium. The experiments were conducted using Luria-Bertani (LB) liquid medium and a drug-sensitive inoculation medium (CAMHB turbidity type). Tigecycline was used as the antibiotic for testing. The results were compared against the gold standard broth micro-dilution method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Centrifugation as a Simple Enrichment Strategy: The paper demonstrates that a simple centrifugation step can effectively concentrate bacteria for imaging, overcoming the challenge of dispersed bacteria in liquid cultures without requiring complex microfluidic fabrication.
  • Phase Contrast Microscopy for Label-Free Imaging: The use of phase contrast microscopy allows for label-free visualization of bacterial growth, simplifying the experimental setup and reducing potential interference from labels.
  • Rapid MIC Determination: The combination of rapid bacterial enrichment and real-time imaging enables MIC determination in as little as 4 hours, a significant improvement over traditional methods.
  • Potential for High-Throughput: The design of the counting plate mount, which accommodates multiple counting plates, suggests a straightforward path towards high-throughput screening of various bacteria-antibiotic combinations.

Key Results

The study successfully demonstrated the efficacy of their rapid AST method using E. coli and tigecycline.

  • MIC Determination: The method accurately determined the MIC of tigecycline for E. coli to be 0.125 µg/mL, which was consistent with the results obtained from the gold standard broth micro-dilution method.
  • Time Efficiency: The proposed method achieved MIC results within 4 hours, a substantial reduction from the typical 16-24 hours required by conventional methods.
  • Image Processing Effectiveness: The image processing pipeline effectively segmented bacteria from the background, enabling accurate calculation of bacterial growth rates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Bacterial Clumping: The authors acknowledge that as bacteria grow over time, they can clump together, making clear imaging and accurate counting of bacterial growth rates more challenging, potentially increasing the standard deviation of experimental results.
  • Scope of Testing: While E. coli and tigecycline were used as a proof of concept, the method's applicability to a wider range of bacterial species and antibiotic classes would require further validation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that the method's low cost and ease of implementation make it suitable for large-scale promotion and point-of-care applications. Further work could focus on optimizing the system for high-throughput detection and expanding its use to diverse clinical scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Currently, the world is facing the problem of bacterial resistance, which threatens public health, and bacterial antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) plays an important role in biomedicine, dietary safety and aquaculture. Traditional AST methods take a long time, usually 16–24 h, and cannot meet the demand for rapid diagnosis in the clinic, so rapid AST methods are needed to shorten the detection time. In this study, by using an in-house built centrifuge to centrifuge bacteria in a liquid medium onto the inner wall of the bottom surface of a counting plate, and using a phase contrast microscope to track bacterial growth under the effect of different antibiotic concentrations, the results of the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of bacteria under the effect of antibiotics can be obtained in as early as 4 h. We used a combination of E. coli and tigecycline and obtained MIC results that were consistent with those obtained using the gold standard broth micro-dilution method, demonstrating the validity of our method; due to the time advantage, the complete set can be used in the future for point of care and clinical applications, helping physicians to quickly obtain the MIC used to inhibit bacterial growth.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023phase,
  author = {Xiaonan Zhang and Xuenian Wang and Yaqing Bao and Zhiyuan Shen and Yang Xu and Bei Wang and Haowei Zhang and Tian Guan and Yonghong He},
  title = {{Phase Contrast Image-Based Rapid Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing of Bacteria in Liquid Culture Media}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=NuTww86GC01},
}
Figure