PHA*: Finding the Shortest Path with A* in An Unknown Physical Environment

Ariel Felner, Roni Stern, Sarit Kraus, Asaph Ben-Yair, Nathan S. Netanyahu

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Physical-A (PHA) algorithm, a novel approach for finding the shortest path in unknown physical environments where an agent must explore to discover the path. PHA adapts the standard A search by measuring complexity in terms of agent travel effort rather than node expansions, offering optimized strategies for both single and multi-agent scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of finding the shortest path between two points in an environment that is not fully known beforehand. Unlike traditional pathfinding problems where the graph is pre-defined, here a mobile agent must actively explore the environment to discover its structure (nodes and edges). The goal is not just to reach a destination quickly, but to identify the optimal path for future use, which requires a more strategic exploration process. This is crucial in scenarios like military scouting or network routing where upfront mapping is impractical or impossible.

Methods

The core contribution is the Physical-A (PHA) algorithm, a two-level approach:

  • High-Level: This component functions like a standard A* search, selecting the next node to expand based on an admissible heuristic (Euclidean distance to the goal).
  • Low-Level: This is a navigation algorithm responsible for physically moving the agent to the selected high-level node. Crucially, the low-level algorithm can explore new nodes during navigation, gathering information about the environment.

Several variations are proposed:

  • Low-Level Navigation:
    • Simple: Tree path, shortest known path, aerial path.
  • DFS-based: Positional DFS (P-DFS), Directional DFS (D-DFS), and A*DFS. These explore new nodes during navigation.
  • Improved DFS (I-A*DFS): This variant prioritizes visiting nodes that are not only on the path to the target but also have a low f-value (indicating they are likely to be expanded soon by the high-level A*).
  • High-Level Enhancement:
    • Window A (WinA): Instead of always picking the single best node, WinA* considers a "window" of k best nodes and selects one based on a combined cost function (f-value * distance to agent). This allows for more intelligent exploration of nearby nodes.

The paper also extends PHA to the Multi-Agent Physical A (MAPHA)* algorithm, with two main strategies:

  • Fuel-Efficient: Agents move one at a time, prioritizing exploration and knowledge sharing.
  • Time-Efficient: All agents move simultaneously to minimize overall search time.

Datasets

The paper uses Delaunay graphs for experimental evaluation. These graphs are derived from Delaunay triangulations of points generated by a Poisson point process. The authors also consider variations:

  • Regular Delaunay graphs: Each node is connected to all its neighbors.
  • Sparse Delaunay graphs: Created by randomly deleting approximately 60% of edges from regular graphs.
  • Dense Delaunay graphs: Created by adding 400 random edges to regular graphs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Travel Effort as Complexity: The fundamental shift from node expansion count to agent travel distance as the primary measure of complexity is key for real-world physical environments.
  • Exploration During Navigation: Integrating exploration into the low-level navigation phase (as in DFS-based methods and I-A*DFS) is significantly more efficient than relying solely on the high-level search to discover new nodes.
  • Proactive Exploration of Promising Nodes: The I-ADFS and WinA enhancements highlight the benefit of visiting nodes that are not strictly the "best" according to A* but are nearby and have a good f-value, as this can significantly reduce future travel costs.
  • Multi-Agent Coordination: Distributing agents effectively (either to minimize fuel or time) is crucial for performance in multi-agent scenarios, and the proposed allocation functions balance exploration, proximity, and load.

Key Results

  • Single Agent: The I-ADFS low-level algorithm consistently outperformed simpler navigation methods, reducing search cost by over 10x compared to the most basic approach and over 2x compared to ADFS. WinA as a high-level enhancement provided a further improvement of up to 30% over I-ADFS alone.
  • Optimality: PHA and its enhanced versions are proven to return the optimal path, leveraging the properties of admissible A.
  • Multi-Agent:
    • Fuel-Efficient: Adding more agents initially decreases fuel consumption but plateaus or increases beyond an optimal point, suggesting a trade-off.
  • Time-Efficient: Increasing the number of agents consistently reduces search time, converging towards the shortest path length. For example, with 14 agents, search time was reduced from 2.3 to 0.7 for a 500-node graph.
  • Combined Cost: The algorithms for combined fuel and time objectives showed that an optimal number of agents exists for various weight ratios, and the improved combined algorithm generally performed better by selecting moving agents more strategically.
  • Graph Types: The relative performance of algorithms remained consistent across regular, sparse, and dense Delaunay graphs, though sparse graphs generally required more travel effort.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumption of Instant Neighbor Discovery: The paper assumes that when an agent reaches a node, it can instantly learn the locations of all its neighbors. The authors suggest future work to explore models where node locations are only known after the agent physically visits them.
  • Centralized Knowledge Sharing: The multi-agent algorithms assume a centralized model where all agents share knowledge instantly. Future work could explore more distributed or decentralized communication paradigms, including models with no communication (ant-robotics).
  • Fixed Number of Agents: The combined algorithms assume the number of agents is determined a priori. Future research could investigate dynamically adjusting the number of agents.
  • Theoretical Bounds: While empirical results are strong, the paper notes the absence of a theoretical bound on the actual cost of PHA*.
  • Other Graph Problems: The authors suggest that the traveling agent mechanism could be adapted to solve other graph problems like Minimum Spanning Tree or Traveling Salesman Problem.

Summary updated

Abstract

We address the problem of finding the shortest path between two points in an unknown real physical environment, where a traveling agent must move around in the environment to explore unknown territory. We introduce the Physical-A* algorithm (PHA*) for solving this problem. PHA* expands all the mandatory nodes that A* would expand and returns the shortest path between the two points. However, due to the physical nature of the problem, the complexity of the algorithm is measured by the traveling effort of the moving agent and not by the number of generated nodes, as in standard A*. PHA* is presented as a two-level algorithm, such that its high level, A*, chooses the next node to be expanded and its low level directs the agent to that node in order to explore it. We present a number of variations for both the high-level and low-level procedures and evaluate their performance theoretically and experimentally. We show that the travel cost of our best variation is fairly close to the optimal travel cost, assuming that the mandatory nodes of A* are known in advance. We then generalize our algorithm to the multi-agent case, where a number of cooperative agents are designed to solve the problem. Specifically, we provide an experimental implementation for such a system. It should be noted that the problem addressed here is not a navigation problem, but rather a problem of finding the shortest path between two points for future usage.
BibTeX
@article{felner2004pha,
  author = {Ariel Felner and Roni Stern and Sarit Kraus and Asaph Ben-Yair and Nathan S. Netanyahu},
  title = {{PHA*: Finding the Shortest Path with A* in An Unknown Physical Environment}},
  journal = {J. Artif. Intell. Res.},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1613/jair.1373},
}
Figure