Personalizing or Not: Dynamically Personalized Federated Learning with Incentives

Zichen Ma, Yu Lu, Wenye Li, Shuguang Cui

TL;DR

This paper introduces DyPFL, a novel federated learning approach that dynamically incentivizes clients to personalize their models. It addresses the issue that not all clients benefit equally from personalization, proposing a "personalization rate" metric and an optimization strategy that encourages participation when beneficial, while allowing clients to default to the global model otherwise.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Federated Learning (FL) allows multiple clients to collaboratively train a machine learning model without sharing their private data. A key challenge in FL is data heterogeneity across clients, meaning their data distributions can be very different (non-IID). Personalized FL aims to tackle this by training a unique model for each client, in addition to a global model. However, existing personalized FL methods often assume that all clients are willing to participate in personalization. This is a flawed assumption because training a personalized model requires extra computational and communication resources, and it might not always yield better results than the global model for a given client. If a client's personalized model performs worse than the global one, they have no incentive to invest the extra effort. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a framework that dynamically encourages clients to personalize only when it's beneficial for them, thereby improving overall participation and model performance.

Methods

The core of DyPFL lies in its novel approach to incentivizing personalization. Instead of assuming universal participation, DyPFL introduces a "personalization rate" metric, defined as the fraction of clients willing to train personalized models. This willingness is determined by whether a client's personalized model performs better than the global model.

To optimize this, DyPFL reformulates the objective to maximize this personalization rate. It uses a differentiable sigmoid function to approximate the binary decision of whether a client is incentivized, allowing for gradient-based optimization. The algorithm then jointly optimizes the global model (through standard federated aggregation) and the personalized models for each client. The update rule for personalized models is designed to be incentive-dependent, meaning the learning rate and update direction are influenced by the gap between the personalized and global model performance. This ensures that clients are encouraged to personalize when the gap is positive (personalized model is better) and are less pushed to do so when the gap is negative or zero. DyPFL is presented as a wrapper that can be applied to various FL aggregation schemes and non-convex objectives.

Datasets

The paper evaluates DyPFL on several datasets across different domains:

  • Image Classification:
    • FEMNIST (non-IID and IID settings)
    • Celeba (non-IID and IID settings)
  • Natural Language Processing (NLP):
    • Reddit (next-word prediction, non-IID and IID settings)
    • Shakespeare (next-character prediction, non-IID and IID settings)
  • Real-world Medical Dataset:
    • RSNA Intracranial Hemorrhage Detection dataset (used for a case study)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Personalization Rate" is Crucial: The paper highlights that simply assuming clients will personalize is unrealistic. Quantifying and optimizing the "personalization rate" is key to successful personalized FL in heterogeneous environments.
  • Incentives Drive Participation: DyPFL demonstrates that by dynamically adjusting incentives based on performance gains, clients are more likely to engage in personalization, leading to better overall system performance.
  • Flexibility is Key: DyPFL is designed as a wrapper, making it adaptable to various FL aggregation methods and model architectures, which is a significant practical advantage.
  • Robustness to Heterogeneity: The method shows resilience to variations in local epochs, batch sizes, and even dropped clients, suggesting its practical applicability in real-world, noisy environments.

Key Results

  • Improved Personalization Rate: DyPFL consistently achieved a higher personalization rate across all tested non-IID benchmark datasets, often by 5% or more compared to baselines.
  • Enhanced Testing Accuracy: DyPFL not only increased personalization but also achieved higher average testing accuracy on preferred models, with improvements ranging from 3.2% to 11.1% over baselines on different datasets.
  • Robustness: The method demonstrated strong performance and convergence even with heterogeneous local epochs, varying batch sizes, and up to 50% of clients being dropped per round.
  • Real-world Application: In a case study on intracranial hemorrhage detection, DyPFL outperformed baselines by 10% for different numbers of hospitals, showcasing its potential in healthcare.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theoretical Analysis Scope: The theoretical analysis primarily focuses on the convergence of the global model and personalized models under specific assumptions (e.g., Lc-continuous and Ls-smooth functions). While promising, further analysis for more complex scenarios might be beneficial.
  • Wrapper Nature: While being a wrapper is a strength, its performance is still dependent on the underlying FL aggregation and optimization schemes. Future work could explore integrating DyPFL with advanced FL techniques for even greater gains.
  • Further Improvements: The authors suggest that DyPFL can be further improved by incorporating advanced FL aggregation or optimization schemes for non-IID settings. Exploring more sophisticated incentive mechanisms beyond the current performance-based approach could also be a future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Personalized federated learning (FL) facilitates collaborations between multiple clients to learn personalized models without sharing private data. The mechanism mitigates the statistical heterogeneity commonly encountered in the system, i.e., non-IID data over different clients. Existing personalized algorithms generally assume all clients volunteer for personalization. However, potential participants might still be reluctant to personalize models since they might not work well. In this case, clients choose to use the global model instead. To avoid making unrealistic assumptions, we introduce the personalization rate, measured as the fraction of clients willing to train personalized models, into federated settings and propose DyPFL. This dynamically personalized FL technique incentivizes clients to participate in personalizing local models while allowing the adoption of the global model when it performs better. We show that the algorithmic pipeline in DyPFL guarantees good convergence performance, allowing it to outperform alternative personalized methods in a broad range of conditions, including variation in heterogeneity, number of clients, local epochs, and batch sizes.
BibTeX
@misc{ma2022personalizing,
  author = {Zichen Ma and Yu Lu and Wenye Li and Shuguang Cui},
  title = {{Personalizing or Not: Dynamically Personalized Federated Learning with Incentives}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2208.06192},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.06192},
}
Figure