Persistent flat band splitting and strong selective band renormalization in a kagome magnet thin film

Zheng Ren, Jianwei Huang, Hengxin Tan, Ananya Biswas, Aki Pulkkinen, Yichen Zhang, Yaofeng Xie, Ziqin Yue, Lei Chen, Fang Xie, Kevin Allen, Han Wu, Qingguang Ren, Anil Rajapitamahuni, Asish K. Kundu, E. Vescovo, Junichiro Kono, E. Morosan, Pengcheng Dai, Jianxin Zhu, Qimiao Si, J. Minář, Binghai Yan, Ming Yi

This research paper, recently published by a collaborative team led by Rice University, explores the complex electronic landscape of FeSn, a magnetic kagome material. By combining high-quality thin-film synthesis with advanced spectroscopy, the authors provide a new perspective on how magnetism and electron correlations interact in these topologically interesting lattices.

TL;DR

Researchers have demonstrated that in the kagome magnet FeSn, magnetic band splitting persists well above the ordering temperature, proving that its magnetism arises from local moments rather than itinerant electrons. They also discovered a massive, orbital-specific "slowing down" of electrons (renormalization), linking the physics of kagome lattices to that of high-temperature superconductors and twisted bilayer graphene.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Kagome lattices—named after a traditional Japanese basket-weave pattern—are a playground for condensed matter physics. Their geometry causes "destructive interference" for moving electrons, resulting in flat bands where electrons sit nearly still. This lack of kinetic energy makes electron-electron interactions (correlations) much more dominant.

A major debate in the field is the nature of magnetism in these materials:

  1. Itinerant (Stoner) Magnetism: Magnetism emerges from the collective behavior of moving electrons. In this scenario, the "splitting" of energy bands between spin-up and spin-down electrons should vanish when the material is heated above its magnetic ordering temperature ($T_N$).
  2. Local Moment Magnetism: Magnetism comes from fixed magnetic moments. Here, the band splitting should persist even in the paramagnetic phase (above $T_N$).

Until now, visualizing this transition was nearly impossible because most kagome magnets have very high ordering temperatures. The authors used FeSn thin films to finally "see" what happens to these bands across the magnetic transition.

Methods

  • Synthesis: The team grew 30 nm thick FeSn films using Molecular Beam Epitaxy (MBE) on $SrTiO_3(111)$ substrates. This method produces much cleaner surfaces than traditional bulk crystal cleaving.
  • ARPES: They used Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES) with a 21.2 eV helium lamp. This technique allows researchers to directly map the energy and momentum of electrons inside the material.
  • Computational Modeling: The experimental data were compared against Density Functional Theory (DFT) (using VASP and SPR-KKR codes) and Dynamical Mean Field Theory (DMFT) to account for strong electron correlations.

Datasets

The study does not rely on external public datasets but generates several primary experimental and theoretical datasets:

  • ARPES Spectra: Energy vs. momentum maps across a temperature range of 20 K to 400 K.
  • Magnetization Data: SQUID measurements confirming a Néel temperature ($T_N$) of ~370 K.
  • Structural Characterization: RHEED and XRD patterns confirming the high crystallinity of the epitaxial films.
  • Calculated Band Structures: Comparative DFT and DMFT simulations for both paramagnetic and antiferromagnetic phases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Persistent Splitting: The most striking finding is that the exchange splitting of the kagome flat bands does not disappear above $T_N$. It only shifts slightly. This is the "smoking gun" for a local moment picture of magnetism.
  • Compact Molecular Orbitals: Because the flat bands in FeSn are "topologically non-trivial," electrons can't be localized on single atoms. Instead, they form "compact molecular orbitals" that span multiple sites but still act like local magnetic moments.
  • Spin-Orbital Selectivity: The researchers found that electron correlation effects are not uniform. Only specific orbitals ($d_{xy} + d_{x^2-y^2}$) in the spin-majority channel showed massive renormalization (where electrons act much heavier than predicted).
  • Hund’s Metal Physics: This selective "heaviness" is a hallmark of Hund’s metals, a state previously used to describe iron-based superconductors. This suggests a deep theoretical link between kagome magnets and high-$T_c$ superconductivity.

Key Results

  • Temperature Stability: The band splitting persists at 385 K (above the 370 K $T_N$), with the spin-majority band shifting by only ~0.2 eV—roughly 14% of the full predicted exchange scale.
  • Mass Enhancement: In the $d_{xy} + d_{x^2-y^2}$ channel, the electrons were found to be 6.8 to 11.4 times heavier than predicted by standard theory, with an effective mass $m^* \approx 7m_e$.
  • Absence of Van Hove Singularities (VHS): Unlike the related material FeGe, FeSn lacks VHS near the Fermi level. This explains why FeSn does not exhibit the Charge Density Waves (CDW) seen in its sister compounds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Surface vs. Bulk: While the authors provide rigorous checks (capping/de-capping and single-crystal comparisons) to prove these features are "bulk" properties, some previous studies on bulk crystals suggested they might be surface states. Further photon-energy-dependent studies are needed to settle this definitively.
  • Theoretical Refinement: Current DFT models struggle to capture the exact degree of spin-orbital selectivity observed. New theoretical frameworks are required to model how topology and Hund's coupling interact in flat-band systems.
  • Dimensionality: Future research could explore how these correlation effects change as the FeSn films are thinned down to the monolayer limit.

Summary updated

Abstract

Magnetic kagome materials provide a fascinating playground for exploring the interplay of magnetism, correlation and topology. Many magnetic kagome systems have been reported including the binary FemXn (X=Sn, Ge; m:n = 3:1, 3:2, 1:1) family and the rare earth RMn6Sn6 (R = rare earth) family, where their kagome flat bands are calculated to be near the Fermi level in the paramagnetic phase. While partially filling a kagome flat band is predicted to give rise to a Stoner-type ferromagnetism, experimental visualization of the magnetic splitting across the ordering temperature has not been reported for any of these systems due to the high ordering temperatures, hence leaving the nature of magnetism in kagome magnets an open question. Here, we probe the electronic structure with angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy in a kagome magnet thin film FeSn synthesized using molecular beam epitaxy. We identify the exchange-split kagome flat bands, whose splitting persists above the magnetic ordering temperature, indicative of a local moment picture. Such local moments in the presence of the topological flat band are consistent with the compact molecular orbitals predicted in theory. We further observe a large spin-orbital selective band renormalization in the Fe d_xy+d_(x^2-y^2 ) spin majority channel reminiscent of the orbital selective correlation effects in the iron-based superconductors. Our discovery of the coexistence of local moments with topological flat bands in a kagome system echoes similar findings in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene, and provides a basis for theoretical effort towards modeling correlation effects in magnetic flat band systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2024persistent,
  author = {Zheng Ren and Jianwei Huang and Hengxin Tan and Ananya Biswas and Aki Pulkkinen and Yichen Zhang and Yaofeng Xie and Ziqin Yue and Lei Chen and Fang Xie and Kevin Allen and Han Wu and Qingguang Ren and Anil Rajapitamahuni and Asish K. Kundu and E. Vescovo and Junichiro Kono and E. Morosan and Pengcheng Dai and Jianxin Zhu and Qimiao Si and J. Minář and Binghai Yan and Ming Yi},
  title = {{Persistent flat band splitting and strong selective band renormalization in a kagome magnet thin film}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-53722-3},
}
Figure