Performance Predictions of Dry and Wet Vapors Ejectors Over Entire Operational Range

Fenglei Li, Zhihe Zhao, Qi Tian, Changzhi Wu, Xiangyu WangEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new, more accurate model for predicting the performance of ejectors, crucial components in energy-efficient refrigeration systems. This model works across the full operational range (critical and subcritical modes) and for both dry and wet vapor refrigerants, overcoming limitations of previous models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional models for ejectors often rely on ideal gas assumptions, which lead to significant inaccuracies, especially when dealing with wet vapor refrigerants. These models also struggle to predict performance outside of the "critical mode," limiting their usefulness for real-world applications. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a unified model that accurately predicts ejector performance across all operating conditions and for various refrigerants. This is important because ejectors are key to developing more energy-efficient refrigeration and air conditioning systems, reducing reliance on traditional compressors.

Methods

The core of the paper is the development of a novel ejector model that integrates several key components:

  • Critical and Breakdown Point Models: The authors developed specific models for the "critical point" (where entrainment ratio is maximized) and the "breakdown point" (where performance degrades significantly). These models are built on assumptions of constant-pressure mixing and disturbing.
  • Linear Characteristic Equations: These equations are used to describe the ejector's behavior across its operational range, connecting the critical and breakdown points.
  • Real Gas Properties and Two-Phase Speed of Sound: To improve accuracy, especially for wet vapors, the model incorporates real gas equations and the speed of sound for two-phase flow (using Wood's equation).
  • Ejector Component Efficiency Optimization: The model's accuracy is further enhanced by determining ejector component efficiencies through an "Effect of Change" (EOC) analysis and a "sparsity-enhanced optimization" method, using experimental data.

Datasets

The paper uses experimental data from existing studies for three refrigerants:

  • R134a (wet vapor)
  • R141b (dry vapor)
  • R245fa (dry vapor)

These datasets were used to validate the proposed model and determine optimal component efficiencies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wet Vapor Challenges: Ideal gas models are insufficient for wet vapor refrigerants, necessitating the use of real gas properties and two-phase flow physics.
  • Unified Operational Range: A single model that covers both critical and subcritical modes is essential for comprehensive ejector performance prediction.
  • Superheating Impact: Superheating the primary flow can significantly improve the performance of wet vapor ejectors (like R134a) by increasing cooling capacity and entrainment ratio, but has less impact on dry vapor ejectors.
  • Generating Temperature is Key: For ERS performance, decreasing the saturated generating temperature has a more significant impact than superheating the primary flow.
  • Evaporating Temperature Influence: Increasing the saturated evaporating temperature generally improves performance metrics like entrainment ratio and COP.

Key Results

The proposed model demonstrated good agreement with experimental data for R134a, R141b, and R245fa ejectors across their entire operational range.

  • Critical Point Predictions: Errors for critical condensing pressure (Pcc) were within ±3% for R134a and ±4% for R141b. Critical entrainment ratios (uc) showed deviations within ±6% for R134a and ±7.70% for R141b.
  • Breakdown Point Predictions: Breakdown condensing pressures (Pcb) for R134a showed deviations within ±2%.
  • Superheating Effects: For R134a, superheating by 20°C increased uc by 19% and cooling capacity (Qe) by 10%. For R141b, the impact of superheating was much less pronounced.
  • Operational Parameter Effects: Decreasing generating temperature (tg) significantly improved COP and uc. Increasing evaporating temperature (te) also boosted performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Efficiency Determination: The accuracy of the model relies heavily on the careful determination of ejector component efficiencies, which are often derived from experimental data and can be geometry-dependent.
  • Experimental Data: While the model is validated against existing experimental data, further validation with a wider range of ejector geometries and working fluids would be beneficial.
  • Simplified Assumptions: The model is based on assumptions like adiabatic walls and negligible kinetic energy at inlets/outlets, which might not hold true in all real-world scenarios.

The authors suggest that their model provides a robust framework for analyzing and optimizing ejector refrigeration systems, paving the way for more efficient cooling technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

If a traditional ideal-gas ejector model is used to evaluate the performance of a wet vapor ejector, large deviations from the experimental results will be unavoidable. Moreover, the model usually fails to assess the ejector performance at subcritical mode. In this paper, we proposed a novel model to evaluate the performance of both dry and wet vapors ejectors over the entire operational range at critical or subcritical modes. The model was obtained by integrating the linear characteristic equations of ejector with critical and breakdown points models, which were developed based on the assumptions of constant-pressure mixing and constant-pressure disturbing. In the models, the equations of the two-phase speed of sound and the property of real gas were introduced and ejector component efficiencies were optimized to improve the accuracy of evaluation. It was validated that the proposed model for the entire operational range can achieve a better performance than those existing for R134a, R141b and R245fa. The critical and breakdown points models were further used to investigate the effect of operational parameters on the performance of an ejector refrigeration system (ERS). The theoretical results indicated that decreasing the saturated generating temperature when the actual condensing temperature decreases, and/or increasing the saturated evaporating temperature can improve the performance of ERS significantly. Moreover, superheating the primary flow before it enters the ejector can further improve the performance of an ERS using R134a as a working fluid.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2017performance,
  author = {Fenglei Li and Zhihe Zhao and Qi Tian and Changzhi Wu and Xiangyu Wang},
  title = {{Performance Predictions of Dry and Wet Vapors Ejectors Over Entire Operational Range}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10071012},
}
Figure