Performance of UAV assisted Multiuser Terrestrial-Satellite Communication System over Mixed FSO/RF Channels

Praveen Kumar Singya, Mohamed‐Slim Alouini

Abstract

In this work, performance of a multi-antenna multiuser unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) assisted terrestrial-satellite communication system over mixed free space optics (FSO)/ radio frequency (RF) channels is analyzed. Downlink transmission from the satellite to the UAV is completed through FSO link which follows Gamma-Gamma distribution with pointing error impairments. Both the heterodyne detection and intensity modulation direct detection techniques are considered at the FSO receiver. To avail the antenna diversity, multiple transmit antennas are considered at the UAV. Selective decode-and-forward scheme is assumed at the UAV and opportunistic user scheduling is performed while considering the practical constraints of outdated channel state information (CSI) during the user selection and transmission phase. The RF links are assumed to follow Nakagami-m distribution due to its versatile nature. In this context, for the performance analysis, analytical expressions of outage probability, asymptotic outage probability, ergodic capacity, effective capacity, and generalized average symbol-error-rate expressions of various quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) schemes such as hexagonal-QAM, cross-QAM, and rectangular QAM are derived. A comparison of various modulation schemes is presented. Further, the impact of pointing error, number of antennas, delay constraint, fading severity, and imperfect CSI are highlighted on the system performance. Finally, all the analytical results are verified through the Monte-Carlo simulations.

Introduction

As we push toward 6G, terrestrial networks alone cannot provide the ubiquitous, high-speed coverage required for global connectivity. Satellite-terrestrial networks are a promising solution, but they face a major hurdle: "masking." Buildings, mountains, and even atmospheric conditions can block the direct line-of-sight (LoS) between a satellite and a ground user.

Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) can act as "flying base stations" to solve this, providing a flexible relay point. However, analyzing these systems is incredibly complex. The link from the satellite to the UAV typically uses FSO for high data rates, which is sensitive to "pointing errors" (the laser wobbling) and atmospheric turbulence. Meanwhile, the link from the UAV to ground users uses RF, which suffers from fading and the practical reality of "outdated CSI"—where the channel state changes between the time it's measured and the time data is actually sent. This paper develops the analytical tools to understand how these factors combined affect the system's overall performance.

System Model and Methodology

The authors model a downlink system where a satellite sends an optical signal to a multi-antenna UAV, which then decodes and broadcasts it to the "best" available ground user through opportunistic scheduling.

System model of a UAV-assisted multiuser terrestrial-satellite communication system featuring a satellite-to-UAV FSO link and UAV-to-user RF links.

Key technical components include:

  • Channel Modeling: The FSO link is modeled using a Gamma-Gamma distribution (to account for both large and small-scale turbulence) combined with a statistical model for pointing errors. The RF links follow a Nakagami-m distribution, known for its versatility in modeling various fading environments.
  • Detection Techniques: The study compares Heterodyne Detection (more complex but efficient) vs. Intensity Modulation/Direct Detection (IM/DD) at the FSO receiver.
  • Diversity & Scheduling: The UAV uses multiple antennas for transmit beamforming. The system employs Selective Decode-and-Forward (DF) relaying and selects users based on the highest instantaneous SNR, specifically accounting for the delay in Channel State Information (CSI).
  • Mathematical Framework: The authors derive exact analytical expressions for outage probability, ergodic capacity, and effective capacity (which considers delay constraints) using complex functions like Meijer-G and series expansions. The results were validated using Monte-Carlo simulations with $10^7$ realizations.

Key Insights and Results

The Impact of Outdated CSI

One of the most critical findings is that outdated CSI can completely nullify the benefits of multiuser diversity in high SNR regimes. If the channel information is too old, picking the "best" user becomes no better than picking a random one. Improving the CSI correlation ($\rho$) from 0.2 to 0.8 (making the channel info more "fresh") resulted in a massive 3.7 dB gain in outage performance.

Modulation Efficiency: HQAM vs. RQAM

The paper analyzes several Quadrature Amplitude Modulation (QAM) schemes. Hexagonal QAM (HQAM) consistently outperforms Rectangular (RQAM) and Cross (XQAM) constellations because it has the densest 2D packing, requiring less power for the same error rate. HQAM was shown to provide a 0.3 to 0.65 dB gain over standard Square QAM for higher-order constellations (like 256-QAM).

FSO as the System Bottleneck

In scenarios with severe pointing errors, the FSO link becomes the dominant limiting factor. In these cases, adding more antennas at the UAV provides diminishing returns because the "bottleneck" is the laser link from space, not the RF link to the ground. Furthermore, Heterodyne detection is shown to be significantly more robust against atmospheric turbulence than IM/DD, making it the preferred choice for high-reliability satellite-to-UAV links.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a rigorous framework for predicting the reliability and capacity of hybrid FSO/RF UAV relay systems. While the model provides deep insights, it currently assumes users are in close proximity and follow an independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) model. Real-world scenarios with non-i.i.d. users (varying distances) might yield different scheduling dynamics.

Future research could explore different relaying protocols (like Amplify-and-Forward) or investigate the impact of UAV mobility and trajectory optimization on the FSO pointing error statistics. Additionally, reducing the computational complexity of the ASER expressions, which currently involve infinite series, remains a practical challenge for real-time implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work, performance of a multi-antenna multiuser unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) assisted terrestrial-satellite communication system over mixed free space optics (FSO)/ radio frequency (RF) channels is analyzed. Downlink transmission from the satellite to the UAV is completed through FSO link which follows Gamma-Gamma distribution with pointing error impairments. Both the heterodyne detection and intensity modulation direct detection techniques are considered at the FSO receiver. To avail the antenna diversity, multiple transmit antennas are considered at the UAV. Selective decode-and-forward scheme is assumed at the UAV and opportunistic user scheduling is performed while considering the practical constraints of outdated channel state information (CSI) during the user selection and transmission phase. The RF links are assumed to follow Nakagami-m distribution due to its versatile nature. In this context, for the performance analysis, analytical expressions of outage probability, asymptotic outage probability, ergodic capacity, effective capacity, and generalized average symbol-error-rate expressions of various quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) schemes such as hexagonal-QAM, cross-QAM, and rectangular QAM are derived. A comparison of various modulation schemes is presented. Further, the impact of pointing error, number of antennas, delay constraint, fading severity, and imperfect CSI are highlighted on the system performance. Finally, all the analytical results are verified through the Monte-Carlo simulations.
BibTeX
@article{singya2022performance,
  author = {Praveen Kumar Singya and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Performance of UAV assisted Multiuser Terrestrial-Satellite Communication System over Mixed FSO/RF Channels}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electron. Syst.},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=2PijKNML5nZ},
}
Figure