Performance of Android Forensics Data Recovery Tools

Bernard Chukwuemeka Ogazi-Onyemaechi, Ali Dehghantanha, Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo

Introduction

Smartphones have become central repositories of personal and professional data, making them critical targets in digital forensic investigations. However, recovering data from internal memory remains a significant challenge, particularly when a user has performed a factory reset. Standard forensic tools often suggest that such data is permanently lost. This study evaluates the effectiveness of various forensic data recovery tools on an Android device following a factory wipe, quantifying their ability to retrieve "deleted" information.

Methodology

The researchers established a multi-stage experimental pipeline to test the limits of current forensic software. A Samsung Galaxy S2 was selected as the test device and pre-loaded with the Enron dataset—a standard corpus of emails and documents used in fraud detection research—to simulate a realistic user environment.

Following the data seeding, the device underwent a factory reset to simulate an attempt to destroy evidence. The team then performed two types of physical acquisition to create bit-for-bit disk dumps: AccessData FTK Imager and the command-line Backtrack dd Imager. Finally, five specialized carving tools—Phone Image Carver, AccessData FTK, Foremost, DiskDigger, and Recover My Files—were used to extract files based on headers and footers rather than file system metadata.

Experimental workflow for evaluating data recovery tools

Comparative Analysis: Logical vs. Physical Acquisition

A key finding of the study is the absolute necessity of physical acquisition in post-wipe scenarios. Logical acquisition, which relies on the operating system to provide file access, proved entirely ineffective after the factory reset, returning only empty logs.

Furthermore, the choice of imaging tool significantly impacted the volume of data available for analysis. The raw dd image captured 68.75% of the device's capacity, whereas the proprietary AccessData FTK Imager captured only 14%. This discrepancy suggests that some proprietary tools may overlook "slack space"—the unused storage area between the end of a file and the end of a disk cluster—which often contains vital forensic evidence.

Recovery Results and Tool Specialization

The performance of the carving tools varied significantly, highlighting that no single tool serves as a "silver bullet" for mobile forensics.

  • Foremost: This tool proved exceptionally effective for recovering graphic files. As shown in the results, it successfully extracted over 6,000 JPEGs and 7,000 PNGs from the raw images, demonstrating high proficiency in identifying common media formats within unallocated space.
  • DiskDigger: This tool recovered the highest total number of files (20,145), though a large portion consisted of small .tif files.
  • Recover My Files: This tool led in total data volume, recovering 7.37 GB, including large video files (.mov) and database files (.myob) that other tools failed to detect.
  • Phone Image Carver: While extremely slow, this was the only tool capable of recovering specific formats like SQLite and Text-Shift JIS.
File formats recovered using the Foremost carving tool

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that a factory reset does not necessarily result in the permanent destruction of data on Android devices. Through physical bit-for-bit imaging and specialized carving, thousands of files can be recovered. However, the effectiveness of these methods is highly dependent on the specific tools used and the nature of the data sought.

It is important to note that this research was conducted on older hardware (Samsung Galaxy S2) and Android versions (2.3.4/4.0.3). Modern mobile devices employing File-Based Encryption (FBE) and aggressive TRIM behaviors on SSDs present significantly greater challenges for data recovery. Future research should focus on these modern architectures and the impact of cloud-synchronization on physical device recoverability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recovering deleted or hidden data is among most important duties of forensics investigators. Extensive utilisation of smartphones as subject, objects or tools of crime made them an important part of residual forensics. This chapter investigates the effectiveness of mobile forensic data recovery tools in recovering evidences from a Samsung Galaxy S2 i9100 Android phone. We seek to determine the amount of data that could be recovered using Phone image carver, Access data FTK, Foremost, Diskdigger, and Recover My File forensic tools. The findings reflected the difference between recovery capacities of studied tools showing their suitability in their specialised contexts only.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ogazionyemaechi2017performance,
  author = {Bernard Chukwuemeka Ogazi-Onyemaechi and Ali Dehghantanha and Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo},
  title = {{Performance of Android Forensics Data Recovery Tools}},
  booktitle = {Contemporary Digital Forensic Investigations of Cloud and Mobile Applications},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=s2S5Xe8bMlp},
}
Figure