Performance and Productivity of Regional Air Transport Systems in China

Mingli Song, Guangshe JiaISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2021 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of accurately evaluating the performance of China's regional air transport systems (ATS) by developing a novel three-stage Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) model. This approach effectively accounts for the significant influence of external environmental factors and statistical noise, revealing that scale efficiency, rather than pure technical efficiency, is the primary bottleneck for ATS performance in China.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global air transport industry is a critical economic driver, yet governments and industry stakeholders often struggle to confidently invest in and expand it due to uncertainty about the performance of existing systems. While much research focuses on individual airports or airlines, understanding the efficiency of the entire regional Air Transport System (ATS) is crucial for effective development strategies. A key challenge in evaluating ATS performance is the significant impact of external factors (like economic conditions, policies, and infrastructure) and statistical noise, which can distort efficiency measurements if not properly accounted for. Previous studies often overlook these environmental influences or address them post-hoc, leading to potentially inaccurate assessments of "real" performance. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a robust method to evaluate regional ATS performance that explicitly isolates the effects of these external factors.

Methods

The authors employ a sophisticated three-stage DEA model combined with a bootstrap-Malmquist productivity index.

  • Stage 1: Initial Efficiency Evaluation (BCC DEA): This stage uses a standard Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) model with variable returns to scale (VRS) to calculate initial efficiency scores. The BCC DEA model is chosen for its ability to handle multiple inputs and outputs without requiring a specific production function. This stage identifies "slacks" in inputs, representing inefficiencies.
  • Stage 2: Environmental Factor Adjustment (Stochastic Frontier Analysis - SFA): The input slacks from Stage 1 are then regressed against a set of environmental variables using a Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA) model. SFA is crucial here as it not only quantifies the impact of environmental factors but also decomposes the error term into managerial inefficiency and statistical noise. This allows for the adjustment of input values to create a "level playing field" for all decision-making units (DMUs).
  • Stage 3: Real Performance Evaluation (BCC DEA + Bootstrap-Malmquist): The adjusted inputs from Stage 2 are fed back into the BCC DEA model, along with the original outputs. This yields a "real" efficiency score that is purged of environmental influences and statistical noise. To analyze productivity changes over time, the bootstrap-Malmquist productivity index is applied. This method is preferred over standard DEA-based Malmquist indices because bootstrapping provides a more statistically robust estimation of efficiency and productivity by approximating the sampling distribution of the estimators.

Datasets

The study utilizes data for China's 30 provincial ATSs from 2002 to 2017.

  • Input Indicators: Capital Stock (estimated using the perpetual inventory method based on fixed-asset investment data) and Number of Employees.
  • Output Indicators: Volume of Passengers, Volume of Freight, and Number of Planes taking off and landing.
  • Environmental Variables: Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita, Consumption (household consumption expenditure), Scientific and technological level (patent grants per capita), Tourism industry level (inbound tourists), Wholesale and retail industry level (value added), Openness to foreign investment (actual utilization of FDI), and Industrial structure (ratio of tertiary industry added value to GDP).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Environmental Factors Matter Significantly: The study strongly demonstrates that external economic and social factors have a substantial impact on ATS performance, often leading to an underestimation of true efficiency when ignored.
  • Scale Efficiency is the Primary Constraint: Unlike many developed countries, China's ATS is still in a phase of increasing returns to scale. This means that expanding capacity can lead to more than proportional increases in output, but many provinces are operating below their optimal scale, hindering overall efficiency.
  • Technological Change Drives Productivity: While technical efficiency changes (TECI) have shown mixed results, technological change (TCI) has been the main driver of total factor productivity (TFPI) growth in China's ATS. This highlights the importance of innovation and technological advancement.
  • "Moderately Advanced" Strategy is Justified: The findings support China's "moderately advanced" development strategy, suggesting that further expansion of the ATS is warranted given the current stage of increasing scale benefits and the growing demand for air transport.

Key Results

  • After adjusting for environmental factors and statistical noise, the efficiency scores for most provinces improved, indicating that previous DEA analyses likely underestimated their true performance.
  • Scale efficiency (SE) was found to be the main factor restricting ATS investment efficiency in most provinces, with nearly two-thirds of DMUs operating at an insufficient scale.
  • The national average ATS productivity (TFPI) showed a slight decrease of 0.3% from 2002-2017, despite significant investment. However, seven provinces experienced productivity increases.
  • Technological change (TCI) consistently showed positive growth, especially in the later years of the study period, driving overall productivity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exclusion of Alternative Transport Modes: The study acknowledges its limitation in not considering the impact of alternative transport modes, such as high-speed rail (HSR), on air transport industry performance. Future research could develop methods to incorporate these intermodal competition effects.
  • Pre-COVID-19 Data: The research period predates the significant impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the global air transport industry. Future work could investigate the pandemic's effects and explore mitigation strategies.
  • Policy Implications: The authors suggest that improving scale efficiency requires a focus on coordinated planning and balanced development of air transport across regions. Enhancing management practices and fostering public-private cooperation are also recommended to improve technical efficiency. The study underscores the importance of China's ongoing modernization of its air transport system and technological development strategy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The construction and operation of air transport systems (ATS) needs huge investment, so its performance is of wide concern. The influences of social and economic factors in different regions must be considered when evaluating ATS performance. In this paper, a model combining data envelopment analysis, stochastic frontier analysis, and bootstrap technique is adopted to evaluate the ‘real’ performance of the air transport system in China. The evaluation results show the ATS performance in different regions. Social and economic factors are proved to pose influences on provincial ATS efficiency. Scale efficiency is the main factor that restricts the efficiency of China’s ATS. Technological change has determined the trend of ATS total factor productivity. The research results may implicate that improvements can be gained by modifying airspace limitations and regulatory conditions that impose significant constraints on ATS. The importance of ATS technological development strategy and the legitimacy of air transport modernization policy are also supported.
BibTeX
@article{song2021performance,
  author = {Mingli Song and Guangshe Jia},
  title = {{Performance and Productivity of Regional Air Transport Systems in China}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi10020083},
}
Figure