Performance Analysis of Non-ideal Wireless PBFT Networks with mmWave and Terahertz Signals

Haoxiang Luo, Xiangyue Yang, Hongfang Yu, Gang Sun, Shizhong Xu, Long Luo

TL;DR

This paper investigates the performance of the Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance (PBFT) consensus protocol in future 6G wireless networks that utilize high-frequency mmWave and Terahertz (THz) signals. By considering realistic channel impairments like path loss and fading, the authors provide crucial insights into the consensus success rate and latency, revealing a critical "active distance" for reliable PBFT operation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Blockchain technology, particularly its consensus mechanisms like PBFT, is poised to play a significant role in securing future 6G wireless communications. However, existing research on PBFT in wireless settings often assumes ideal channel conditions, which are far from reality. The advent of 6G will see the widespread use of mmWave and THz frequencies, which are known for their unique propagation characteristics (e.g., high attenuation, short range). The performance of PBFT under these non-ideal, high-frequency wireless conditions remains largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by analyzing how channel impairments and the specific properties of mmWave and THz signals affect PBFT's consensus success rate and latency.

Methods

The authors employ a theoretical and simulation-based approach. They model the wireless environment using a two-dimensional Poisson distribution for node placement. For channel modeling, they consider:

  • Path Loss: Close-in Free Space (FS) model, which accounts for distance-dependent attenuation.
  • Fading: Rayleigh Fading (RF) model, which captures signal fluctuations due to multipath propagation.

They then derive mathematical expressions for the consensus success rate across the four stages of PBFT (pre-prepare, prepare, commit, reply) and for the overall communication delay. These derivations incorporate the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) threshold for signal recovery and node density. Finally, they validate their theoretical models through numerical simulations, comparing the performance of mmWave and THz signals under various parameter settings (SNR threshold and node density). A novel concept, the "active distance of PBFT," is introduced, representing the maximum distance between nodes for guaranteed consensus success.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors use simulated data based on established channel models and PBFT protocols.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Realism Matters: The paper strongly emphasizes that neglecting physical layer channel characteristics (path loss, fading) leads to overly optimistic PBFT performance predictions, making them unsuitable for practical 6G deployments.
  • THz vs. mmWave Trade-offs: While THz signals generally offer better performance in terms of delay due to their higher bandwidth, mmWave signals can exhibit better consensus success rates at higher node densities. This highlights a nuanced trade-off depending on network configuration.
  • The "Active Distance" Concept: The identification of a maximum "active distance" for guaranteed PBFT consensus is a significant contribution. This provides a critical design parameter for ensuring reliable blockchain operation in wireless networks.
  • Distance is King (or Queen): The study consistently shows that the distance between nodes is a primary factor degrading PBFT performance, especially for high-frequency signals that are more susceptible to attenuation.

Key Results

  • Success Rate: The consensus success rate (Pc) decreases significantly as the number of nodes (n) increases, particularly for longer distances. THz signals generally show a higher success rate than mmWave signals, especially at lower node densities.
  • Delay: The communication delay is dominated by the pre-prepare, prepare, and commit stages (t1), which grow linearly with the number of nodes. THz signals exhibit significantly lower latency compared to mmWave signals, with t1 being orders of magnitude smaller. The reply stage (t2) contributes minimally to the overall delay.
  • Active Distance: The paper derives an equation for the "active distance," which, if maintained between all nodes, guarantees successful PBFT consensus. This distance is dependent on signal power, SNR threshold, and path loss exponent.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Channel Models: While more realistic than ideal models, the RF and FS models are still simplifications. Future work could explore more complex and realistic channel models that capture a wider range of environmental effects.
  • Limited Parameter Space: The simulations explore a specific range of SNR thresholds and node densities. A broader exploration could reveal more nuanced performance characteristics.
  • PBFT Variants: The study focuses on the standard PBFT. Investigating the performance of its variants (e.g., BFT-SMaRt, Tendermint) in these non-ideal wireless environments would be valuable.
  • Practical Deployment: The "active distance" is a theoretical concept. Future work could focus on practical mechanisms for maintaining this distance or adapting PBFT to dynamic network conditions.
  • Energy Efficiency: The paper does not discuss the energy consumption of PBFT in these high-frequency networks, which is a crucial aspect for 6G.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to advantages in security and privacy, blockchain is considered a key enabling technology to support 6G communications. Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance (PBFT) is seen as the most applicable consensus mechanism in blockchain-enabled wireless networks. However, previous studies on PBFT do not consider the channel performance of the physical layer, such as path loss and channel fading, resulting in research results that are far from real networks. Additionally, 6G communications will widely deploy high frequency signals such as millimeter wave (mmWave) and terahertz (THz), while the performance of PBFT is still unknown when these signals are transmitted in wireless PBFT networks. Therefore, it is urgent to study the performance of non-ideal wireless PBFT networks with mmWave and THz siganls, so as to better make PBFT play a role in 6G era. In this paper, we study and compare the performance of mmWave and THz signals in non-ideal wireless PBFT networks, considering Rayleigh Fading (RF) and close-in Free Space (FS) reference distance path loss. Performance is evaluated by consensus success rate and delay. Meanwhile, we find and derive that there is a maximum distance between two nodes that can make PBFT consensus inevitably successful, and it is named active distance of PBFT in this paper. The research results not only analyze the performance of non-ideal wireless PBFT networks, but also provide an important reference for the future transmission of mmWave and THz signals in PBFT networks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luo2023performance,
  author = {Haoxiang Luo and Xiangyue Yang and Hongfang Yu and Gang Sun and Shizhong Xu and Long Luo},
  title = {{Performance Analysis of Non-ideal Wireless PBFT Networks with mmWave and Terahertz Signals}},
  booktitle = {MetaCom},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=3ufYdG3Okk},
}
Figure