Performance Analysis of NOMA in Training-Based Multiuser MIMO Systems

Hei Victor Cheng, Emil Björnson, Erik G. Larsson

TL;DR

This paper evaluates the performance of Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) in massive MIMO systems under the realistic constraint that channel information must be acquired through pilot signaling. The authors propose a novel NOMA scheme that reuses pilots among users to save overhead and demonstrate that while NOMA offers significant gains when users have high-quality downlink channel estimates, traditional multi-user beamforming is often superior as the number of user groups in a cell increases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the quest for 5G and beyond, two technologies are often pitted against or paired with each other: Multiuser MIMO (MU-MIMO) and NOMA. MU-MIMO separates users in the spatial domain using many antennas, while NOMA separates them in the power domain using superposition coding and interference cancellation.

Most existing studies on NOMA in MIMO systems make the "heroic" assumption of perfect Channel State Information (CSI). In reality, channels must be estimated using pilots (training signals), which consumes time and frequency resources. This paper addresses a critical gap: Does NOMA still provide a benefit when we account for the overhead and estimation errors inherent in practical training-based systems? Specifically, it looks at the "pilot shortage" scenario where the number of users exceeds the available orthogonal pilot sequences.

Methods

The authors compare a traditional orthogonal access scheme (Scheme-O) with a proposed generalized NOMA scheme (Scheme-N).

  • Shared Pilots: To handle more users than available pilots, Scheme-N assigns the same pilot sequence to a pair of users (one at the cell center, one at the cell edge).
  • Channel Estimation: The Base Station (BS) uses Minimum Mean Square Error (MMSE) estimation. Because of the shared pilots, the BS cannot distinguish between the two users' individual channels and instead estimates a linear combination of them.
  • Precoding and Signaling: The BS uses Maximum Ratio (MR) beamforming based on this combined estimate. It then uses superposition coding to send data to both users simultaneously.
  • Capacity Bounds: The paper derives rigorous, semi-closed-form lower bounds on the achievable ergodic rates for three scenarios:
  • Perfect CSI at the users.
  • No CSI at the users (relying on statistical averages).
  • Estimated CSI at the users via beamformed downlink pilots.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a theoretical performance analysis, the study relies on standard independent Rayleigh fading models and numerical simulations rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "CSI is King" Realization: NOMA's success is almost entirely dependent on the quality of CSI at the receiver. Without downlink pilots to help users estimate their effective channels, NOMA provides virtually no gain over orthogonal schemes because "self-interference" from estimation errors becomes a bottleneck.
  • Exploiting Pilot Contamination: Usually, pilot contamination is a nuisance in massive MIMO. Here, the authors intentionally induce it by sharing pilots, then use NOMA's power-domain multiplexing to resolve the resulting interference.
  • The Near-Far Requirement: NOMA performs best when there is a large difference in path loss between the paired users (e.g., one very close to the BS and one at the edge). If the users have similar channel strengths, the gains vanish.
  • Scaling Limits: While NOMA looks great for a single pair of users, the "aha moment" is that as you add more groups of users to the cell, the inter-group interference starts to dominate. In these crowded scenarios, it is actually better to use traditional multi-user beamforming with orthogonal pilots.

Key Results

  • Significant Gains in Pairs: With perfect CSI at the users and a high path loss difference (e.g., 20 dB), NOMA can increase the rate of a cell-center user by nearly 2 b/s/Hz without sacrificing the cell-edge user's rate.
  • The Downlink Pilot Penalty: Using downlink pilots to improve CSI adds overhead. However, the results show that the performance gain from better estimation outweighs the "pre-log" penalty of sending those extra pilots.
  • Multi-user Beamforming Dominance: In simulations with more than 4 users (2 groups), the "Orthogonal UL Pilots" scheme (which uses more pilots but provides better spatial separation) eventually outperforms the shared-pilot NOMA scheme. This suggests NOMA is a niche tool for specific "pilot-starved" or high-path-loss-diversity scenarios rather than a universal replacement for MU-MIMO.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Precoding Constraints: The analysis is limited to Maximum Ratio (MR) precoding. The authors note that more advanced techniques like Zero-Forcing (ZF) might change the interference landscape and require further study.
  • User Pairing: The study assumes a simple pairing of one "near" and one "far" user. Optimizing user pairing and power control for more than two users per group remains an open challenge.
  • Blind Estimation: The authors suggest that "blind" channel estimation methods (which don't require pilots) could be a promising way to reduce overhead for NOMA in the future.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper considers the use of non-orthogonal-multiple-access (NOMA) in multiuser MIMO systems in practical scenarios where channel state information (CSI) is acquired through pilot signaling. A new NOMA scheme that uses shared pilots is proposed. Achievable rate analysis is carried out for different pilot signaling schemes, including both uplink and downlink pilots. The achievable rate performance of the proposed NOMA scheme with shared pilot within each group is compared with the traditional orthogonal access scheme with orthogonal pilots. Our proposed scheme is a generalization of the orthogonal scheme, and can be reduced to the orthogonal scheme when appropriate power allocation parameters are chosen. Numerical results show that when downlink CSI is available at the users, our proposed NOMA scheme outperforms orthogonal schemes. However with more groups of users present in the cell, it is preferable to use multi-user beamforming instead of NOMA.
BibTeX
@article{cheng2018performance,
  author = {Hei Victor Cheng and Emil Björnson and Erik G. Larsson},
  title = {{Performance Analysis of NOMA in Training-Based Multiuser MIMO Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Z3wZLhnxX7S},
}

Loading related content...

Figure