Performance Analysis for Massive MIMO Downlink with Low Complexity Approximate Zero-Forcing Precoding

Cheng Zhang, Yindi Jing, Yongming Huang, Luxi Yang

Abstract

Zero-forcing (ZF) precoding is a cornerstone of massive MIMO downlink systems due to its near-optimal performance in mitigating multi-user interference. However, the cubic computational complexity associated with matrix inversion poses a significant barrier to real-time implementation. This paper presents a low-complexity alternative using a first-order Neumann series (NS) expansion. We introduce the Identity-plus-Column NS (ICNS) method, which incorporates a relaxation parameter and the interference data of a single selected user into the precondition matrix. By further selecting the user with the highest interference—exploiting multi-user diversity—we propose the Ordered ICNS method. We derive closed-form sum-rate approximations for these methods, allowing for a rigorous analysis of performance loss relative to ideal ZF and gains over standard identity-based approximations. Simulations demonstrate that our proposed designs offer a superior performance-complexity tradeoff, particularly in scenarios with correlated channels and moderate loading factors.

Introduction

In the evolution toward 5G and 6G networks, massive MIMO (Multiple-Input Multiple-Output) technology has emerged as a critical component. By employing hundreds of antennas at the base station to serve multiple users simultaneously, these systems significantly increase spectral efficiency. To prevent signals intended for different users from interfering with one another, the base station must perform linear precoding.

Zero-forcing (ZF) precoding is widely regarded as the gold standard for this task because it effectively nullifies inter-user interference. However, ZF requires the inversion of a large Gram matrix, a process with a computational complexity of $O(K^3)$, where $K$ is the number of users. As $K$ increases, this cubic scaling leads to high power consumption and latency, making it difficult to implement on standard hardware. While Neumann series (NS) expansions have been proposed to reduce this complexity to $O(K^2)$, traditional approximations often fail to maintain adequate data rates (sum-rates) when the system is heavily loaded or when wireless channels are spatially correlated.

Proposed Methodology: ICNS and Ordered ICNS

To bridge the gap between computational efficiency and network performance, this research introduces the Identity-plus-Column Neumann Series (ICNS) method. The core innovation lies in the construction of the "precondition matrix" used for the approximation.

The ICNS Approach

Standard Neumann series approximations typically use a scaled identity matrix as a starting point (Identity NS or INS). While computationally light, this approach ignores the specific interference patterns of the users. The ICNS method improves upon this by injecting the interference data of exactly one user (one column of the Gram matrix) into the precondition matrix. By combining this with a carefully tuned relaxation parameter, the approximation becomes significantly more robust without exceeding $O(K^2)$ complexity.

Exploiting Diversity: Ordered ICNS

Building on the ICNS framework, the Ordered ICNS method introduces a selection mechanism. By identifying the "loudest" user—the one whose signal causes the most interference to others—and using their specific channel data for the precondition matrix, the system exploits multi-user diversity. This targeted approach ensures that the most significant interference components are addressed first, leading to faster convergence and higher accuracy.

Theoretical Analysis and Sum-Rate Derivation

A key contribution of this work is the derivation of closed-form mathematical expressions for the sum-rate of the proposed methods. Unlike purely empirical studies, this analytical framework allows for the prediction of performance across three typical massive MIMO scenarios:

  1. Independent and Identically Distributed (i.i.d.) Channels: Idealized environments with no correlation.
  2. Correlated Channels: Realistic environments where physical proximity or scattering causes signal overlap.
  3. Variable Loading Factors: Scenarios with different ratios of users to antennas.

The analysis provides an explicit look at the performance loss of ICNS compared to ideal ZF and its performance gain over the standard INS method, providing a roadmap for system designers to choose the best precoder based on current network conditions.

Key Results and Insights

Complexity Reduction

The ICNS method requires only $4K^2$ complex multiplications and eliminates the need for division operations, which are notoriously difficult to implement in high-speed hardware. This represents a massive reduction in overhead compared to the $O(K^3)$ requirement of exact ZF.

Performance in the "Goldilocks Zone"

The research identifies that ICNS is most effective at intermediate loading factors. In very lightly loaded networks, simple approximations suffice; in extremely congested networks, all approximations struggle. However, in the realistic middle ground where most 5G/6G systems operate, ICNS maintains a sum-rate very close to ideal ZF.

Robustness to Correlation

One of the primary weaknesses of existing low-complexity precoders is their failure in correlated channels. By using a relaxation parameter adapted to the channel's spatial correlation, the ICNS method remains stable and efficient where other Neumann-based methods fail. Simulations confirmed that the derived closed-form equations match real-world performance with high precision.

Conclusion

The proposed ICNS and Ordered ICNS methods offer a practical solution to the computational bottlenecks of massive MIMO. By strategically incorporating a small amount of interference data into a low-complexity approximation, these methods achieve a near-optimal balance between processing speed and network throughput. This work paves the way for more efficient hardware implementations in future wireless infrastructure, ensuring that the high-speed promises of 5G and 6G can be met without prohibitive computational costs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Zero-forcing (ZF) precoding plays an important role for massive MIMO downlink due to its near optimal performance. However, the high computation cost of the involved matrix inversion hinders its application. In this paper, we adopt the first order Neumann series (NS) for a low-complexity approximation. By introducing a relaxation parameter jointly with one selected user's interference to others into the precondition matrix, we propose the identity-plus-column NS (ICNS) method. By further exploiting the multi-user diversity gain via choosing the user with the largest interference to others, the ordered ICNS method is also proposed. Moreover, the sum-rate approximations of the proposed ICNS method and the competitive existing identity matrix based NS (INS) method are derived in closed-form, based on which the performance loss of ICNS due to inversion approximation compared with ideal ZF and its performance gain over INS are explicitly analyzed for three typical massive MIMO scenarios. Finally, simulations verify our analytical results and also show that the proposed two designs achieve better performance-complexity tradeoff than ideal ZF and existing low-complexity ZF precodings for practical large antenna number, correlated channels and not-so-small loading factor.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2018performance,
  author = {Cheng Zhang and Yindi Jing and Yongming Huang and Luxi Yang},
  title = {{Performance Analysis for Massive MIMO Downlink with Low Complexity Approximate Zero-Forcing Precoding}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=X7R_kUjmRVo},
}
Figure