Perceived Intensities of Normal and Shear Skin Stimuli Using a Wearable Haptic Bracelet

Mine Saraç, Tae Myung Huh, Hojung Choi, Mark R. Cutkosky, Massimiliano Di Luca, Allison M. Okamura

Abstract

Our aim is to provide effective interaction with virtual objects, despite the lack of co-location of virtual and real-world contacts, while taking advantage of relatively large skin area and ease of mounting on the forearm. We performed two human participant studies to determine the effects of haptic feedback in the normal and shear directions during virtual manipulation using haptic devices worn near the wrist. In the first study, participants performed significantly better while discriminating stiffness values of virtual objects when the feedback consisted of normal displacements compared to shear displacements. Participants also commented that they could detect normal cues much easier than shear, which motivated us to perform a second study to find the point of subjective equality (PSE) between normal and shear stimuli. Our results show that shear stimuli require a larger actuator displacement but less force than normal stimuli to achieve perceptual equality for our haptic bracelets. We found that normal and shear stimuli cannot be equalized through skin displacement nor the interaction forces across all users. Rather, a calibration method is needed to find the point of equality for each user where normal and shear stimuli create the same intensity on the user’s skin.

Introduction

In Augmented Reality (AR) and robotics, providing realistic haptic feedback is crucial for immersive interaction with virtual objects. While fingertip-mounted devices offer high fidelity, they are often bulky and obstruct natural touch. Relocating haptic feedback to the forearm or wrist via wearable "haptic bracelets" offers a promising alternative, utilizing a larger skin area without interfering with manual dexterity. However, this shift introduces a perceptual challenge: the wrist does not naturally "feel" objects in the same way as fingerpads.

Conceptual mapping of haptic forces from fingertips to the wrist.

Haptic devices typically stimulate the skin in two ways: Normal (perpendicular squeeze) and Shear (parallel stretch). While prior research on fingerpads suggested higher sensitivity to shear, it was unclear if this holds true for the wrist. This research investigates which stimulus type is more effective for virtual tasks and how to equalize their perceived intensities to ensure balanced multi-axis feedback.

Methods

The researchers developed a lightweight (<40g) haptic bracelet equipped with linear actuators capable of providing both normal and shear stimuli to the dorsal and ventral sides of the wrist. Two primary psychophysical studies were conducted:

  1. Stiffness Discrimination Study: Twelve participants interacted with virtual boxes of varying stiffness. The bracelet rendered the "resistance" of the box as either normal or shear skin displacement.
  2. Point of Subjective Equality (PSE) Study: Eight participants performed a "tuning" task to find the point where normal and shear stimuli felt equally intense. Participants adjusted a test stimulus (e.g., shear) until it matched a reference stimulus (e.g., a 3mm normal squeeze).

To ensure precise measurements, custom low-cost capacitive force sensors were integrated into the device to record the actual interaction forces applied to the skin, moving beyond simple motor displacement metrics.

Key Results and Discussion

The studies revealed several critical insights into how we perceive haptic stimuli on the wrist:

Superiority of Normal Force for Stiffness

Participants were significantly more accurate and faster at identifying the stiffness of virtual objects when using normal (squeeze) feedback compared to shear (stretch) feedback. Subjective reports indicated that normal cues were much easier to notice during active manipulation tasks.

Accuracy and time spent for stiffness discrimination across different comparison pairs.

The Displacement vs. Force Paradox

A significant finding was the mismatch between skin displacement and applied force. To achieve perceptual equality, shear stimuli required greater displacement than normal stimuli. On average, a 3mm normal reference was perceived as equal to a 3.7mm shear displacement. Conversely, a 3mm shear reference was perceived as equal to only 1.9mm of normal displacement.

However, the force data told a different story: when intensities were perceived as equal, the interaction forces for normal stimuli were consistently and significantly higher than for shear stimuli. This indicates a higher physical sensitivity to shear force—it takes much less force to create a noticeable stretch than a noticeable squeeze.

The Need for Personalized Calibration

The ratio of normal-to-shear perception varied significantly across individuals, likely due to differences in skin elasticity, arm physiology, and device fit. Consequently, a universal mapping between normal and shear forces is impractical. The researchers conclude that wearable haptic devices must include a brief calibration step for each user to determine their unique Point of Subjective Equality.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research demonstrates that while normal forces are more effective for discriminating virtual stiffness on the wrist, shear forces are perceived as more intense at lower force levels. These findings highlight the necessity of personalized calibration in multi-axis haptic wearables.

Future work will focus on developing rapid, gamified calibration procedures suitable for consumer applications. Additionally, the researchers plan to explore how these feedback modes perform in dynamic tasks, such as robotic teleoperation, and investigate the qualitative aspects of feedback, such as the perceived "pleasantness" of shear versus normal stimuli.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our aim is to provide effective interaction with virtual objects, despite the lack of co-location of virtual and real-world contacts, while taking advantage of relatively large skin area and ease of mounting on the forearm. We performed two human participant studies to determine the effects of haptic feedback in the normal and shear directions during virtual manipulation using haptic devices worn near the wrist. In the first study, participants performed significantly better while discriminating stiffness values of virtual objects when the feedback consisted of normal displacements compared to shear displacements. Participants also commented that they could detect normal cues much easier than shear, which motivated us to perform a second study to find the point of subjective equality (PSE) between normal and shear stimuli. Our results show that shear stimuli require a larger actuator displacement but less force than normal stimuli to achieve perceptual equality for our haptic bracelets. We found that normal and shear stimuli cannot be equalized through skin displacement nor the interaction forces across all users. Rather, a calibration method is needed to find the point of equality for each user where normal and shear stimuli create the same intensity on the user’s skin.
BibTeX
@article{sarac2022perceived,
  author = {Mine Saraç and Tae Myung Huh and Hojung Choi and Mark R. Cutkosky and Massimiliano Di Luca and Allison M. Okamura},
  title = {{Perceived Intensities of Normal and Shear Skin Stimuli Using a Wearable Haptic Bracelet}},
  journal = {IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/lra.2021.3140132},
}
Figure