Peer-to-Peer (P2P) Electricity Markets for Low Voltage Networks

Diana Vieira Fernandes, Nicolas Christin, Soummya Kar

TL;DR

This paper introduces a robust clearance and settlement model for peer-to-peer (P2P) electricity trading specifically designed for low-voltage distribution networks. By integrating DC power flow equations directly into the market mechanism, the model ensures that decentralized energy trades between "prosumers" are not just economically matched, but physically feasible within the grid's technical limits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The traditional electricity grid was built for a one-way street: large power plants sent electricity down to passive consumers. Today, the rise of rooftop solar and home batteries has created "prosumers"—users who both produce and consume energy. While P2P trading offers a way to democratize the energy market and reduce transmission losses, most existing models treat these trades as purely financial transactions.

The challenge is that the physical grid has limits. If too many neighbors try to sell solar power at once, they can exceed line capacities or cause voltage instability. Most current P2P research either ignores these physical constraints or assumes a "closed" microgrid. This paper tackles the "open" network problem: how do we clear and settle thousands of independent, concurrent trades while ensuring the local distribution wires don't melt?

Methods

The authors propose a two-stage approach to P2P market operations:

  1. Trade Generation (Double Auction): A matching process where buyers (bids) and sellers (asks) are paired based on price. The highest-willing buyer is matched with the lowest-cost seller, creating a list of "proposed" trades.
  2. Clearance and Settlement (Optimization): This is the core innovation. The proposed trades are fed into a Linear Programming (LP) model. The objective is to maximize the total volume of trades executed ($x_t \cdot q_t$). Crucially, this optimization is subject to DC Power Flow constraints, including:
  3. Nodal Power Balance: Ensuring energy in equals energy out at every bus.
  4. Line Capacity: Preventing any single wire from carrying more current than its thermal limit.
  5. Voltage Angle Differences: Keeping the grid stable by limiting phase shifts between nodes.
  6. Slack Bus Management: Using a reference connection to the main grid to balance any residual mismatch between local generation and demand.

The model uses a continuous decision variable ($x_t \in [0,1]$), which allows for "partial execution" of trades if the full amount would violate a grid constraint.

Datasets

The researchers validated their model using a combination of real-world demand/supply data and standard test networks:

  • Demand Data: NREL’s "End-Use Load Profiles for the U.S. Building Stock" (Pennsylvania/PJM region), clustered via K-means to represent typical residential patterns.
  • Supply Data: Global Solar Atlas data, assuming a standard 3kWp solar installation for prosumers.
  • Network Topologies:
    • The CIGRE 44-bus low-voltage radial distribution network.
  • The "Village" 80-bus synthetic voltage control network.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Physics-Aware Trading: The most important takeaway is that P2P markets cannot exist in a vacuum. By embedding the "admittance matrix" (the mathematical representation of the grid's physical connectivity) into the market clearing process, the DSO (Distribution System Operator) can act as a facilitator rather than a bottleneck.
  • The "Slack Bus" as a Buffer: The model treats the connection to the main utility grid as a "slack bus." This allows the P2P market to coexist with traditional retail; the grid absorbs excess local power or provides the deficit, ensuring 100% reliability for the users.
  • Scalability and Robustness: The model is formulated as a Linear Program, making it computationally efficient enough to handle high trade volumes in real-time or near-real-time (e.g., hourly blocks).

Key Results

  • High Fulfillment: In simulations of both the 44-bus and 80-bus systems, P2P trading was able to fulfill over 50% of the total network load during peak solar hours (typically around the 11th or 12th hour of the day).
  • Extreme Stress Test: To test robustness, the authors simulated an "extreme case" with 100x the baseline trade volume. The model successfully maintained grid stability by automatically scaling down trades (reducing the $x_t$ variable) to fit within physical line limits. For example, in the 44-bus extreme test, some trades were scaled to ~34% to 53% of their proposed volume to prevent overloads.
  • Seamless Integration: The results showed that P2P trades could be integrated alongside traditional retail without violating voltage or capacity limits, even in decentralized, open-loop systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • DC Approximation: The study uses the "DC Power Flow" approximation. While standard for high-level optimization, it neglects reactive power and actual line losses. Future work could move toward "AC Power Flow" for even higher precision in low-voltage settings where R/X ratios are high.
  • Economic Incentives: The paper focuses on the feasibility of the trades. It does not deeply explore the game-theoretic behavior of prosumers (e.g., strategic bidding) or how the "slack bus" electricity is priced relative to P2P trades.
  • Energy Communities: The authors suggest the model could be adapted for "energy communities" by implementing adjusted sharing coefficients, which remains a promising area for further implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop a clearance and settlement model for Peer-to-Peer (P2P) energy trading in low-voltage networks. The model enables direct transactions between parties within an open and distributed system and integrates unused capacity while respecting network constraints. We evaluate the model through simulations of different scenarios (normal operating conditions and extreme conditions) for 24-hour time blocks. Our simulations highlight the benefits of our model in a decentralized energy system, notably its ability to deal with high-trade volumes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fernandes2024peer,
  author = {Diana Vieira Fernandes and Nicolas Christin and Soummya Kar},
  title = {{Peer-to-Peer (P2P) Electricity Markets for Low Voltage Networks}},
  booktitle = {Smartgridcomm},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/smartgridcomm60555.2024.10738057},
}

Loading related content...

Figure