Peak-to-Average Power Ratio Analysis for OFDM-Based Mixed-Numerology Transmissions

Xiaoran Liu, Lei Zhang, Jun Xiong, Xiaoying Zhang, Li Zhou, Jibo Wei

Abstract

In this paper, the probability distribution of the peak to average power ratio (PAPR) is analyzed for the mixed numerologies transmission based on orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM). State of the art theoretical analysis implicitly assumes continuous and symmetric frequency spectrum of OFDM signals. Thus, it is difficult to be applied to the mixed-numerology system due to its complication. By comprehensively considering system parameters, including numerology, bandwidth and power level of each subband, we propose a generic analytical distribution function of PAPR for continuous-time signals based on level-crossing theory. The proposed approach can be applied to both conventional single numerology and mixed-numerology systems. In addition, it also ensures the validity for the noncontinuous-OFDM (NC-OFDM). Given the derived distribution expression, we further investigate the effect of power allocation between different numerologies on PAPR. Simulations are presented and show the good match of the proposed theoretical results.

Introduction

As 5G transitions from a uniform signaling approach to flexible "mixed-numerology" transmissions, traditional models for predicting signal power spikes, known as Peak-to-Average Power Ratio (PAPR), have become inadequate. Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) is central to modern wireless communication but suffers from high PAPR when subcarriers align, potentially distorting signals or damaging power amplifiers (PAs).

In 4G/LTE, subcarrier spacing was uniform. 5G New Radio (NR) introduces mixed-numerology, where different subbands utilize varying subcarrier spacings (SCS) and cyclic prefixes to support diverse applications, from low-latency vehicular communications to high-density IoT. Existing PAPR models often assume a continuous, symmetric frequency spectrum, which does not hold for these complex composite signals. This research introduces a generic mathematical framework based on level-crossing theory to accurately predict these power peaks.

Frequency-domain representation of mixed-numerology signal showing multiple subbands with different bandwidths and spacings.

Methodology

The study leverages level-crossing theory, treating the signal as a continuous-time random process to calculate the expected frequency of signal envelope crossings over a specific power threshold.

Key components of the methodology include:

  • Generic Analytical Expression: A new formula for the Complementary Cumulative Distribution Function (CCDF) of PAPR was derived, incorporating subband-specific parameters such as numerology, bandwidth, and power levels.
  • Broad Applicability: The model is designed to function across conventional single-numerology, mixed-numerology, and Non-Continuous OFDM (NC-OFDM) systems.
  • Power Allocation Optimization: Power allocation was formulated as an optimization problem to determine distributions that minimize or maximize PAPR.

Validation was conducted through numerical simulations involving $10^6$ randomly generated 16-QAM symbols. Signals were 8-times oversampled to capture continuous-time behavior accurately.

Key Insights and Results

A critical finding is that PAPR is primarily driven by the total system bandwidth rather than the specific subcarrier spacing within individual subbands. The model also effectively addresses theoretical gaps in NC-OFDM where previous bounds were imprecise.

Simulation results demonstrate superior accuracy. For instance, in scenarios with multiple numerologies (e.g., $N_1=200, N_2=100$), the proposed analytical expression showed a near-perfect match with simulation data, significantly outperforming legacy models which exhibited discernible deviations.

CCDF of PAPR comparing the proposed analytical model against simulation results and existing benchmarks for various subcarrier configurations.

Furthermore, the model supports asynchronous systems where subbands are not perfectly time-aligned. For two-subband cases, a closed-form solution for optimal power allocation revealed that an equal 50/50 power split across equal-bandwidth subbands results in the maximum mean PAPR.

Conclusion

The proposed framework provides a robust tool for engineers to determine necessary power amplifier back-off, preventing energy waste and signal distortion in 5G deployments. While the model relies on a Gaussian approximation—which is valid for the high subcarrier counts typical in 5G—future work will explore PAPR reduction techniques specifically for mixed-numerology structures and power allocation strategies that balance system capacity with strict hardware constraints.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the probability distribution of the peak to average power ratio (PAPR) is analyzed for the mixed numerologies transmission based on orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM). State of the art theoretical analysis implicitly assumes continuous and symmetric frequency spectrum of OFDM signals. Thus, it is difficult to be applied to the mixed-numerology system due to its complication. By comprehensively considering system parameters, including numerology, bandwidth and power level of each subband, we propose a generic analytical distribution function of PAPR for continuous-time signals based on level-crossing theory. The proposed approach can be applied to both conventional single numerology and mixed-numerology systems. In addition, it also ensures the validity for the noncontinuous-OFDM (NC-OFDM). Given the derived distribution expression, we further investigate the effect of power allocation between different numerologies on PAPR. Simulations are presented and show the good match of the proposed theoretical results.
BibTeX
@article{liu2020peak,
  author = {Xiaoran Liu and Lei Zhang and Jun Xiong and Xiaoying Zhang and Li Zhou and Jibo Wei},
  title = {{Peak-to-Average Power Ratio Analysis for OFDM-Based Mixed-Numerology Transmissions}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/tvt.2019.2960801},
}
Figure