Pathway Commons 2019 Update: integration, analysis and exploration of pathway data

Igor V. Rodchenkov, Ozgun Babur, Augustin Luna, Bülent Arman Aksoy, Jeffrey V. Wong, Dylan Fong, Max Franz, Metin Can Siper, Manfred Cheung, Michael Wrana, Harsh Mistry, Logan Mosier, Jonah Dlin, Qizhi Wen, Caitlin O'Callaghan, Wanxin Li, Geoffrey Elder, Peter T. Smith, Christian Dallago, Ethan Cerami, Benjamin Gross, Ugur Dogrusoz, Emek Demir, Gary D. Bader, Chris SanderNucleic Acids Res 2020 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

Pathway Commons (PC) is a vital resource that integrates biological pathway data from numerous public databases into a unified, accessible format. This 2019 update highlights significant expansion in data coverage, enhanced software infrastructure for analysis and visualization, and new web applications to empower researchers in understanding complex biological processes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding biological pathways is crucial for deciphering disease mechanisms, developing therapeutics, and interpreting large-scale biological data like genomics. However, the field faces a significant challenge: pathway information is fragmented across many diverse databases, each using different data formats and ontologies. This fragmentation makes it difficult for researchers to combine, analyze, and visualize data from multiple sources, hindering scientific progress. Pathway Commons aims to solve this by acting as a central hub, integrating these disparate datasets into a standardized format and providing tools for easy access and analysis.

Methods

The core of Pathway Commons' infrastructure relies on two key components: cPath2 and Paxtools. cPath2 is an open-source database and web application that handles the collection, storage, and querying of pathway data. It's built upon the Paxtools library, which provides an in-memory object model for BioPAX (Biological Pathway Exchange) data, enabling rich querying, validation, and format conversion.

Key methodological advancements include:

  • Standardized Data Integration: Data is collected from various providers using standard formats like BioPAX Level 3 and PSI-MI, ensuring consistency.
  • Identifier Mapping: cPath2 includes built-in mapping for linking identical interactors and external resources, crucial for integrating data from different sources.
  • Web Services and APIs: A RESTful architecture for the web service allows programmatic access to data, facilitating the development of third-party applications.
  • SBGN Visualization: Support for the Systems Biological Graphical Notation (SBGN) standard provides a consistent and unambiguous way to visualize biological maps.
  • Software Redevelopment: The entire database software stack has been redeveloped for improved querying capabilities and broader output format support.

Datasets

Pathway Commons integrates data from 22 public databases. This represents a significant increase from previous versions, tripling the number of pathways (from 1477 to 4794) and interactions (from 687,883 to over 2.3 million). The data covers 18,490 genes with associated HGNC identifiers and 11,437 small molecules linked to databases like ChEBI, HMDB, KEGG Compound, and DrugBank. The focus is primarily on human pathway data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Integration: The sheer volume of biological pathway data necessitates a centralized, integrated resource. Pathway Commons demonstrates that by standardizing and aggregating data, complex biological questions become more tractable.
  • Bridging the Gap Between Data and Discovery: The development of user-friendly web applications and training materials is as crucial as the data itself. These tools democratize access to complex pathway analysis, enabling a wider range of researchers to leverage the data.
  • The Importance of Standardization: The adoption and promotion of standards like BioPAX and SBGN are critical for interoperability and the long-term sustainability of biological data resources.
  • Evolving User Needs: The "smarter" search engine and context-aware linking to analysis tools reflect an understanding of how researchers actually interact with biological data, moving beyond simple keyword searches.

Key Results

  • Data Expansion: Pathway Commons Version 11 (released February 2019) contains data from 22 databases, featuring 4794 detailed human biochemical processes (pathways) and approximately 2.3 million interactions.
  • Enhanced Usability: New interactive web applications and training materials have been developed to facilitate pathway exploration and advanced analysis.
  • Improved Software Infrastructure: The cPath2 and Paxtools infrastructure has been redeveloped for more powerful querying and broader data format support.
  • Programmatic Access: A robust web service allows programmatic access to the entire dataset, supporting automated analysis and the development of custom tools.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Provider Sustainability: The paper notes that a significant number of pathway resources are no longer active or available, highlighting a challenge in maintaining the landscape of biological databases.
  • Effort in Data Integration: Integrating data from providers, even with standardized formats, requires substantial effort to tune and create BioPAX output. This suggests that integrating new databases in the future may remain challenging.
  • Text-Mining for Literature Extraction: The authors acknowledge the vast amount of knowledge locked in scientific literature and are advancing text-mining technology to extract pathway information directly, aiming to address the challenge of limited funding for manual curation.
  • Federated Search: Future plans include extending the range of biological concepts recognized (e.g., drugs, metabolites, diseases) and developing a unified, user-friendly federated search across network and pathway resources.
  • Curation Support Tools: Development of tools to empower authors to capture and share structured summaries of knowledge from their articles is planned to enhance data accessibility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pathway Commons (https://www.pathwaycommons.org) is an integrated resource of publicly available information about biological pathways including biochemical reactions, assembly of biomolecular complexes, transport and catalysis events and physical interactions involving proteins, DNA, RNA, and small molecules (e.g. metabolites and drug compounds). Data is collected from multiple providers in standard formats, including the Biological Pathway Exchange (BioPAX) language and the Proteomics Standards Initiative Molecular Interactions format, and then integrated. Pathway Commons provides biologists with (i) tools to search this comprehensive resource, (ii) a download site offering integrated bulk sets of pathway data (e.g. tables of interactions and gene sets), (iii) reusable software libraries for working with pathway information in several programming languages (Java, R, Python and Javascript) and (iv) a web service for programmatically querying the entire dataset. Visualization of pathways is supported using the Systems Biological Graphical Notation (SBGN). Pathway Commons currently contains data from 22 databases with 4794 detailed human biochemical processes (i.e. pathways) and ∼2.3 million interactions. To enhance the usability of this large resource for end-users, we develop and maintain interactive web applications and training materials that enable pathway exploration and advanced analysis.
BibTeX
@article{rodchenkov2020pathway,
  author = {Igor V. Rodchenkov and Ozgun Babur and Augustin Luna and Bülent Arman Aksoy and Jeffrey V. Wong and Dylan Fong and Max Franz and Metin Can Siper and Manfred Cheung and Michael Wrana and Harsh Mistry and Logan Mosier and Jonah Dlin and Qizhi Wen and Caitlin O'Callaghan and Wanxin Li and Geoffrey Elder and Peter T. Smith and Christian Dallago and Ethan Cerami and Benjamin Gross and Ugur Dogrusoz and Emek Demir and Gary D. Bader and Chris Sander},
  title = {{Pathway Commons 2019 Update: integration, analysis and exploration of pathway data}},
  journal = {Nucleic Acids Res.},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1093/nar/gkz946},
}
Figure