Pathway analysis of dilated cardiomyopathy using global proteomic profiling and enrichment maps

Ruth Isserlin, Daniele Merico, Rasoul Alikhani‐Koupaei, Anthony O. Gramolini, Gary D. Bader, Andrew EmiliPROTEOMICS 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel visualization tool, "Enrichment Map," to interpret complex proteomic data from a mouse model of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). This approach simplifies the analysis of hundreds of differentially expressed proteins, revealing key pathways involved in disease progression and offering new insights into potential therapeutic targets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) is a major cause of heart failure, characterized by the stretching and thinning of the heart's ventricles, leading to impaired pumping function. While proteomic profiling can identify changes in protein expression associated with DCM, interpreting the functional significance of these hundreds of altered proteins has been a significant challenge. Traditional methods often focus on the most drastically changed proteins, potentially missing subtler but important biological signals. This paper aims to address this interpretability challenge by developing and applying a more comprehensive and visually intuitive analysis framework to understand the progressive molecular alterations in DCM.

Methods

The study utilizes Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA), a statistical method that assesses whether a predefined set of genes (a "gene set") is enriched at the top or bottom of a ranked list of genes based on differential expression. This approach considers all genes, not just the most significantly altered ones, allowing for the detection of coordinated changes even in proteins with modest expression shifts.

To overcome the complexity of interpreting numerous enriched gene sets, the authors developed Enrichment Map, a novel visualization tool implemented as a Cytoscape plugin. Enrichment Map organizes gene sets into a network where nodes represent significant gene sets and edges represent their overlap. Similar gene sets are clustered together, creating a more concise and intuitive overview of biological functions affected by the disease. This visualization allows for easy comparison of disease stages and facilitates hypothesis generation.

For specific pathways of interest, such as apoptosis and the MAPK cascade, a more detailed analysis was performed, including the construction of signaling networks and experimental validation of protein expression patterns.

Datasets

The study used proteomics data from a previously published study on a phospholamban transgenic mutant mouse model (PLN-R9C) of dilated cardiomyopathy. This dataset included cardiac protein extracts from three time points representing early (8 wk), mid-stage (16 wk), and end-stage (24 wk) disease, compared to healthy littermates.

The gene sets used for GSEA were collected from a diverse range of public repositories, including:

  • Gene Ontology (GO)
  • Reactome
  • Cancer Cell Map
  • NetPath
  • Integrating Network Objects with Hierarchies (INOH)
  • BioCyc
  • NCI Pathway Interaction Database
  • NCI Biocarta
  • Molecular Signal Database (MSigDB) - c2 (pathways)
  • Disease Phenotypes
  • Corum Mips Complexes

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Enrichment Map simplifies complex data: The developed Enrichment Map tool is crucial for making sense of the vast number of enriched gene sets, allowing researchers to quickly grasp global trends and identify key affected pathways.
  • Subtle changes matter: By using GSEA, the study identified significant biological trends that were missed by previous analyses focusing only on the most differentially expressed proteins. This highlights the importance of considering all genes for a comprehensive understanding of disease mechanisms.
  • Disease progression is dynamic: The analysis revealed distinct patterns of pathway activation and deactivation at different stages of DCM, suggesting a dynamic interplay of cellular processes as the disease progresses.
  • Apoptosis and MAPK signaling are key players: The study strongly implicates apoptosis and the MAPK signaling pathway in the transition from compensatory hypertrophy to heart failure, with specific proteins like gelsolin and XIAP showing interesting expression patterns.
  • Therapeutic potential of beta-blockers: The experimental validation of the MAPK pathway's role and the demonstration that propanolol treatment can rescue DCM phenotypes in mice suggest a potential therapeutic avenue.

Key Results

  • The study identified 266 enriched gene sets for the early and mid-stages of DCM, a tenfold increase compared to a previous analysis of the same dataset.
  • Enrichment Map visualization revealed coordinated up-regulation of actin remodeling machinery and protein translation at both early and mid-stages, and down-regulation of the citric acid cycle.
  • At the mid-stage, there was a strong up-regulation of apoptosis, proteasome, and RNA processing/splicing apparatus, indicating a shift in cellular processes as the disease progresses.
  • Experimental validation confirmed elevated activity of p38 and JNK (MAPK pathway effectors) in PLN-R9C mice, which was significantly reduced by propanolol treatment.
  • Propanolol treatment in mice led to a near-complete rescue of DCM phenotypes, including reduced mortality, improved cardiac function, and normalized MAPK pathway activation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mouse model limitations: While the PLN-R9C mouse model mimics aspects of human DCM, it is still a model, and direct translation of findings to human patients requires further investigation.
  • Protein coverage: The study acknowledges that MS/MS methods may still miss some proteins, particularly low molecular weight ones, which could affect the completeness of the proteomic profiling.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that ongoing efforts to improve protein coverage by MS and to expand pathway data (including transcriptional regulation by microRNAs) will lead to more robust and informative computational analyses. They envision a more complete network being generated over time, providing a deeper understanding of progressive heart failure. The developed framework is presented as a flexible tool applicable to other datasets and diseases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Global protein expression profiling can potentially uncover perturbations associated with common forms of heart disease. We have used shotgun MS/MS to monitor the state of biological systems in cardiac tissue correlating with disease onset, cardiac insufficiency and progression to heart failure in a time-course mouse model of dilated cardiomyopathy. However, interpreting the functional significance of the hundreds of differentially expressed proteins has been challenging. Here, we utilize improved enrichment statistical methods and an extensive collection of functionally related gene sets, gaining a more comprehensive understanding of the progressive alterations associated with functional decline in dilated cardiomyopathy. We visualize the enrichment results as an Enrichment Map, where significant gene sets are grouped based on annotation similarity. This approach vastly simplifies the interpretation of the large number of enriched gene sets found. For pathways of specific interest, such as Apoptosis and the MAPK (mitogen-activated protein kinase) cascade, we performed a more detailed analysis of the underlying signaling network, including experimental validation of expression patterns.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{isserlin2010pathway,
  author = {Ruth Isserlin and Daniele Merico and Rasoul Alikhani‐Koupaei and Anthony O. Gramolini and Gary D. Bader and Andrew Emili},
  title = {{Pathway analysis of dilated cardiomyopathy using global proteomic profiling and enrichment maps}},
  booktitle = {PROTEOMICS},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1002/pmic.200900412},
}
Figure