Paris Agreement requires substantial, broad, and sustained engagements beyond COVID-19 recovery packages

Katsumasa Tanaka, Christian Azar, Oliviér Boucher, Philippe Ciais, Yann Gaucher, Daniel Johansson

TL;DR

This paper argues that while COVID-19 stimulus packages can offer a valuable opportunity for climate action, they are insufficient on their own to meet the substantial, long-term investment needs required for the Paris Agreement's 1.5°C target. The authors emphasize the necessity of sustained, broad engagements beyond short-term recovery funds, highlighting that current Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs) may underestimate these long-term requirements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the question of whether COVID-19 recovery stimulus packages, often touted as a means to accelerate green investments, are adequate for achieving the ambitious goals of the Paris Agreement, specifically the 1.5°C warming limit. Following the pandemic, there was a surge of discussion suggesting that these stimulus funds could bridge the gap in short-term energy investments needed for climate mitigation. However, the authors contend that this perspective overlooks the sheer scale and duration of investments required. They highlight a potential disconnect between the short-term focus of stimulus packages and the long-term, sustained nature of the climate challenge, questioning whether current modeling approaches adequately capture this reality.

Methods

The authors primarily employ a critical analysis of existing literature and data from Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs). They re-examine data from studies like Andrijevic et al. (2020) and datasets from the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) and the Exploring National and Global Actions to reduce Greenhouse gas Emissions (ENGAGE) projects. Their method involves:

  • Comparative Analysis: Comparing estimates of short-term stimulus funds with IAM-derived estimates of necessary low-carbon investments.
  • Data Interpretation: Critically evaluating the assumptions and outputs of IAMs, particularly concerning carbon pricing and its impact on energy demand and investment.
  • Argumentation: Building a case through five key arguments that underscore the need for sustained, broad, and long-term engagements beyond immediate stimulus measures.

Datasets

The paper utilizes data from existing Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs) and related projects, specifically:

  • CD-LINKS database (McCollum et al., 2018): Used for figures illustrating additional low-carbon and total energy investments required for the 1.5°C target.
  • NGFS (Network for Greening the Financial System) project: Provides more recent datasets for analysis.
  • ENGAGE (Exploring National and Global Actions to reduce Greenhouse gas Emissions) project: Also provides recent datasets for analysis.

The authors note that the data for figures are available on Zenodo with a provided DOI. No new datasets are introduced in this paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Short-term vs. Long-term: COVID-19 stimulus packages are inherently short-term, while achieving Paris Agreement goals requires investments that scale up and persist for decades.
  • IAMs May Underestimate Needs: Current IAMs, especially when driven by high near-term carbon prices, might underestimate the total energy investment required because they can lead to suppressed energy demand, masking the true scale of investment needed for a low-carbon transition.
  • Carbon Pricing Nuances: While carbon pricing is a crucial tool, its effectiveness in driving sufficient investment is complex. IAMs assuming very high near-term carbon prices might present a misleading picture of investment needs compared to scenarios with more moderate pricing.
  • Beyond Energy Investments: Climate mitigation involves more than just energy investments; legal, institutional, and social frameworks promoting long-term investment are equally critical.
  • Public Support vs. Carbon Pricing: The paper suggests that pathways driven by public support packages might differ significantly from those driven solely by carbon pricing, leading to different investment profiles and social costs.

Key Results

  • The paper reiterates that additional low-carbon investments needed for a 1.5°C pathway are projected to be significantly larger in annual terms for decades beyond 2024 (four to five times larger than those until 2024, as presented in A20).
  • Analysis of IAM data suggests that the net estimate of 20 billion US$/year for additional total energy investments (as claimed by A20) is potentially an underestimate, with some models indicating figures closer to 200 billion US$/year when considering more moderate near-term carbon prices.
  • Recent datasets from NGFS and ENGAGE also suggest higher estimates for additional total energy investments for 2020-2024, ranging from 227 to 335 billion US$/year.
  • The paper highlights that only a small fraction of greenhouse gas emissions globally are currently covered by carbon pricing, and the average global price is significantly lower than what some IAMs assume for achieving climate targets.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Assumptions: The authors acknowledge that the response of final energy demand to carbon prices can vary across models, and their arguments about high carbon prices suppressing demand might not hold universally across all model assumptions and scenarios.
  • Need for Explicit Modeling: The paper strongly advocates for IAMs to explicitly model public spending and stimulus packages to better understand their role and impact on energy investments and prices.
  • In-depth Studies: More in-depth research is needed to investigate the complex relationship between carbon pricing, energy demand, and investment, particularly for scenarios where public support, rather than carbon pricing, is the primary driver of emission reduction policies.
  • Investment Classification: The authors suggest that IAMs should model different classes of investments based on their origin, destination, risk level, and expected return rate to provide a more nuanced understanding of climate finance.

Summary updated

Abstract

It has been claimed that COVID-19 public stimulus packages could be sufficient to meet the short-term energy investment needs to leverage a shift toward a pathway consistent with the 1.5 {\\deg}C target of the Paris Agreement. Here we provide complementary perspectives to reiterate that substantial, broad, and sustained engagements beyond recovery packages will be needed for achieving the Paris Agreement long-term targets. Low-carbon investments will need to scale up and persist over the next several decades following short-term stimulus packages. The required total energy investments in the real world can be larger than the currently available estimates from Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs). Existing databases from IAMs are not sufficient for analyzing the effect of public spending on emission reduction. To inform what role COVID-19 stimulus packages and public investments may play for reaching the Paris Agreement targets, explicit modelling of such policies is required.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tanaka2022paris,
  author = {Katsumasa Tanaka and Christian Azar and Oliviér Boucher and Philippe Ciais and Yann Gaucher and Daniel Johansson},
  title = {{Paris Agreement requires substantial, broad, and sustained engagements beyond COVID-19 recovery packages}},
  booktitle = {Climatic},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s10584-022-03355-6},
}

Loading related content...

Figure