Paraquat Preferentially Induces Apoptosis of Late Stage Effector Lymphocyte and Impairs Memory Immune Response in Mice

Yiming Shao, Yifan Zhao, Tingting Zhu, Fen Zhang, Xiuli Chang, Yubin Zhang, Zhijun ZhouInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the herbicide paraquat (PQ), at a dose of 20 mg/kg, impairs the development of long-term immune memory in mice. It achieves this by preferentially inducing apoptosis (programmed cell death) in late-stage effector immune cells during the initial response to an antigen, thereby reducing the pool of cells available to form lasting immunity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Paraquat (PQ) is a widely used, highly toxic herbicide known to affect various organs, including the immune system. While its general immunotoxicity has been studied, its specific impact on the development of memory immune responses remained largely unknown. Immune memory is crucial for long-term protection against pathogens, allowing the body to mount a faster and stronger response upon re-exposure. Understanding how environmental toxins like PQ might disrupt this vital process is critical for public health. This paper aims to fill that knowledge gap by investigating PQ's effect on the generation of immunological memory.

Methods

The researchers used a mouse model (C57BL/6 mice) to study the effects of PQ on immune memory.

  • PQ Treatment: Mice were treated with either a low dose (2 mg/kg) or a high dose (20 mg/kg) of PQ, or a vehicle control, every three days for two weeks.
  • Antigen Challenge: To induce an immune response, mice were injected with keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH), a common antigen used in immunology studies. A primary response was initiated, followed by a secondary (memory) response three months later.
  • Immune Cell Analysis:
    • Flow Cytometry: This technique was used to identify and quantify different types of immune cells (e.g., CD4 T cells, B cells) and assess their activation status (e.g., effector, memory, naive). It was also used to measure apoptosis (cell death) using Annexin V staining and cleaved caspase-3.
  • ELISA: Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays were employed to measure the levels of specific antibodies (IgM and IgG) in the serum, including anti-KLH IgG to assess the memory response.
  • In Vitro Studies:
    • KLH Stimulation: Splenic cells from PQ-treated mice were cultured with KLH in vitro to assess their proliferative capacity.
  • PQ Exposure of Purified Cells: Specific subtypes of lymphocytes (naïve, effector, and memory CD4 T cells, and different B cell populations) were purified and then exposed to PQ in vitro to directly assess its effect on their apoptosis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from animal models and in vitro cell cultures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Selective Apoptosis of Effector Cells: The most striking finding is that PQ doesn't broadly kill all immune cells. Instead, it specifically targets and induces apoptosis in late-stage effector CD4 T cells and activated B cells. This suggests a targeted mechanism rather than a general cytotoxic effect on all lymphocytes.
  • Timing is Crucial: PQ's impact on apoptosis is time-dependent. It doesn't significantly affect cell death during the early stages of the primary immune response but becomes potent in the late stages. This timing is critical because it's during these later stages that effector cells either die off or differentiate into memory cells.
  • Impaired Memory, Not Primary Response: While PQ significantly impairs the secondary (memory) immune response to KLH, it does not appear to affect the proliferation or co-stimulatory molecule expression of lymphocytes during the primary immune response. This suggests PQ's primary mechanism of immunotoxicity in this context is on memory cell generation, not on the initial fight against the antigen.
  • Dose-Dependent Effect: The low dose of PQ (2 mg/kg) had no discernible impact on memory immune response, highlighting the importance of dose in toxicological studies. The significant effects were observed at the higher dose (20 mg/kg).

Key Results

  • Reduced Serum IgG: Treatment with 20 mg/kg PQ significantly reduced serum IgG levels in mice, but not IgM.
  • Decreased Effector and Memory Lymphocytes: In steady-state conditions, 20 mg/kg PQ treatment led to a decrease in the number of effector and memory lymphocytes.
  • Impaired Secondary Response: Mice treated with 20 mg/kg PQ showed significantly reduced serum anti-KLH IgG levels after a secondary KLH challenge, indicating a weakened memory response.
  • Increased Late-Stage Apoptosis: PQ treatment (20 mg/kg) increased the apoptosis of CD4 T cells and B cells at days 7 and 9 post-KLH immunization, but not at day 4.
  • Preferential Apoptosis of Effector Cells In Vitro: Purified effector CD4 T cells and activated B cells were more sensitive to PQ-induced apoptosis in vitro compared to their naïve or memory counterparts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lung Toxicity Not Evaluated: The authors acknowledge that PQ is known to cause pulmonary fibrosis, and this study did not evaluate lung toxicity in the mice.
  • No "Real" Negative Control: Due to the use of CFA (a known immunomodulator) as a vehicle control for KLH immunization, a true "no treatment" negative control for the KLH experiment was not included.
  • Mechanism of Apoptosis: While the study shows PQ induces apoptosis, the precise molecular mechanisms (e.g., specific pathways like autophagy or necroptosis, role of ROS) are not fully elucidated and remain an area for future investigation.
  • Extrapolation to Humans: The study was conducted in mice, and direct extrapolation of these findings to human immune responses requires further research.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further investigation into the specific pathways PQ utilizes to induce apoptosis in effector cells and how this might relate to its known toxicity profiles (e.g., pulmonary fibrosis). Understanding the differential death pathways (apoptosis vs. necroptosis vs. autophagy) preferred by different lymphocyte subtypes in response to PQ is also highlighted as an area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Paraquat (PQ) is a toxic non-selective herbicide. To date, the effect of PQ on memory immune response is still unknown. We investigated the impact of PQ on memory immune response. Adult C57BL/6 mice were subcutaneously injected with 2 mg/kg PQ, 20 mg/kg PQ or vehicle control every three days for two weeks. A single injection of keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) at day four after the initial PQ treatment was used to induce a primary immune response; a second KLH challenge was performed at three months post the first KLH immunization to induce a secondary immune response. In steady state, treatment with 20 mg/kg PQ reduced the level of serum total IgG, but not that of IgM; treatment with 20 mg/kg PQ decreased the number of effector and memory lymphocytes, but not naïve or inactivated lymphocytes. During the primary immune response to KLH, treatment with 20 mg/kg PQ did not influence the proliferation of lymphocytes or expression of co-stimulatory molecules. Instead, treatment with 20 mg/kg PQ increased the apoptosis of lymphocytes at late stage, but not early stage of the primary immune response. During the secondary immune response to KLH, treatment with 20 mg/kg PQ reduced the serum anti-KLH IgG and KLH-responsive CD4 T cells and B cells. Moreover, effector or activated lymphocytes were more sensitive to PQ-induced apoptosis in vitro. Treatment with 2 mg/kg PQ did not impact memory immune response to KLH. Thus, treatment with 20 mg/kg PQ increased apoptosis of late stage effector cells to yield less memory cells and thereafter impair memory immune response, providing a novel understanding of the immunotoxicity of PQ.
BibTeX
@article{shao2019paraquat,
  author = {Yiming Shao and Yifan Zhao and Tingting Zhu and Fen Zhang and Xiuli Chang and Yubin Zhang and Zhijun Zhou},
  title = {{Paraquat Preferentially Induces Apoptosis of Late Stage Effector Lymphocyte and Impairs Memory Immune Response in Mice}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph16112060},
}
Figure