Abstract
In this paper, we study the average packet error probability (APEP) and effective throughput (ET) of the control link in unmanned-aerial-vehicle (UAV) communications, where the ground central station (GCS) sends control signals to the UAV that requires ultra-reliable and low-latency communications (URLLC). To ensure the low latency, short packets are adopted for the control signal. As a result, the Shannon capacity theorem cannot be adopted here due to its assumption of infinite channel blocklength. We consider both free space (FS) and 3-Dimensional (3D) channel models by assuming that the locations of the UAV are randomly distributed within a restricted space. We first characterize the statistical characteristics of the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) for both FS and 3D models. Then, the closed-form analytical expressions of APEP and ET are derived by using Gaussian-Chebyshev quadrature. Also, the lower bounds are derived to obtain more insights. Finally, we obtain the optimal value of packet length with the objective of maximizing the ET by applying one-dimensional search. Our analytical results are verified by the Monte-Carlo simulations.
Introduction
Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) rely on a Ground Central Station (GCS) for safety-critical control signals. These signals require Ultra-Reliable and Low-Latency Communications (URLLC): they must arrive almost instantly and with near-zero errors to prevent collisions. To minimize latency, these systems use "short packets."
The challenge is that the cornerstone of modern communications—the Shannon capacity theorem—assumes "infinite blocklength." In the real world of short packets, this assumption breaks down, leading to significant underestimations of error rates. Furthermore, UAVs are mobile; their distance and angle relative to the ground station change constantly. This paper fills the gap by providing a statistical model that combines finite blocklength theory with the spatial randomness of UAV flight.
Methodology
The authors employed several sophisticated mathematical techniques to bridge the gap between theory and practice. They modeled the UAV's location as a random variable within a 3D hemispherical shell, defined by minimum and maximum distances and elevation angles.
Key components of the approach include:
- Finite Blocklength Theory: Instead of Shannon’s formula, they used a tight approximation for packet error probability that accounts for "channel dispersion."
- Stochastic Geometry: Modeling the UAV's location within a restricted 3D space.
- Gaussian-Chebyshev Quadrature: To solve the complex integrals resulting from the random UAV positions, this numerical method was used to derive accurate, closed-form analytical expressions for Average Packet Error Probability (APEP) and Effective Throughput (ET).
Key Insights and Results
The analytical models for APEP and ET were verified to be extremely tight to simulation results across various power levels and packet lengths.
- The "Sweet Spot" for Packet Length: There is a fundamental trade-off. Longer packets reduce the error probability but decrease the overall data rate per channel use. The paper demonstrates that an optimal packet length exists for every environment.
- Geometry is Destiny: In 3D urban models, the elevation angle is just as important as distance. Higher elevation angles increase the probability of a clear Line-of-Sight (LoS), significantly boosting reliability.
- Urban vs. Suburban: Dense urban environments require significantly longer packets (e.g., $M=224$) compared to suburban areas ($M=186$) to achieve optimal throughput, due to the higher likelihood of signal blockage by buildings.
- Computational Efficiency: The derived Chebyshev approximations are shown to be nearly identical to time-consuming Monte-Carlo simulations, providing engineers with a fast tool for system design.
Conclusion
This study provides a rigorous mathematical framework for analyzing and optimizing UAV control links under URLLC requirements. While the focus is on point-to-point links, the authors suggest extending this framework to multi-UAV networks and relay-assisted communications in future work.
Summary updated