P137/17 Incidence and outcome of perforations occuring during Medium-Vessel Occlusion thrombectomy compared to Large-Vessel occlusion thrombectomy

Victor Schulze-Zachau, Alex Brehm, Nikolaos Ntoulias, Nadja Krug, Ioannis Tsogkas, Kristine A. Blackham, Markus Möhlenbruch, Jessica Jesser, Amedeo Cervo, Kornelia Kreiser, Katharina Althaus, Errikos Maslias, Patrik Michel, Guillaume Saliou, Christoph Riegler, Christian H. Nolte, Ilko Maier, Ala Jamous, Riitta Rautio, Pauli Ylikotila, Kyle M Fargen, Stacey Q Wolfe, Davide Castellano, Andrea Boghi, Daniel Kaiser, Ani Cuberi, Jan S. Kirschke, Julian Schwarting, Nicola Limbucci, Leonardo Renieri, Sami Al Kasab, Alejandro M Spiotta, Isabel Fragata, Tania Rodríguez-Ares, Christoph J. Maurer, Berlis Ansgar, Manuel Moreu, Alfonso López-Frías López-Jurado, Carlos Pérez-García, Christian Commodaro, Marco Pileggi, Justin Mascitelli, Flavio Giordano, Walter Casagrande, Cynthia Purves, Maxim Bester, Fabian Flottmann, Peter Kan, Gautam Edhayan, Jérémy Hofmeister, Paolo Machi, Marius Kaschner, Daniel Weiß, Mira Katan, Urs Fischer, Marios PsychogiosAbstracts 2023 · DOI

This summary covers the research abstract P137/17: Incidence and outcome of perforations occurring during Medium-Vessel Occlusion thrombectomy compared to Large-Vessel occlusion thrombectomy, presented at the ESMINT 2023 conference.

TL;DR

Vessel perforation is twice as likely to occur during mechanical thrombectomy for medium-vessel occlusions (MeVO) compared to large-vessel occlusions (LVO). Despite this higher risk, MeVO patients who suffer a perforation actually have significantly better functional recovery than LVO patients with the same complication.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mechanical thrombectomy—the physical removal of a blood clot from the brain—is the gold standard for treating major strokes. While originally reserved for large-vessel occlusions (LVO), surgeons are increasingly moving "downstream" to treat medium-vessel occlusions (MeVO).

However, smaller vessels are more tortuous and fragile. The clinical community has long hypothesized that MeVO procedures carry a higher risk of vessel perforation (tearing the artery), but large-scale comparative data has been scarce. This study aims to quantify that risk and determine if a perforation in a medium vessel is as clinically devastating as one in a large vessel.

Methods

The researchers conducted a multicenter retrospective cohort study spanning 25 stroke centers. They analyzed data from consecutive patients treated between January 2015 and September 2022.

The study compared two primary groups:

  1. MeVO: Occlusions in smaller, more distal branches.
  2. LVO: Occlusions in the main, large arteries of the brain.

The primary endpoints were functional independence (defined as a modified Rankin Scale score of 0–2) and all-cause mortality at 90 days. Statistical significance was determined using binomial, chi-squared, and t-tests for unpaired samples.

Datasets

The study utilized a massive clinical dataset comprising 25,769 thrombectomy procedures:

  • 5,124 MeVO cases.
  • 20,645 LVO cases.

From this pool, they identified 335 patients who experienced a vessel perforation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Double Risk" Factor: The intuition that smaller vessels are more dangerous is correct. Perforations occurred in 2.4% of MeVO cases compared to only 1.0% of LVO cases.
  • The Resilience of MeVO Patients: Surprisingly, even when a perforation occurs, MeVO patients fare better. They were more than twice as likely to achieve functional independence (25.7%) compared to LVO patients (10.9%) who suffered a perforation.
  • The "Natural Course" Argument: The authors note that MeVO strokes often have a more "benign natural course" than LVO strokes. Because the initial stroke damage is often less extensive in MeVO, these patients may have more "neurological reserve" to survive the complication of a perforation.
  • Identifying the Danger Zones: The study pinpointed the specific procedural steps most likely to cause a tear: navigating the wire/catheter beyond the occlusion and the retraction of the stent-retriever or aspiration catheter.

Key Results

  • Perforation Rate: 2.4% (MeVO) vs. 1.0% (LVO) — a statistically significant difference (p < 0.001).
  • Functional Independence at 90 Days: 25.7% (MeVO) vs. 10.9% (LVO) (p = 0.001).
  • Mortality: No significant difference between the two groups; the overall mortality rate for patients who suffered a perforation was high at 51.6%.
  • Demographics: The average age of patients with perforations was 72 years, and 62% were female.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that because MeVO strokes are naturally less severe, the threshold for "acceptable risk" is much lower.

Limitations: * As a retrospective study, there may be selection bias in which patients were chosen for MeVO thrombectomy versus medical management. * The abstract does not detail the specific types of devices (stent-retrievers vs. aspiration) used in each perforation case, which could influence the results.

Future Work: The authors suggest that procedural optimization is critical. Future research should focus on developing safer navigation techniques and specialized tools designed specifically for the delicate architecture of medium vessels to mitigate the higher perforation risk.

Summary updated

Abstract

<h3>Introduction</h3> Vessel perforation during thrombectomy is a severe complication and is hypothesized to be more frequent during MeVO compared to LVO thrombectomy. <h3>Aim of the study</h3> To compare the incidence and outcome of patients with perforation during MeVO and LVO thrombectomy and to report on the procedural steps that led to perforation. <h3>Methods</h3> In this multicenter retrospective cohort study, data of consecutive patients with vessel perforation during thrombectomy between January 01, 2015 and September 30, 2022 were collected. The primary outcomes were independent functional outcome (i.e. modified Rankin Scale 0–2) and all-cause mortality at 90 days. Binomial test, chi-squared test and t-test for unpaired samples were used for statistical analysis. <h3>Results</h3> During 25,769 thrombectomies (5,124 MeVO, 20,645 LVO) in 25 stroke centers, perforation occurred in 335 patients (1.3%; mean age 72 years, 62% female). Perforation occurred more often in MeVO thrombectomy (2.4%) than in LVO thrombectomy (1.0%, p &lt; 0.001). More MeVO than LVO patients with perforation achieved functional independence at three months (25.7% vs 10.9%; p=0.001). All-cause mortality did not differ (overall 51.6%). Navigation beyond the occlusion and retraction of stent-retriever/aspiration catheter were the two most common procedural steps that led to perforation. <h3>Conclusions</h3> In our cohort, perforation was approximately twice as frequent in MeVO than in LVO thrombectomy. Considering the rather benign natural course of MeVO stroke, physicians should be avoiding perforation during MeVO thrombectomy by all means. Efforts to optimize the procedure may focus on navigation beyond the occlusion site and retraction of stent-retriever/aspiration catheter. <h3>Disclosure of Interest</h3> Nothing to disclose
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schulzezachau2023p,
  author = {Victor Schulze-Zachau and Alex Brehm and Nikolaos Ntoulias and Nadja Krug and Ioannis Tsogkas and Kristine A. Blackham and Markus Möhlenbruch and Jessica Jesser and Amedeo Cervo and Kornelia Kreiser and Katharina Althaus and Errikos Maslias and Patrik Michel and Guillaume Saliou and Christoph Riegler and Christian H. Nolte and Ilko Maier and Ala Jamous and Riitta Rautio and Pauli Ylikotila and Kyle M Fargen and Stacey Q Wolfe and Davide Castellano and Andrea Boghi and Daniel Kaiser and Ani Cuberi and Jan S. Kirschke and Julian Schwarting and Nicola Limbucci and Leonardo Renieri and Sami Al Kasab and Alejandro M Spiotta and Isabel Fragata and Tania Rodríguez-Ares and Christoph J. Maurer and Berlis Ansgar and Manuel Moreu and Alfonso López-Frías López-Jurado and Carlos Pérez-García and Christian Commodaro and Marco Pileggi and Justin Mascitelli and Flavio Giordano and Walter Casagrande and Cynthia Purves and Maxim Bester and Fabian Flottmann and Peter Kan and Gautam Edhayan and Jérémy Hofmeister and Paolo Machi and Marius Kaschner and Daniel Weiß and Mira Katan and Urs Fischer and Marios Psychogios},
  title = {{P137/17 Incidence and outcome of perforations occuring during Medium-Vessel Occlusion thrombectomy compared to Large-Vessel occlusion thrombectomy}},
  booktitle = {Abstracts},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1136/jnis-2023-esmint.165},
}
Figure