Abstract
Final successful reperfusion rate after PCA was higher than after SR only. Functional and safety outcomes were not significantly different. Further research is warranted, including individual patient data meta-analyses and data on novel aspiration devices not used in this trial.
Introduction
Mechanical thrombectomy is the established standard for Large Vessel Occlusions (LVOs), but its application in Medium or Distal Vessel Occlusions (MDVOs) remains a therapeutic challenge. MDVOs involve smaller, more fragile, and tortuous vessels that are prone to collapse or injury during mechanical retrieval. Currently, interventionalists utilize three primary strategies: pure aspiration (ADAPT), stent retriever only (SR), and the Primary Combined Approach (PCA), which uses both techniques simultaneously. This study evaluates which approach offers the optimal balance of technical success and patient safety.
Methods
This study is a post hoc analysis of the DISTAL Trial, a prospective, randomized multicenter study conducted between 2021 and 2024. The analysis included 222 patients who underwent thrombectomy for MDVOs. The researchers compared ADAPT, SR only, and PCA across technical efficacy (first-pass success and final reperfusion), clinical efficacy (modified Rankin Scale at 90 days), and safety (intracranial hemorrhage and vessel perforation). Mixed-effects logistic regression models were used to account for hospital center and clot location variables.
Results
Technical vs. Clinical Efficacy
The Primary Combined Approach (PCA) emerged as the most effective technique for vessel restoration. PCA achieved a significantly higher first-pass success rate (66.4%) compared to ADAPT (44.4%), with an adjusted Odds Ratio (aOR) of 2.37. Final successful reperfusion (mTICI 2b–3) was also highest in the PCA group at 82.4%, compared to 76.5% for ADAPT and 61.1% for SR only.
Despite these technical advantages, clinical outcomes did not show a corresponding improvement. Functional independence (mRS 0–2 at 90 days) was remarkably similar across all groups: 58.3% for ADAPT, 54.0% for SR only, and 53.7% for PCA.
Safety Outcomes
Safety data revealed a numerical trend toward higher rates of symptomatic intracranial hemorrhage (sICH) in the PCA group (7.4%) compared to the ADAPT group (2.8%). While not statistically significant, this suggests that the mechanical force of combined approaches may be more taxing on delicate distal vessels.
Discussion and Conclusion
While PCA is the most reliable method for opening distal vessels, its technical superiority does not yet translate into improved long-term patient recovery. This "disconnect" may be due to the increased mechanical stress of combined techniques or the complexity of managing hardware in small vessels. Limitations of this analysis include operator bias in technique selection and limited statistical power for safety endpoints. Future research, including randomized trials and the evaluation of novel micro-aspiration devices, is necessary to determine if technical gains can be converted into better clinical outcomes for stroke survivors.
Summary updated