Oxytocin Receptor Gene Polymorphisms and Early Parental Bonding Interact in Shaping Instagram Social Behavior

Andrea Bonassi, Ilaria Cataldo, Giulio Gabrieli, Jia Nee Foo, Bruno Lepri, Gianluca Esposito

TL;DR

This study explores how genetic predispositions related to the oxytocin receptor gene (OXTr) interact with early childhood parental bonding experiences to influence social behavior on Instagram. The findings suggest that individuals with specific OXTr gene variations and a history of low paternal care or high maternal overprotection exhibit distinct patterns of online social engagement, highlighting a gene-environment interplay in shaping digital social lives.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While we know that human social behavior is influenced by both genetics and environmental factors, understanding how these elements combine to shape specific behaviors, especially in the context of rapidly evolving digital environments like social media, remains a challenge. This paper tackles the question of how individual differences in social interaction frequency and quality online, specifically on Instagram, can be explained by the interplay between genetic variations in the oxytocin receptor gene (OXTr) and recalled childhood parental relationships. Previous research has established the importance of both genetics and early bonding for social development, but their combined effect on nuanced online social behaviors like Instagram usage is underexplored.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining genetic analysis, self-reported psychological assessments, and objective data extraction from social media profiles.

  • Genetic Assessment: DNA was extracted from buccal mucosa samples to genotype participants for two specific single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the oxytocin receptor gene (OXTr): rs2254298 and rs53576. Participants were then categorized based on their genotypes (e.g., G/G homozygotes vs. A-carriers for rs2254298).
  • Parental Bonding Assessment: The Parental Bonding Instrument (PBI) was used to measure participants' recalled experiences of care and overprotection from their parents during childhood. This yielded scores for paternal care, maternal care, paternal overprotection, and maternal overprotection.
  • Instagram Data Extraction: Publicly available data from participants' Instagram profiles was collected. Key metrics included the number of "followings" (accounts followed), "followers" (accounts following the participant), number of posts, and a "Social Desirability Index" (SDI), calculated as the ratio of followers to followings.
  • Statistical Analysis: A combination of regression analyses and post-hoc tests were used to examine main effects of genotype and parental bonding, as well as their interaction effects on the Instagram variables. Bonferroni corrections were applied to account for multiple comparisons.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • Participant Genotypes: Collected from buccal mucosa samples.
  • Self-Reported Parental Bonding: Data from the Parental Bonding Instrument (PBI).
  • Instagram Profile Data: Publicly available metrics (followings, followers, posts, SDI) extracted from participants' Instagram profiles.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gene-Environment Interaction is Key: The study strongly supports the idea that it's not just genetics or environment in isolation, but their interaction, that shapes complex behaviors like social media use.
  • The Oxytocin Receptor Gene's Role: The OXTr gene, known for its involvement in social bonding and behavior, appears to play a significant role in how individuals express their social selves online, particularly when interacting with their early life experiences.
  • Sensitivity Hypothesis in Action: The findings align with the "sensitivity hypothesis," suggesting that individuals with certain genetic predispositions (A-carriers for rs2254298) are more sensitive to their environment, leading to more pronounced effects from both positive and negative early experiences on their social behavior.
  • Instagram as a Window: Instagram, with its focus on visual self-presentation and social networking, serves as a valuable platform for observing these gene-environment interactions in a modern social context.

Key Results

  • OXTr rs2254298 and Instagram Posts: A significant gene-environment interaction was found between the OXTr rs2254298 genotype and paternal care on the number of Instagram posts. Specifically, individuals with the "genetic risk factor" (A-carriers) who reported low paternal care posted significantly fewer times than those with the G/G genotype. This suggests that a lack of early paternal warmth, combined with a specific genetic makeup, can lead to reduced online self-expression.
  • OXTr rs2254298 and Social Desirability Index (SDI): Another significant interaction was observed between the OXTr rs2254298 genotype and maternal overprotection on the Instagram SDI. A-carriers with high maternal overprotection showed a decreasing trend in their SDI, while those with low maternal overprotection showed an increasing trend. This indicates that early maternal control can influence how individuals manage their online social image and the balance between seeking recognition (followers) and engaging with others (followings).
  • No Significant Interactions for OXTr rs53576: Interestingly, no significant gene-environment interactions were found for the OXTr rs53576 polymorphism with any of the parental bonding dimensions on Instagram social behaviors. This might be due to allele frequency distributions or the specific role of rs53576 in other forms of sociality.
  • Gender Differences: While most analyses focused on gene-environment interactions, a preliminary finding indicated that males had a higher number of Instagram followings than females.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size and Demographics: The sample size (N=57) was relatively small, and predominantly female, which may limit the generalizability of the findings.
  • Retrospective Reporting: The Parental Bonding Instrument relies on self-reported, retrospective data, which can be subject to recall bias.
  • Limited Instagram Variables: Only four specific Instagram variables were analyzed. Future research could explore a wider range of online behaviors.
  • Genetic Candidate Selection: Only two OXTr SNPs were investigated. Future studies could incorporate other genetic factors (e.g., serotonin, dopamine) and their interactions with environmental factors.

Future research directions include:

  • Longitudinal Studies: Employing longitudinal designs to track parental practices and online behavior over time.
  • Observational Techniques: Using observational methods to assess caregiving patterns more objectively.
  • Broader Genetic and Environmental Factors: Investigating a wider array of genetic polymorphisms and environmental influences, including hormonal factors and social characteristics.
  • Non-Western Samples: Expanding research to diverse cultural contexts, as the current study was conducted on a non-Western sample, which is often under-represented.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human beings engage in multiple social interactions daily, both in person and online. There are, however, individual differences in the frequency and quality of these interactions. This exploratory study focuses on online interactions and aims to model these differences by looking at potential environmental and genetic factors. The environmental factor is the childhood parental relationship, as reported by the participants in the dimensions of the Parental Bonding Instrument (N = 57, 41 females). At a genetic level, buccal mucosa cell samples were collected to assess participants' genetic susceptibility, and OXTr regions rs2254298 (G/G homozygotes vs. A-carriers) and rs53576 (A/A homozygotes vs. G-carriers) were analyzed. To capture participants' online activity, Instagram was probed. The number of people that the individual follows ("followings"), followers, and posts were used as a proxy for the quantity of interaction, and a Social Desirability Index (SDI) was computed as the ratio of followers to followings. An interaction between OXTr groups and parental bonding scores on the number of followings and posts was hypothesized. A gene-environment interaction for OXTr/rs2254298 on the number of Instagram posts was identified. In line with the hypothesis, participants with a genetic risk factor (A-carriers) and a history of low paternal care showed fewer Instagram posts than those without this risk factor (G/G genotype). Moreover, an interaction effect between maternal overprotection and OXTr/rs2254298 on the Instagram SDI was detected. These findings could represent an indirect pathway through which genes and parental behavior interact to shape social interactions on Instagram.
BibTeX
@article{bonassi2020oxytocin,
  author = {Andrea Bonassi and Ilaria Cataldo and Giulio Gabrieli and Jia Nee Foo and Bruno Lepri and Gianluca Esposito},
  title = {{Oxytocin Receptor Gene Polymorphisms and Early Parental Bonding Interact in Shaping Instagram Social Behavior}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17197232},
}
Figure