Output characteristics of three 200-watt series transformers with multiple lamps as load

James Davis1959 · DOI

National Bureau of Standards Report Header

Abstract

This report presents data from performance tests of three 6.6/6.6-ampere, 200-watt runway-lighting transformers, each from a different manufacturer. The study evaluates their output characteristics when loaded with various 120-volt multiple-type lamps. By intentionally driving these isolating transformers into magnetic saturation, researchers identified a method to stabilize light output for auxiliary airfield markers, reducing the extreme intensity fluctuations typical of standard series circuits.

Introduction

In 1959, the National Bureau of Standards (NBS) investigated an engineering solution for a specific challenge in airfield lighting: maintaining visible light levels for auxiliary markers—such as runway distance indicators and taxiway signs—across all brightness settings of a constant-current regulator. While standard series-type lamps are efficient for runway lighting, their extreme sensitivity to current changes makes them unsuitable for auxiliary signs that must remain visible even when main runway lights are dimmed.

The Problem: Intensity Ratios in Series Circuits

Airfield lighting in the mid-20th century relied heavily on constant-current series circuits. These circuits are ideal for long cable runs but present a significant hurdle for dimming. When a regulator is adjusted from its highest setting (Step 5) to its lowest (Step 1), the current drop causes the light output of a standard series lamp to plummet by a ratio of approximately 500:1. At lower steps, auxiliary markers powered by these lamps become virtually invisible to pilots.

The goal of the NBS study was to find a way to use existing series infrastructure to power these aids while achieving a much more stable light output—ideally maintaining a ratio of 5:1 or 10:1 across all regulator settings.

Methodology: Testing Magnetic Saturation

Researcher James E. Davis conducted empirical tests on three 200-watt isolating transformers (manufactured by AGA, Jefferson, and Line Material) built to Air Force Specification 32635. The core strategy involved using 120V "multiple-type" (parallel) lamps as the load instead of standard series lamps.

Experimental Variables

  • Variable Loading: The secondary sides of the transformers were loaded with combinations of 25W, 100W, and 300W lamps to create total loads ranging from 25W to 1000W.
  • Circuit Simulation: Testing occurred under two primary conditions: connected to a realistic 16,000-foot runway circuit with 34 other transformers, and connected directly to a 15-kilowatt constant-current regulator.
  • Measurement: The team recorded secondary voltage and current across five regulator intensity steps. Light output (lumens) was then calculated using voltage-to-lumen factors derived from standard lamp catalogs.

Key Insights and Results

Saturation as a Stabilizer

The study's most significant finding was that a saturated transformer core acts as an effective current limiter. By overloading a 200W transformer with a higher-wattage lamp load (e.g., 300W or 500W), the transformer reaches magnetic saturation earlier in the current cycle. This flattens the output curve, making the lamp's intensity far less sensitive to the primary current provided by the regulator.

Improved Intensity Ratios

For loads exceeding 100W, the ratio of light output between Step 5 and Step 1 was dramatically reduced to approximately 2:1. This represents a massive improvement over the 500:1 ratio seen in standard configurations, ensuring that markers remain clearly visible even at the lowest regulator settings.

Performance Characteristics

  • Optimal Load: Maximum light output did not occur at the transformer's rated 200W load. Instead, peak lumens (ranging from 1000 to 2100 depending on the manufacturer) were achieved with lamp loads between 200W and 500W.
  • Manufacturer Variance: Despite adhering to the same military specification, the three transformers exhibited distinct saturation characteristics. This suggests that internal design and material choices significantly influence performance in saturated states.
  • Waveform Sensitivity: The output waveform of the regulator changed based on the total circuit load, which in turn affected the individual transformer performance.

Conclusion

The 1959 NBS report demonstrated that utilizing magnetic saturation in isolating transformers is a viable method for stabilizing auxiliary airfield lighting. By carefully selecting lamp loads, engineers could leverage existing series circuit infrastructure to provide consistent visual guidance. While the study focused on 120V lamps, it laid the groundwork for further optimization using different lamp voltages and highlighted the importance of transformer design in non-linear operating regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

This report presents the data from tests made of series-series transformers using different wattage, 120-volt, multiple-type lamps as the load.Three 6.6/6.6-ampere, 200-watt, runway-lighting trans- formers, each from a different manufacturer, were tested to determine output characteristics.The characteristics of the transformers are shown as plots of secondary voltage versus current and of output wattage as a function of the rated wattage of the lamp load.Plots of the computed light output of the lamps as a function of rated lamp load are also included. 1.'
BibTeX
@misc{davis1959output,
  author = {James Davis},
  title = {{Output characteristics of three 200-watt series transformers with multiple lamps as load}},
  year = {1959},
  doi = {10.6028/nbs.rpt.6337},
}
Figure