Organometallic Pillarplexes That Bind DNA 4-Way Holliday Junctions and Forks

James S. Craig, Larry Melidis, Hugo D. Williams, Samuel J. Dettmer, Alexandra A. Heidecker, Philipp J. Altmann, Shengyang Guan, Callum J. Campbell, Douglas F. Browning, Roland K. O. Sigel, Silke Johannsen, Ross T. Egan, Brech Aikman, Angela Casini, Alexander Pöthig, Michael J. Hannon

TL;DR

Researchers have developed novel organometallic "pillarplexes" that can bind to and stabilize open DNA 4-way Holliday junctions, a crucial but previously difficult-to-target structure involved in DNA repair and recombination. These pillarplexes offer a new avenue for modulating DNA structures in biological systems and synthetic nanostructures, showing promising antiproliferative activity in cancer cells.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

DNA exists in various forms beyond the familiar double helix. Non-canonical structures like Holliday junctions (4-way junctions or 4WJs) and three-way junctions (3WJs) are critical for fundamental biological processes such as DNA repair, recombination, and replication. These junctions are dynamic, existing in either open or closed conformations. The open conformation is often the biologically active one, presenting a cavity that is an attractive target for therapeutic agents. However, synthetic agents capable of specifically binding to and stabilizing these open junction structures, particularly the 4WJ, have been limited. Previous work focused on metallo-supramolecular cylinders that preferentially bind 3WJs and can even rearrange 4WJs into 3WJs. This paper addresses the need for agents that can directly target and interact with the open 4WJ conformation, opening up new possibilities for therapeutic intervention and DNA-based nanotechnology.

Methods

The study employed a combination of experimental and computational techniques:

  • Gel Electrophoresis (PAGE): This was the primary experimental method to observe the binding of pillarplexes to different DNA structures (3WJ, 4WJ, Y-forks, and duplex DNA). By analyzing band shifts, researchers could infer binding events and structural changes.
  • DNA Melting Experiments: UV-Vis spectroscopy was used to monitor the thermal stability of DNA structures in the presence and absence of the pillarplexes, providing insights into the extent of stabilization.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: These simulations were crucial for visualizing the atomic-level interactions between the pillarplexes and DNA junctions. They helped to understand how the pillarplexes fit into the junction cavities, the conformational changes induced, and the dynamics of base pairing.
  • Flow Linear Dichroism (LD) and Circular Dichroism (CD) Spectroscopy: These techniques were used to probe the orientation and structural integrity of DNA in the presence of pillarplexes, particularly for duplex DNA.
  • Cellular Uptake and Cytotoxicity Assays: Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) was used to quantify intracellular metal content, and cell viability assays were performed to assess antiproliferative activity.

The novelty lies in the application of these pillarplexes, a class of tetracationic metallo-supramolecular cages, to target DNA junctions, particularly the open 4WJ. The MD simulations were specifically adapted to study the dynamic interactions with these complex DNA structures.

Datasets

The study utilized synthetic DNA sequences designed to form specific structures:

  • 3-way junctions (3WJ): Assembled from three 14-mer strands.
  • 4-way junctions (4WJ): Assembled from four complementary strands, based on sequences previously used in the literature for 4WJ binding studies.
  • Y-shaped forks: Formed from combinations of DNA strands.
  • Double-stranded DNA (dsDNA): Including a 21-mer duplex (DS-21), a 24-mer palindromic sequence (Pal24), and a plasmid DNA (pBR-322).
  • Mismatch 3WJ (mm-3WJ): A modified 3WJ designed to have a less stable central cavity.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study used established DNA constructs and sequences to investigate the binding properties of the novel pillarplexes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Targeting the Open 4WJ: The most significant finding is the ability of the Au pillarplex to bind to and stabilize the open conformation of DNA 4-way Holliday junctions. This is a novel binding mode not previously achieved with synthetic agents.
  • Pillarplex Size Matters: The larger girth of the pillarplex, compared to previously studied metallo-supramolecular cylinders, allows it to interact with and expand the cavity of 3WJs, leading to base-pair disruption and increased hydrodynamic size.
  • Junction Rearrangement: At higher concentrations, both 3WJs and 4WJs are rearranged by the pillarplex into Y-shaped forks, suggesting a preference for these structures when junction cavities become saturated or less accessible.
  • Differential Binding Preferences: The Au pillarplex shows a preference for 4WJs and Y-forks over 3WJs, and 3WJs over duplex DNA. This contrasts with metallo-supramolecular cylinders, which prefer 3WJs and can rearrange 4WJs into 3WJs.
  • Organometallic Chemistry for DNA Binding: The use of N-heterocyclic carbene ligands in the pillarplexes expands the design space for bioactive junction binders into organometallic chemistry.
  • Cellular Uptake and Cytotoxicity: The Au pillarplex can enter human lung cells (A549) and reach the nucleus, exhibiting antiproliferative activity comparable to cisplatin, suggesting therapeutic potential.

Key Results

  • 3WJ Binding: Au pillarplex successfully binds to and stabilizes 3WJs, but at higher loadings, it promotes the formation of Y-shaped forks.
  • 4WJ Binding: Au pillarplex binds to 4WJs, stabilizing an open, cruciform-like structure. This binding is stronger than for 3WJs.
  • Duplex DNA Interaction: Pillarplexes interact with duplex DNA, causing retardation in gel electrophoresis and DNA condensation, though junctions are preferred targets.
  • MD Simulations: Simulations confirmed that pillarplexes enter 3WJ and 4WJ cavities, inducing base-pair disruption and cavity expansion in 3WJs, and promoting an open 4WJ structure.
  • Thermal Stability: DNA melting experiments showed that both pillarplexes and cylinders stabilize 3WJs, but the cylinder provides greater stabilization, consistent with the pillarplex disrupting base pairs.
  • Cellular Activity: Au pillarplex enters A549 lung cells and accumulates in the nucleus, showing moderate cytotoxicity (IC50 11-12 µM at 72h), comparable to cisplatin.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pillarplex Size Mismatch: The authors note that the pillarplex is slightly too small to completely fill an open 4WJ cavity, which might explain the competition observed between 4WJ binding and Y-fork formation at high loadings. This suggests scope for designing slightly larger agents.
  • Ag Pillarplex Stability: While isostructural Ag pillarplexes show similar binding behavior, their lower solution stability and susceptibility to degradation in the presence of chloride ions complicate experimental studies.
  • In Vivo Mechanisms: The paper highlights the potential for future detailed studies on the in-cellulo effects of Holliday junction binding, particularly given the observed nuclear localization of the Au pillarplex without immediate cytotoxicity.
  • Synthetic Nanostructures: The ability of pillarplexes to modulate and switch DNA junction structures is of particular interest for applications in nucleic acid nanostructure construction, an area the authors are actively exploring.
  • Rotaxane Formation: The pillarplex structure's potential for rotaxane formation is mentioned as an avenue for further chemical toolbox expansion for junction binders.

Summary updated

Abstract

Holliday 4-way junctions are key to important biological DNA processes (insertion, recombination, and repair) and are dynamic structures that adopt either open or closed conformations, the open conformation being the biologically active form. Tetracationic metallo-supramolecular pillarplexes display aryl faces about a cylindrical core, an ideal structure to interact with open DNA junction cavities. Combining experimental studies and MD simulations, we show that an Au pillarplex can bind DNA 4-way (Holliday) junctions in their open form, a binding mode not accessed by synthetic agents before. Pillarplexes can bind 3-way junctions too, but their large size leads them to open up and expand that junction, disrupting the base pairing, which manifests in an increased hydrodynamic size and lower junction thermal stability. At high loading, they rearrange both 4-way and 3-way junctions into Y-shaped forks to increase the available junction-like binding sites. Isostructural Ag pillarplexes show similar DNA junction binding behavior but lower solution stability. This pillarplex binding contrasts with (but complements) that of metallo-supramolecular cylinders, which prefer 3-way junctions and can rearrange 4-way junctions into 3-way junction structures. The pillarplexes' ability to bind open 4-way junctions creates exciting possibilities to modulate and switch such structures in biology, as well as in synthetic nucleic acid nanostructures. In human cells, the pillarplexes do reach the nucleus, with antiproliferative activity at levels similar to those of cisplatin. The findings provide a new roadmap for targeting higher-order junction structures using a metallo-supramolecular approach, as well as expanding the toolbox available to design bioactive junction binders into organometallic chemistry.
BibTeX
@article{craig2023organometallic,
  author = {James S. Craig and Larry Melidis and Hugo D. Williams and Samuel J. Dettmer and Alexandra A. Heidecker and Philipp J. Altmann and Shengyang Guan and Callum J. Campbell and Douglas F. Browning and Roland K. O. Sigel and Silke Johannsen and Ross T. Egan and Brech Aikman and Angela Casini and Alexander Pöthig and Michael J. Hannon},
  title = {{Organometallic Pillarplexes That Bind DNA 4-Way Holliday Junctions and Forks}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.3c00118},
}
Figure