Orbitofrontal control of visual cortex gain promotes visual associative learning

Dechen Liu, Juan Deng, Zhewei Zhang, Zhiyu Zhang, Yan-Gang Sun, Tianming Yang, Haishan Yao

TL;DR

This study reveals a crucial role for the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) in visual associative learning by demonstrating how its projections to the primary visual cortex (V1) modulate V1's response gain. By selectively activating inhibitory interneurons in V1, the OFC helps filter out irrelevant visual information, thereby promoting the learning of associations between visual cues and outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) is known to be involved in flexible, outcome-guided behavior, encoding expected outcomes and playing a role in learning from discrepancies between expectations and reality. While the OFC has known projections to primary sensory areas like the visual cortex (V1), the precise function of this top-down connection in learning has remained unclear. Specifically, how OFC signals influence V1's processing of visual information during associative learning tasks, and whether this influence is critical for the learning process itself, was an open question.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining optogenetics, in vivo electrophysiology, slice electrophysiology, and behavioral paradigms in mice.

  • Optogenetics: They used channelrhodopsin (ChR2) and chrimsonR to activate OFC projections to V1, and the inhibitory opsin Jaws to inactivate these projections. They also used optogenetic stimulation to activate specific interneuron subtypes (SST, PV, VIP) in V1.
  • In Vivo Electrophysiology: Single-unit recordings were performed in V1 and OFC of behaving mice during a visual task to monitor neuronal activity.
  • Slice Electrophysiology: Whole-cell recordings were used in acute V1 slices to investigate the synaptic mechanisms by which OFC axons influence V1 neurons, including the role of local interneurons.
  • Behavioral Paradigm: A Go/No-Go visual task was used, where mice learned to associate visual stimuli with water rewards or no rewards. This task allowed for the assessment of learning and the modulation of V1 responses to reward-irrelevant stimuli.
  • Circuit Tracing: Viral tracing techniques (CTB, rAAV2-retro, rabies virus) were used to identify the projection targets of OFC neurons in V1 and the subtypes of V1 interneurons innervated by the OFC.
  • Fiber Photometry: This technique was used to measure the calcium activity of specific interneuron populations in V1 in response to OFC stimulation.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study utilized data collected from experiments on mice performing a Go/No-Go visual task. This involved recording neuronal activity (spikes, calcium signals) and behavioral responses (licking) under various optogenetic manipulation conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OFC-V1 Connection Modulates V1 Gain: Activating the OFC projection to V1 directly suppresses V1 neuronal responses. This suppression is mediated by the recruitment of local somatostatin-expressing (SST) interneurons in V1. This suggests a mechanism for controlling the "gain" or overall responsiveness of V1 neurons.
  • Outcome Expectancy in V1: During the Go/No-Go task, V1 neurons show differential responses to the "No-Go" stimulus based on whether the animal's expectation of reward is correct or incorrect. Specifically, responses are lower when the expectation is correct (i.e., anticipating no reward and correctly withholding a lick).
  • OFC is Crucial for Outcome-Expectancy Modulation: Inactivating the OFC projection to V1 during the task disrupts this outcome-expectancy modulation of V1 responses to the No-Go stimulus, particularly in trials where the animal correctly rejects the stimulus.
  • V1-Projecting OFC Neurons Show Opposite Modulation: Interestingly, the V1-projecting OFC neurons themselves show reduced firing during reward expectation (specifically, when anticipating reward in "hit" trials or no reward in "false alarm" trials), which is opposite to the modulation seen in V1. This suggests a complex interplay where OFC signals prepare V1 for expected outcomes.
  • OFC-V1 Pathway is Essential for Learning: While inactivating the OFC-V1 projection didn't affect immediate performance, it significantly impaired the learning of the Go/No-Go task, specifically the ability to correctly reject the No-Go stimulus. Conversely, activating SST interneurons in V1 (which are targeted by OFC projections) improved learning.

Key Results

  • Optogenetic activation of OFC projections to V1 significantly reduced V1 firing rates in both anesthetized and awake mice (P < 10⁻⁵).
  • This suppression was mediated by local SST interneurons in V1, as evidenced by fiber photometry data showing increased SST activity upon OFC stimulation.
  • In a Go/No-Go task, V1 responses to the No-Go stimulus were lower in correct rejection (CR) trials compared to false alarm (FA) trials, and this modulation was reduced by OFC inactivation.
  • V1-projecting OFC neurons showed decreased firing in FA trials compared to CR trials, indicating an outcome-expectancy modulation opposite to V1.
  • Chronic inactivation of the OFC projection to V1 significantly slowed the learning of the Go/No-Go task (demonstrated by a slower increase in CR rate and discriminability).
  • Chronic activation of SST interneurons in V1 improved the learning of the Go/No-Go task.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Immediate Performance vs. Learning: The study highlights a dissociation between immediate task performance and learning. Inactivation of the OFC-V1 projection did not affect immediate performance but impaired learning. The authors suggest that the OFC-V1 pathway might contribute to learning by influencing future trials rather than the current one, or by providing feedback to the OFC itself.
  • Generalizability: While the study focuses on visual associative learning, the authors suggest that the OFC's top-down projections to other sensory cortices might play similar roles in associative learning across different modalities.
  • Specific Circuitry: While SST interneurons were identified as key mediators, further investigation into the precise downstream targets of SST interneurons within V1 and their specific roles could be explored.
  • Role of Other OFC Projections: The study focuses on the OFC projection to V1. The OFC also projects to other brain areas involved in learning and reward processing, and understanding how these parallel pathways interact with the V1 projection would be a valuable future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

The orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) encodes expected outcomes and plays a critical role in flexible, outcome-guided behavior. The OFC projects to primary visual cortex (V1), yet the function of this top-down projection is unclear. We find that optogenetic activation of OFC projection to V1 reduces the amplitude of V1 visual responses via the recruitment of local somatostatin-expressing (SST) interneurons. Using mice performing a Go/No-Go visual task, we show that the OFC projection to V1 mediates the outcome-expectancy modulation of V1 responses to the reward-irrelevant No-Go stimulus. Furthermore, V1-projecting OFC neurons reduce firing during expectation of reward. In addition, chronic optogenetic inactivation of OFC projection to V1 impairs, whereas chronic activation of SST interneurons in V1 improves the learning of Go/No-Go visual task, without affecting the immediate performance. Thus, OFC top-down projection to V1 is crucial to drive visual associative learning by modulating the response gain of V1 neurons to non-relevant stimulus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020orbitofrontal,
  author = {Dechen Liu and Juan Deng and Zhewei Zhang and Zhiyu Zhang and Yan-Gang Sun and Tianming Yang and Haishan Yao},
  title = {{Orbitofrontal control of visual cortex gain promotes visual associative learning}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-16609-7},
}
Figure