Optimizing Energy Harvesting Decode-and-Forward Relays With Decoding Energy Costs and Energy Storage

Yanxin Yao, Zhengwei Ni, Wanqiu Hu, Mehul MotaniIEEE Access 2021 · OpenReview

In the world of the Internet of Things (IoT), energy is the ultimate currency. Energy Harvesting (EH) relays—devices that extract power from ambient radio waves to pass along data—are a promising way to extend network reach without the need for traditional batteries. However, most theoretical models make a dangerous assumption: that decoding data is "free."

A recent paper published in IEEE Access by Yao et al. challenges this notion, providing a rigorous framework for optimizing relays that must pay an energy tax for every bit they decode. By accounting for the significant energy cost required to decode incoming signals, the authors provide a more realistic model for low-power IoT infrastructure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In traditional relaying research, the focus is typically on the energy needed to transmit a signal. But for low-power IoT devices, the energy consumed by the circuitry to decode a message (the "decoding cost") can be just as high as the transmission cost.

Furthermore, real-world relays don't just get energy from a single source. They might harvest from a dedicated transmitter (intentional) and ambient RF noise (random). Most existing studies look at a single "time block," but energy and data can be stored and used later. The challenge addressed here is: How do you balance time spent harvesting, receiving, and forwarding across multiple time blocks when the energy supply is random and decoding isn't free?

System model of the EH relay network showing energy and data flow.

Methods

The authors employ a Harvest-Receive-Forward (HRF) time-switching architecture. As shown in the system model, the relay includes a decoding unit, a data buffer, and a battery for energy storage. Each time block is split into three distinct phases:

  1. Harvesting: Collecting energy from the transmitter and ambient environment.
  2. Reception: Decoding data (and paying the associated energy cost).
  3. Forwarding: Sending data to the destination.
The Harvest-Receive-Forward (HRF) time-switching protocol.

To solve the resulting non-convex optimization problem, the authors used a series of analytical techniques:

  • Decoupling: They broke the multi-block problem into a single-block problem by introducing two auxiliary variables representing the "residual" energy and data left in the buffers.
  • Linear Transformation: They transformed the complex objective into a linear programming problem. This allows the system to be solved with polynomial-time complexity, making it computationally efficient to find the optimal settings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Decoding Tax: The energy cost of decoding is modeled as an increasing convex function of the bit rate. The faster you try to decode, the disproportionately more energy you burn.
  • The "Constant Rate" Phenomenon: One of the most surprising findings is that the optimal reception rate ($R^*$) remains unchanged regardless of how much ambient energy is available. Instead of changing how fast it decodes, a smart relay simply changes how long it spends in the harvesting vs. receiving phases.
  • Storage Strategy: The paper proves that energy storage is mandatory to handle ambient RF sources efficiently, but data storage is not strictly necessary to achieve maximum throughput. You can reach the mathematical optimum even if you forward all decoded data within the same block.
  • Saturation Point: There is a "diminishing returns" point for ambient energy. Once the relay harvests enough to cover its decoding and forwarding costs for the maximum possible time, extra energy doesn't help because the relay has run out of time in the block to use it.

Key Results

Numerical simulations verified the theoretical derivations, showing significant performance impacts:

  • Throughput Gains: In a scenario with a dedicated 8mW transmitter, adding ambient energy harvesting increased the average throughput from 3.57 Mbps to 6.35 Mbps (a ~78% increase) once the ambient source reached saturation.
  • Stability: The optimal reception rate was found to be consistently 14.36 Mbps across various scenarios, proving that the hardware's decoding efficiency and the channel capacity are the primary drivers of the "sweet spot" for rate, not the fluctuating energy supply.
  • Multi-block Efficiency: The proposed algorithm successfully schedules energy use across blocks, "smoothing out" the randomness of ambient RF to maintain steady performance.

Limitations and Future Work

The current model assumes "slow fading" channels, where signal strength is stable between blocks. In high-mobility scenarios, such as a relay on a moving vehicle, "fast fading" would require more complex optimization. Additionally, the model assumes no direct link between the source and destination; future work could explore combining direct and relayed signals for even better performance.

Reference: Y. Yao, Z. Ni, W. Hu and M. Motani, "Optimizing Energy Harvesting Decode-and-Forward Relays With Decoding Energy Costs and Energy Storage," in IEEE Access, vol. 9, pp. 96613-96628, 2021.

Summary updated

Abstract

Energy harvesting (EH) relay communication systems with decoding energy costs in multiple block cases have not been widely studied. This paper investigates the relay network with a decode-and-forward relay powered by EH. Unlike other works, we consider the relay with energy decoding costs which harvests random energy from both a dedicated transmitter and other ambient radio-frequency (RF) sources. The EH relay adopts a harvest-receive-forward time-switching architecture. We optimize the time fractions of the three phases and the reception rate at the relay to maximize the offline throughput for single and multiple block cases under two EH scenarios. The multi-block optimization problem constitutes a complex non-convex problem, which we decouple into a single block problem with two auxiliary variables determined by an outer optimization problem. The original problem is finally solved at the cost of linear optimization after series of tricks. Several conclusions are derived: (i) energy storage is necessary (unnecessary) when the relay harvests energy from the transmitter (ambient RF sources), (ii) the optimal reception rate remains unchanged, while the optimal time fractions vary with the energy harvested from ambient RF sources leading to different average throughput. We give numerical simulations to verify our theoretical analysis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yao2021optimizing,
  author = {Yanxin Yao and Zhengwei Ni and Wanqiu Hu and Mehul Motani},
  title = {{Optimizing Energy Harvesting Decode-and-Forward Relays With Decoding Energy Costs and Energy Storage}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=aQkh3vnwBRj},
}
Figure