Optimization simulation of reflow welding based on prediction of regional center temperature field

Yuan Sui, Fan-yang Bu, Zi-long Shao, Wei Yan

Abstract: Before reflow soldering of integrated electronic products, the numerical simulation of the temperature control curve is crucial for selecting proper parameters and improving overall efficiency and product quality. This paper derives a first-order ordinary differential equation (ODE) for the central temperature curve of the welding area based on heat conduction laws and specific heat capacity. To model the furnace environment, a Sigmoid function is employed for smooth transitions in small-temperature-difference gaps, while a linear combination of exponential and primary functions is used for large-temperature-difference gaps. By calculating the mean square error between predicted and real temperature fields, optimal process parameters are identified. The simulation results demonstrate high consistency with actual sensor data, providing a robust framework for optimizing production processes and solder joint quality.

Introduction

In modern electronics manufacturing, reflow soldering is the critical stage where components are permanently bonded to printed circuit boards (PCBs). Achieving the correct temperature profile is a high-stakes balancing act: excessive heat can damage sensitive components, while insufficient heat leads to "cold" joints that compromise structural integrity.

Traditionally, engineers determine furnace settings through a tedious "guess-and-check" process using "golden boards" equipped with sensors. This method is not only time-consuming and wasteful but also lacks a theoretical basis for true optimization. This research proposes a mathematical model to predict the temperature field with high precision, allowing for digital optimization before physical production begins.

Schematic of a reflow furnace showing the different temperature zones and the conveyor path.

As shown in Figure 1, a reflow furnace consists of multiple heating zones—preheating, soaking, and reflow—followed by a cooling zone. The PCB travels through these zones on a conveyor belt, and its temperature must stay within a strict "process window" defined by specific heating rates, peak temperatures, and time above the solder's melting point.

Methodology

1. The Mathematical Model

The researchers developed a model based on the fundamental laws of heat conduction. They derived a first-order ODE to describe the temperature change of the welding area ($f(x)$) relative to the furnace's internal temperature distribution ($T(x)$):

$$\frac{df}{dx} = \frac{Q}{v} [T(x) - f(x)]$$

In this equation, $v$ represents the conveyor speed, and $Q$ is the "welding coefficient," a parameter that encapsulates the thermal properties of the specific board and its components.

2. Modeling the Furnace Environment

A significant challenge in simulation is accurately modeling the temperature in the gaps between heating zones. The authors introduced two mathematical approaches:

  • Small Gaps: A Sigmoid function is used to create smooth transitions between zones with similar temperature settings.
  • Large Gaps: For the sharp drop-off into the cooling zone, a linear combination of exponential and primary functions captures the "concave" nature of rapid cooling.

3. Optimization Strategies

With a validated simulation, the authors designed three strategies to find optimal process parameters:

  • Speed Interval Prediction: Identifying the maximum conveyor speed that maintains all safety and quality constraints.
  • Minimum Melting Area: Minimizing the duration the solder spends above its melting point (typically 217°C) to reduce thermal stress.
  • Symmetrical Melting Area: Ensuring the heating and cooling phases around the peak temperature are balanced, which is known to produce more stable and reliable solder joints.

Results and Validation

The model was validated using experimental data from a furnace with 11 distinct temperature zones. By iterating through different values of the welding coefficient ($Q$), the researchers found that $Q = -0.021$ provided the best fit for the experimental setup.

Comparison of predicted temperature curves for different welding coefficients (Q) against experimental data.

As illustrated in Figure 5, the predicted curve for $Q = -0.021$ (the dashed line) almost perfectly tracks the experimental sensor data (the solid cyan line). The simulation achieved a Pearson correlation coefficient of over 0.99, indicating an extremely high degree of accuracy in capturing both the complex heating ramps and the rapid cooling phases.

Conclusion

This predictive modeling approach offers a significant advancement over traditional trial-and-error methods in reflow soldering. By treating the complex thermal properties of a PCB as a single tunable coefficient ($Q$), the model remains computationally efficient while staying physically grounded. This method allows manufacturers to optimize for specific reliability goals, reduce equipment commissioning time, and ultimately improve the quality of electronic products. Future work may involve integrating these models into real-time automated control systems for even greater production precision.

Summary updated

Abstract

Before reflow soldering of integrated electronic products, the numerical simulation of temperature control curve of reflow furnace is crucial for selecting proper parameters and improving the overall efficiency of reflow soldering process and product quality. According to the heat conduction law and the specific heat capacity formula, the first-order ordinary differential equation of the central temperature curve of the welding area with respect to the temperature distribution function in the furnace on the conveyor belt displacement is obtained. For the gap with small temperature difference, the sigmoid function is used to obtain a smooth interval temperature transition curve; For the gap with large temperature difference, the linear combination of exponential function and primary function is used to approach the actual concave function, so as to obtain the complete temperature distribution function in the furnace. The welding parameters are obtained by solving the ordinary differential equation, and a set of optimal process parameters consistent with the process boundary are obtained by calculating the mean square error between the predicted temperature field and the real temperature distribution. At the same time, a set of reflow optimization strategies are designed for speed interval prediction strategy, minimum parameter interval prediction strategy, and the most symmetrical parameter interval prediction of solder paste melting reflow area. The simulation results show that the temperature field prediction results obtained by this method are highly consistent with the actual sensor data, and have strong correlation. This method can help to select appropriate process parameters, optimize the production process, reduce equipment commissioning practice and optimize the solder joint quality of production products.
BibTeX
@misc{sui2022optimization,
  author = {Yuan Sui and Fan-yang Bu and Zi-long Shao and Wei Yan},
  title = {{Optimization simulation of reflow welding based on prediction of regional center temperature field}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2206.10119},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.10119},
}
Figure