Abstract
There are many algorithms for regret minimisation in episodic reinforcement learning. This problem is well-understood from a theoretical perspective, providing that the sequences of states, actions and rewards associated with each episode are available to the algorithm updating the policy immediately after every interaction with the environment. However, feedback is almost always delayed in practice. In this paper, we study the impact of delayed feedback in episodic reinforcement learning from a theoretical perspective and propose two general-purpose approaches to handling the delays. The first involves updating as soon as new information becomes available, whereas the second waits before using newly observed information to update the policy. For the class of optimistic algorithms and either approach, we show that the regret increases by an additive term involving the number of states, actions, episode length, the expected delay and an algorithm-dependent constant. We empirically investigate the impact of various delay distributions on the regret of optimistic algorithms to validate our theoretical results.
Introduction
Most theoretical breakthroughs in episodic Reinforcement Learning (RL) rely on a "perfect world" assumption: at the end of every episode, the agent immediately observes the full sequence of states, actions, and rewards. In reality, this is rarely the case. In medical settings, a doctor might not observe a patient's response to a treatment for weeks. In e-commerce, a recommendation might not result in a conversion until days later. Even in robotics, the heavy computation required to update a policy may occur on a separate server, creating a communication lag.
When feedback is delayed, the agent is forced to continue acting using a "stale" policy. This paper addresses a critical gap in the literature: quantifying how much this staleness impacts performance and determining if standard optimistic algorithms can still guarantee near-optimal behavior under these conditions.
Methodology: Active vs. Lazy Updating
The authors propose two general-purpose "meta-algorithms" designed to adapt almost any optimistic model-based RL algorithm (the "base algorithm") for delayed environments:
- Active Updating: The agent updates its policy the moment any new piece of feedback arrives. This is the most intuitive approach, ensuring the agent uses information as soon as it is available.
- Lazy Updating: The agent waits until it has collected a significant "batch" of new data before triggering a policy update. This is controlled by a doubling trick (using a hyperparameter $\alpha$) to decide when the new information is substantial enough to justify a re-calculation.
While Active Updating is more responsive, Lazy Updating is often more computationally efficient and allows for cleaner mathematical proofs by creating "simulated non-delayed" epochs.
Theoretical Analysis
The core of the research is a theoretical analysis using regret decomposition. The authors prove that for a wide class of optimistic algorithms, the "regret" (the difference between the agent's performance and that of an optimal agent) only increases by an additive term proportional to the expected delay.
Key theoretical insights include:
- Additive vs. Multiplicative Regret: Unlike previous approaches that suggested delays might cause multiplicative regret (slowing the entire learning process), this work shows the penalty is merely additive. The agent "pays" for the delay initially, but the long-term learning rate remains stable.
- Independence from Delay Distribution: A surprising finding is that the expected delay ($\mathbb{E}[\tau]$) is the primary driver of regret, rather than the specific shape of the delay distribution (e.g., Poisson vs. Geometric).
- No Prior Knowledge Needed: These meta-algorithms do not require advance knowledge of the maximum possible delay to function effectively.
Empirical Results
The methods were evaluated using the Chain Environment, a classic deep exploration benchmark where an agent must navigate a sequence of $S$ states to reach a single rewarding state. Any incorrect move returns the agent to the start, making it a rigorous test for exploration efficiency under delay.
Experiments yielded several key findings:
- Performance: Active Updating consistently showed the lowest cumulative regret. However, Lazy Updating with a high update frequency ($\alpha=100$) performed nearly identically.
- Comparison to Baselines: Both proposed methods significantly outperformed the "Explicit Exploration" baseline, which requires knowing the maximum delay and suffers from a slow initial exploration phase.
- Scaling: The theoretical bounds were validated, showing the delay penalty scales with $H^2 S A \mathbb{E}[\tau]$, where $H$ is episode length, $S$ is the number of states, and $A$ is the number of actions.
Conclusion and Future Work
This paper demonstrates that optimistic RL algorithms are robust to feedback delays, suffering only an additive regret penalty. While the current analysis focuses on model-based algorithms and independent, identically distributed (i.i.d.) delays, it provides a strong foundation for future research. Potential avenues include extending these proofs to model-free algorithms (like Q-learning) and exploring scenarios where delays are adversarial or dependent on the agent's actions.
Summary updated